Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-30 Thread Jean Abou Samra

Le 30/01/2022 à 22:07, Jean Abou Samra a écrit :

Le 30/01/2022 à 18:19, James a écrit :

Documentation and Patch Meister

?



OK. But I see that you just deleted your GitLab account.
Does this mean you no longer intend to contribute? I
was hoping you would stay with us for documentation, bug
triage, etc. Of course, if you are moving on, thank
you for all of your contributions (so not just patch
countdowns), and enjoy what will be next in your life.



I only received the countdown email after sending this.
I've now opened
https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests/1171

Meanwhile, I got an email bounce for the apparently deleted address 
pkx1...@posteo.net. Farewell, James.





Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-30 Thread Jean Abou Samra

Le 30/01/2022 à 18:19, James a écrit :

Hello,

On 29/01/2022 18:00, Jean Abou Samra wrote:

Le 28/01/2022 à 10:49, pkx1...@posteo.net a écrit :
Why don't you do the 'next' countdown (on Jan 30th) while I am still 
about and let me know what problems/questions you had or need to 
understand how to resolve?


That way there is at least some percieved semblance of a hand-over.



One thought in passing: we need to update the Contributor's
Guide as well as http://lilypond.org/authors.html. James,
how should you be called on the latter page?


Documentation and Patch Meister

?




OK. But I see that you just deleted your GitLab account.
Does this mean you no longer intend to contribute? I
was hoping you would stay with us for documentation, bug
triage, etc. Of course, if you are moving on, thank
you for all of your contributions (so not just patch
countdowns), and enjoy what will be next in your life.

All the best,
Jean




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-30 Thread James

Hello,

On 29/01/2022 18:00, Jean Abou Samra wrote:

Le 28/01/2022 à 10:49, pkx1...@posteo.net a écrit :
Why don't you do the 'next' countdown (on Jan 30th) while I am still 
about and let me know what problems/questions you had or need to 
understand how to resolve?


That way there is at least some percieved semblance of a hand-over.



One thought in passing: we need to update the Contributor's
Guide as well as http://lilypond.org/authors.html. James,
how should you be called on the latter page?


Documentation and Patch Meister

?

--
Regards

James




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-29 Thread Jean Abou Samra

Le 28/01/2022 à 10:49, pkx1...@posteo.net a écrit :
Why don't you do the 'next' countdown (on Jan 30th) while I am still 
about and let me know what problems/questions you had or need to 
understand how to resolve?


That way there is at least some percieved semblance of a hand-over.



One thought in passing: we need to update the Contributor's
Guide as well as http://lilypond.org/authors.html. James,
how should you be called on the latter page?

Regards,
Jean




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-29 Thread Jean-Charles Malahieude
Le 08/01/2022 à 12:15, Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on LilyPond 
development a écrit :

Am Samstag, dem 08.01.2022 um 10:06 + schrieb James:

Hello,

I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.

I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be
whatever the last date in January ends up being.

Thanks for your understanding.




Hi James,

Thanks a lot for all you did for helping Lily's development.
Enjoy your new life!

Cheers,
--
Jean-Charles



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-28 Thread Colin Campbell



On 2022-01-28 02:49, pkx1...@posteo.net wrote:

Colin,



Why don't you do the 'next' countdown (on Jan 30th) while I am still 
about and let me know what problems/questions you had or need to 
understand how to resolve?


That way there is at least some percieved semblance of a hand-over.

You may want to do things differently but my starting point (and 
bookmark) for any countdown is


https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/labels



An excellent thought, James, received with thanks!


Cheers,

Colin




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-28 Thread pkx166h

Colin,

On 28/01/2022 09:13, Jonas Hahnfeld wrote:

Am Mittwoch, dem 26.01.2022 um 15:57 -0700 schrieb Colin Campbell:

On 2022-01-26 14:29, pkx1...@posteo.net wrote:

Hello Colin, 

Good morning to you,James!

A couple of quick(ish) questions:

Given a gitlab account, based on this email, do I need formal
permissions within Lilypond?

Yes, IIRC Jonas will need to give you a level of access so you can
comment and change labels of MRs (i.e. move MRs from Patch::review to
Patch::push etc).



Excellent, James; just what I needed. As this is copied to the devel
list, I'm hoping it will serve as my request to Jonas, per the CG.

Done [1]. (Sorry for the slow response from my side, too much going on
around me right now.)

I'm very happy that we've found a volunteer to "take on the job". If
you have any problems with the script or the GitLab interface, feel
free to contact me either on- or off-list. I'm happy to help as best as
I can.

Why don't you do the 'next' countdown (on Jan 30th) while I am still 
about and let me know what problems/questions you had or need to 
understand how to resolve?


That way there is at least some percieved semblance of a hand-over.

You may want to do things differently but my starting point (and 
bookmark) for any countdown is


https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/labels

regards

James




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-28 Thread Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on LilyPond development
Am Mittwoch, dem 26.01.2022 um 15:57 -0700 schrieb Colin Campbell:
> On 2022-01-26 14:29, pkx1...@posteo.net wrote:
> > Hello Colin, 
> > > Good morning to you,James!
> > > 
> > > A couple of quick(ish) questions:
> > > 
> > > Given a gitlab account, based on this email, do I need formal 
> > > permissions within Lilypond?
> > Yes, IIRC Jonas will need to give you a level of access so you can 
> > comment and change labels of MRs (i.e. move MRs from Patch::review to 
> > Patch::push etc).
> > > 
> > > Does "middle green tick" refer to what I see on lilypond/merge 
> > > requests/!?
> > 
> > Yes, if you hover over the middle tick it says 'tests passed'. Click 
> > it and you get taken to a console window where you can see a URL link 
> > near the end of the build output that, when clicked, takes you to the 
> > reg test diffs (if there are any). The back button works OK in gitlab 
> > to take you back to the MR comment section.
> > 
> > I don't bother clicking on the other '2 ticks' (build and doc) but if 
> > for example the first two pass and the third (documentation) fail then 
> > I don't bother even looking at the reg tests as all builds need three 
> > green ticks to progress as a bare minimum.
> > 
> Excellent, James; just what I needed. As this is copied to the devel 
> list, I'm hoping it will serve as my request to Jonas, per the CG.

