Re: hel-arabic.ly
> \include "hel-arabic.ly"
> \version "2.23.3"
> \relative {
> \key c \rast
> c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
> }
You must have done something wrong; I've just downloaded the 2.24.3
binary bundle for GNU/Linux, and this code compiles fine – this means
that it works for previous versions, too.
The changes to `hel-arabic.ly` happened in version 2.25.2; earlier
versions are *not* affected.
Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
I installed lilypond-2.23.6-1 ,lilypond-2.24.3 and lilypond-2.25.13:
for each version I do : LilyPond rast.ly
for the unstable version it's normal hel-arabic has been truncated.
I would like to point out that my initial version of hel-arabic.ly that I am
using is functional.
I tested them with file : rast.ly =>
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\version "2.23.3"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
\version "2.24.3" and \version "2.25.13"
It doesn't work, for any version of the 3 versions tested
You can do the test yourself: create a file, name it rast.ly, put this in
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\version "2.23.3"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
Then lilypond rast.ly
you must obtain the following file: rast.pdf
Once again it's not for me. my version of hel-arabic.ly that I use, works well
even with version 2.18.1
thanks very match
Hassan
rast.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
Re: hel-arabic.ly
> I did some tests on version 2.24.3, 2.21.0-1 , 2.23.6-1 > > it doesn't work either. What *exactly* did you do? Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
hello again I did some tests on version 2.24.3, 2.21.0-1 , 2.23.6-1 it doesn't work either. hassan
Re: hel-arabic.ly
> for rast.ly
>
> \include "hel-arabic.ly"
> \version "2.25.13"
> \relative {
> \key c \rast
> c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
> }
>
> Tmust give rast.pdf , But that's not the case
Of course not. You are using the current development version without
my fix. Again: please have a look at
https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests/2268
and try the code from this MR.
Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
> > This should ensure full backward compatibility if you process your
> > old files with `convert-ly`.
>
> Which file?
Any input file that uses `hel-arabic.ly`.
Example:
```
\version "2.24.0"
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
```
If you process this with `convert-ly`, you get
```
\version "2.25.13"
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\language "arabic"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
```
and this output compiles fine with the patch from
https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests/2268
applied. Please look at this MR and comment.
Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
> \include "hel_arabic.ly" It's `hel-arabic.ly`, not `hel_arabic.ly`. Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
for rast.ly
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\version "2.25.13"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
Tmust give rast.pdf , But that's not the case
rast.pdf
Description: Adobe PDF document
Re: hel-arabic.ly
lilypond rast.ly =>
GNU LilyPond 2.25.13 (running Guile 3.0)
Traitement de « rast.ly »
Analyse...
rast.ly:5:8: Erreur : « edb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d
edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:20: Erreur : « bdb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a
bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:28: Erreur : « eb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a bdb c |
eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:39: Erreur : « edb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f |
edb d c
Interprétation en cours de la musique...
Pré-traitement des éléments graphiques...
Détermination du nombre optimal de pages...
Répartition de la musique sur une page...
Dessin des systèmes...
Conversion à « rast.pdf »...
erreur fatale : erreur sur les fichiers "rast.ly"
file : rast.ly
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\version "2.25.13"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
Re: hel-arabic.ly
I have this :
lilypond rast.ly
=>
GNU LilyPond 2.25.13 (running Guile 3.0)
Traitement de « rast.ly »
Analyse...
rast.ly:1:10: Erreur : fichier non trouvé : « hel_arabic.ly »
(chemin de recherche : «
/home/helfa/lilypond/share/lilypond/2.25.13/ly:/home/helfa/lilypond/share/lilypond/2.25.13/ps:/home/helfa/lilypond/share/lilypond/2.25.13/scm:/home/helfa/lilypond/share/lilypond/2.25.13/fonts/otf/:/home/helfa/lilypond/share/lilypond/2.25.13/fonts/svg/:
»)
\include
"hel_arabic.ly"
rast.ly:4:10: Erreur : unknown command: `\rast'
\key c
\rast
rast.ly:4:10: Erreur : type d'argument erroné pour 2.
Attendait list of number pairs, "rast" trouvé.
\key c
\rast
rast.ly:5:8: Erreur : « edb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d
edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:20: Erreur : « bdb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a
bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:28: Erreur : « eb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a bdb c |
eb a g f | edb d c
rast.ly:5:39: Erreur : « edb » n'est pas un nom de note
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f |
edb d c
Attention : la compilation a échoué et \version est plus que datée ;
la syntaxe de la source a-t-elle été mise à jour par convert-ly ?
https://lilypond.org/doc/v2.25/Documentation/usage/updating-files-with-convert_002dly
Interprétation en cours de la musique...
Pré-traitement des éléments graphiques...
Détermination du nombre optimal de pages...
Répartition de la musique sur une page...
Dessin des systèmes...
Conversion à « rast.pdf »...
erreur fatale : erreur sur les fichiers "rast.ly"
rast.y :
\include "hel_arabic.ly"
\version "2.25.3"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
Re: hel-arabic.ly
hello again
\include "hel_arabic_initial.ly"
\relative {
\key c \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
This should ensure full backward compatibility if you process your old
files with `convert-ly`.
Which file?
This file: \include "hel_arabic.ly" \relative { \key c \rast c' d edb f | g a
bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c }
Doesn't need compatibility
Hassan
Re: hel-arabic.ly
>> [...] Indeed edb and sdb are no longer recognized > > It's not screwed up at all, however, current LilyPond is not > backward compatible. I'm already working on a patch. Please check https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests/2268 This should ensure full backward compatibility if you process your old files with `convert-ly`. Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
On 2024-03-07 09:24, hassan.elfat...@free.fr wrote: by trying to make hel-arabic.ly dependent on arabic.ly without consulting me, you screwed up the hel-arabic.ly file. Neighbor, 1. You contributed to an open-source project. Proposed changes are posted for public review. GitLab sends notifications to those who are subscribed. This mailing list receives a "PATCHES" message with merge-request headlines three times a week. You have had the same opportunity as any other contributor to follow and respond to proposed changes. 2. The command git grep hel-arabic input/regression/ returns no results. If you are interested in reducing the dependence on the vigilance of one or two expert reviewers, consider contributing a test or two to exercise the unique features of hel-arabic.ly such that breaking changes would cause visual differences even non-experts can appreciate. -- Dan
Re: hel-arabic.ly
> In fact it no longer works, I gave the operational version of > hel-arabic.ly and by trying to make hel-arabic.ly dependent on > arabic.ly without consulting me, you screwed up the hel-arabic.ly > file. I can still repair the damage if you give me the opportunity > to do that. Indeed edb and sdb are no longer recognized It's not screwed up at all, however, current LilyPond is not backward compatible. I'm already working on a patch. Werner
Re: hel-arabic.ly
On Thu, 7 Mar 2024, 14:24 , wrote:
>
> \include "hel-arabic.ly"
> \relative {
> \key do \rast
>
Shouldn't this be
\key c \rast
?
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
> }
>
> => rast1.png
>
>
> Hassan
>
Neil
>
Re: hel-arabic.ly
Hello again
In fact it no longer works, I gave the operational version of hel-arabic.ly and
by trying
to make hel-arabic.ly dependent on arabic.ly without consulting me,
you screwed up the hel-arabic.ly file. I can still repair the damage
if you give me the opportunity to do that.Indeed edb and sdb are no longer
recognized
\include "hel-arabic.ly"
\relative {
\key do \rast
c' d edb f | g a bdb c | eb a g f | edb d c
}
=> rast1.png
Hassan
