Re: JESS: Jess Manners Benchmark with Java Implementation
Attached... I ran these quite some time ago for most rulebased Java engines. Kochhar, Gaurav wrote: Hi, I am trying to create a Benchmark for finalizing a Rule Engine in our Company. We need rule engine for a J2EE based application. I already ran the pumps application in Jess examples. As a standard Benchmark with couple of other rule engines we chose Miss Manners. Could you point me to a JAVA implementation of Miss Manners in Jess? I did find a Miss Manners implementation using C but I need it for Java. Thanks Gaurav -Original Message- From: friedman_hill ernest j [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Thursday, September 02, 2004 3:46 PM To: Kochhar, Gaurav Subject: Re: Welcome to jess-users To post to the list, send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED]. I think Kochhar, Gaurav wrote: I just subscribed to the jess-mailing list. How do I post a question on this mailing list?? -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Thursday, September 02, 2004 2:54 PM To: Kochhar, Gaurav Subject: Welcome to jess-users -- Welcome to the jess-users mailing list! Please save this message for future reference. Thank you. If you ever want to remove yourself from this mailing list, you can send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with the following command in the body of your email message: unsubscribe jess-users or from another account, besides [EMAIL PROTECTED]: unsubscribe jess-users [EMAIL PROTECTED] If you ever need to get in contact with the owner of the list, (if you have trouble unsubscribing, or have questions about the list itself) send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] . This is the general rule for most mailing lists when you need to contact a human. Here's the general information for the list you've subscribed to, in case you don't already have it: [Last updated on: Fri Nov 9 9:00:29 2001] The jess-users list is for discussion of Jess, the rule engine for the Java platform, from Sandia National Laboratories. - Ernest Friedman-Hill Advanced Software Research Phone: (925) 294-2154 Sandia National LabsFAX: (925) 294-2234 PO Box 969, MS 9012 [EMAIL PROTECTED] Livermore, CA 94550 http://herzberg.ca.sandia.gov To unsubscribe, send the words 'unsubscribe jess-users [EMAIL PROTECTED]' in the BODY of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED], NOT to the list (use your own address!) List problems? Notify [EMAIL PROTECTED]. -- SDG jco "Do No Evil. Do Only Good Things. See the good in every one. Always keep learning. Teach those who want to be taught. Avoid fools at all costs. Harm No One, Except to Defend Yourself, Or to Defend Another. Kill No One, Except to Keep From Being Killed, Or to Keep Another From Being Killed." CafeBabe 1210151411101114 CLASSPATH=/home/ejfried/Jess61p5 java -server -XX:NewSize=16m -Xms32m -Xmx32m jess.Main manners.clp ( guest (name 1 ) (sex m ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 1 ) (sex m ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 1 ) (sex m ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 1 ) (sex m ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 2 ) (sex f ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 2 ) (sex f ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 2 ) (sex f ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 2 ) (sex f ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 2 ) (sex f ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 3 ) (sex f ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 3 ) (sex f ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 3 ) (sex f ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 4 ) (sex m ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 4 ) (sex m ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 4 ) (sex m ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 4 ) (sex m ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 5 ) (sex m ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 5 ) (sex m ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 5 ) (sex m ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 6 ) (sex f ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 6 ) (sex f ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 6 ) (sex f ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 6 ) (sex f ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 6 ) (sex f ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 7 ) (sex f ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 7 ) (sex f ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 7 ) (sex f ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 7 ) (sex f ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 8 ) (sex m ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 8 ) (sex m ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 9 ) (sex m ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 9 ) (sex m ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 9 ) (sex m ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 9 ) (sex m ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 10 ) (sex m ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 10 ) (sex m ) (hobby 3) ) ( guest (name 10 ) (sex m ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 10 ) (sex m ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 10 ) (sex m ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 11 ) (sex m ) (hobby 2) ) ( guest (name 11 ) (sex m ) (hobby 4) ) ( guest (name 11 ) (sex m ) (hobby 5) ) ( guest (name 11 ) (sex m ) (hobby 1) ) ( guest (name 12 ) (sex f )
JESS: Jess Manners Benchmark with Java Implementation
Hi, I am trying to create a Benchmark for finalizing a Rule Engine in our Company. We need rule engine for a J2EE based application. I already ran the pumps application in Jess examples. As a standard Benchmark with couple of other rule engines we chose Miss Manners. Could you point me to a JAVA implementation of Miss Manners in Jess? I did find a Miss Manners implementation using C but I need it for Java. Thanks Gaurav -Original Message- From: friedman_hill ernest j [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 02, 2004 3:46 PM To: Kochhar, Gaurav Subject: Re: Welcome to jess-users To post to the list, send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] I think Kochhar, Gaurav wrote: I just subscribed to the jess-mailing list. How do I post a question on this mailing list?? -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Thursday, September 02, 2004 2:54 PM To: Kochhar, Gaurav Subject: Welcome to jess-users -- Welcome to the jess-users mailing list! Please save this message for future reference. Thank you. If you ever want to remove yourself from this mailing list, you can send mail to [EMAIL PROTECTED] with the following command in the body of your email message: unsubscribe jess-users or from another account, besides [EMAIL PROTECTED]: unsubscribe jess-users [EMAIL PROTECTED] If you ever need to get in contact with the owner of the list, (if you have trouble unsubscribing, or have questions about the list itself) send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] . This is the general rule for most mailing lists when you need to contact a human. Here's the general information for the list you've subscribed to, in case you don't already have it: [Last updated on: Fri Nov 9 9:00:29 2001] The jess-users list is for discussion of Jess, the rule engine for the Java platform, from Sandia National Laboratories. - Ernest Friedman-Hill Advanced Software Research Phone: (925) 294-2154 Sandia National LabsFAX: (925) 294-2234 PO Box 969, MS 9012 [EMAIL PROTECTED] Livermore, CA 94550 http://herzberg.ca.sandia.gov To unsubscribe, send the words 'unsubscribe jess-users [EMAIL PROTECTED]' in the BODY of a message to [EMAIL PROTECTED], NOT to the list (use your own address!) List problems? Notify [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: JESS: Jess Manners Benchmark with Java Implementation
I think Kochhar, Gaurav wrote: Hi, I am trying to create a Benchmark for finalizing a Rule Engine in our Company. We need rule engine for a J2EE based application. I already ran the pumps application in Jess examples. As a standard Benchmark with couple of other rule engines we chose Miss Manners. Could you point me to a JAVA implementation of Miss Manners in Jess? I did find a Miss Manners implementation using C but I need it for Java. The manners benchmark itself is never implemented in C nor in Java, but in the rule language of a particular rule engine. I've attached the files manners.clp and mann128.dat, which together comprise the benchmark for Jess with problem size 128. What *is* commonly implemented in C is a little program called manner_data, which generates different versions of the data file mannXXX.dat for different problem sizes. It has to be customized for each rule engine, as the data file contains facts in the rule engine's own format. I don't have a Java implementation, but it's a trivial little program, and it would be fairly easy to whip one up. If anybody wants to do it, I'll find it a home on the web. - Ernest Friedman-Hill Advanced Software Research Phone: (925) 294-2154 Sandia National LabsFAX: (925) 294-2234 PO Box 969, MS 9012 [EMAIL PROTECTED] Livermore, CA 94550 http://herzberg.ca.sandia.gov ;; Deftemplates (deftemplate guest (slot name) (slot sex) (slot hobby)) (deftemplate last_seat (slot seat)) (deftemplate seating (slot id) (slot pid) (slot seat1) (slot name1) (slot name2) (slot seat2) (slot path_done)) (deftemplate path (slot id) (slot name) (slot seat)) (deftemplate chosen (slot id) (slot name) (slot hobby)) (deftemplate count (slot c)) (deftemplate context (slot state)) (defrule assign_first_seat ?ctxt - (context (state start)) (guest (name ?n)) ?count - (count (c ?c)) = (assert (seating (seat1 1) (name1 ?n) (name2 ?n) (seat2 1) (id ?c) (pid 0) (path_done yes))) (assert (path (id ?c) (name ?n) (seat 1))) (modify ?count (c (+ ?c 1))) (printout t seat 1 ?n ?n 1 ?c 0 1 crlf) (modify ?ctxt (state assign_seats))) (defrule find_seating ?ctxt - (context (state assign_seats)) (seating (seat1 ?seat1) (seat2 ?seat2) (name2 ?n2) (id ?id) (pid ?pid) (path_done yes)) ;; ** ;; *** Uncomment this line for the cheat version ;; (not (seating (path_done yes) (seat2 ?s2:( ?s2 ?seat2 ;; ** (guest (name ?n2) (sex ?s1) (hobby ?h1)) (guest (name ?g2) (sex ~?s1) (hobby ?h1)) ?count - (count (c ?c)) (not (path (id ?id) (name ?g2))) (not (chosen (id ?id) (name ?g2) (hobby ?h1))) = (assert (seating (seat1 ?seat2) (name1 ?n2) (name2 ?g2) (seat2 (+ ?seat2 1)) (id ?c) (pid ?id) (path_done no))) (assert (path (id ?c) (name ?g2) (seat ( + ?seat2 1 (assert (chosen (id ?id) (name ?g2) (hobby ?h1))) (modify ?count (c (+ ?c 1))) (printout t seat ?seat2 ?n2 ?g2 crlf) (modify ?ctxt (state make_path))) (defrule path_done ?ctxt - (context (state make_path)) ?seat - (seating (path_done no)) = (modify ?seat (path_done yes)) (modify ?ctxt (state check_done))) (defrule make_path (context (state make_path)) (seating (id ?id) (pid ?pid) (path_done no)) (path (id ?pid)(name ?n1) (seat ?s)) (not (path (id ?id) (name ?n1))) = (assert (path (id ?id) (name ?n1) (seat ?s (defrule continue ?ctxt - (context (state check_done)) = (modify ?ctxt (state assign_seats))) (defrule are_we_done ?ctxt - (context (state check_done)) (last_seat (seat ?l_seat)) (seating (seat2 ?l_seat)) = (printout t crlf Yes, we are done!! crlf) (modify ?ctxt (state print_results)) ) (defrule print_results (context (state print_results)) (seating (id ?id) (seat2 ?s2)) (last_seat (seat ?s2)) ?path - (path (id ?id) (name ?n) (seat ?s)) = (retract ?path) (printout t ?n ?s crlf)) (defrule all_done (context (state print_results)) = (halt)) (set-reset-globals t) (defglobal ?*t* = (time)) ;; (readline) (reset) (batch mann128.dat) (printout t (run) crlf) (printout t Elapsed time: (- (time) ?*t*) crlf) (exit) (assert (guest (name 1) (sex f) (hobby 3))) (assert (guest (name 1) (sex f) (hobby 1))) (assert (guest (name 1) (sex f) (hobby 5))) (assert (guest (name 1) (sex f) (hobby 2))) (assert (guest (name 2) (sex m) (hobby 5))) (assert (guest (name 3) (sex f) (hobby 1))) (assert (guest (name 3) (sex f) (hobby 2))) (assert (guest (name 3) (sex f) (hobby 5))) (assert (guest (name 3) (sex f) (hobby 3))) (assert (guest (name 3) (sex f) (hobby 4))) (assert (guest (name 4) (sex f) (hobby 1))) (assert (guest (name 4) (sex f) (hobby 2))) (assert (guest (name 4) (sex f) (hobby 5))) (assert (guest (name 4) (sex f)