Done [1]. (Sorry for the slow response from my side, too much going on
around me right now.)

I'm very happy that we've found a volunteer to "take on the job". If
you have any problems with the script or the GitLab interface, feel
free to contact me either on- or off-list. I'm happy to help as best as
I can.

Cheers
Jonas


1: I didn't know that you can invite people based on email, that's
actually nice. Maybe we can put this into the CG, which currently only
mentions sending the username...


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part


Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-26 Thread Colin Campbell



On 2022-01-26 14:29, pkx1...@posteo.net wrote:

Hello Colin, 

Good morning to you,James!

A couple of quick(ish) questions:

Given a gitlab account, based on this email, do I need formal 
permissions within Lilypond?
Yes, IIRC Jonas will need to give you a level of access so you can 
comment and change labels of MRs (i.e. move MRs from Patch::review to 
Patch::push etc).


Does "middle green tick" refer to what I see on lilypond/merge 
requests/!?


Yes, if you hover over the middle tick it says 'tests passed'. Click 
it and you get taken to a console window where you can see a URL link 
near the end of the build output that, when clicked, takes you to the 
reg test diffs (if there are any). The back button works OK in gitlab 
to take you back to the MR comment section.


I don't bother clicking on the other '2 ticks' (build and doc) but if 
for example the first two pass and the third (documentation) fail then 
I don't bother even looking at the reg tests as all builds need three 
green ticks to progress as a bare minimum.


Excellent, James; just what I needed. As this is copied to the devel 
list, I'm hoping it will serve as my request to Jonas, per the CG.



Cheers,

Colin




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-26 Thread pkx166h

Hello Colin,

On 26/01/2022 17:26, Colin Campbell wrote:


On 2022-01-23 09:15, pkx1...@posteo.net wrote:

Colin hi,



Apart from the interface of GitLab and a nice countdown script 
(instead of the old script that was used) it's more or less the same 
process as before. Different developers, different interface. Patch 
testing has been completely automated so all you are doing is viewing 
reg test diffs (middle green tick on the MR, find the link in the cmd 
window and clikc on it in a browser).


All you need is a gitlab login and email.




Good morning to you,James!

A couple of quick(ish) questions:

Given a gitlab account, based on this email, do I need formal 
permissions within Lilypond?
Yes, IIRC Jonas will need to give you a level of access so you can 
comment and change labels of MRs (i.e. move MRs from Patch::review to 
Patch::push etc).


Does "middle green tick" refer to what I see on lilypond/merge 
requests/!?


Yes, if you hover over the middle tick it says 'tests passed'. Click it 
and you get taken to a console window where you can see a URL link near 
the end of the build output that, when clicked, takes you to the reg 
test diffs (if there are any). The back button works OK in gitlab to 
take you back to the MR comment section.


I don't bother clicking on the other '2 ticks' (build and doc) but if 
for example the first two pass and the third (documentation) fail then I 
don't bother even looking at the reg tests as all builds need three 
green ticks to progress as a bare minimum.


Regards

James




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-26 Thread Colin Campbell



On 2022-01-23 09:15, pkx1...@posteo.net wrote:

Colin hi,



Apart from the interface of GitLab and a nice countdown script 
(instead of the old script that was used) it's more or less the same 
process as before. Different developers, different interface. Patch 
testing has been completely automated so all you are doing is viewing 
reg test diffs (middle green tick on the MR, find the link in the cmd 
window and clikc on it in a browser).


All you need is a gitlab login and email.




Good morning to you,James!

A couple of quick(ish) questions:

Given a gitlab account, based on this email, do I need formal 
permissions within Lilypond?


Does "middle green tick" refer to what I see on lilypond/merge 
requests/!?



Cheers,

Colin




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-23 Thread pkx166h

Colin hi,

On 22/01/2022 22:32, Colin Campbell wrote:


On 2022-01-08 03:06, James wrote:

Hello,

I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.

I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be 
whatever the last date in January ends up being.


Thanks for your understanding.



Since James took over from me when I left the fold six years ago, 
perhaps I can return the favour now. Fair warning: I left at the start 
of what seems to have been a period of significant change, so I'm 
rather out of touch with current terms ("patch" as I knew it is now 
"merge request"?). With some coaching, and lashings of patience from 
the devs, I'm willing to take it on.



Apart from the interface of GitLab and a nice countdown script (instead 
of the old script that was used) it's more or less the same process as 
before. Different developers, different interface. Patch testing has 
been completely automated so all you are doing is viewing reg test diffs 
(middle green tick on the MR, find the link in the cmd window and clikc 
on it in a browser).


All you need is a gitlab login and email.

James




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-23 Thread pkx166h

Hello,

On 22/01/2022 22:12, Carl Sorensen wrote:

James,

How much time do you spend per week as Patch Meister?


I spend about 15-20 mins every 2 days. I don't review code, I just check 
reg tests (pasting those that are new or changed significantly) I also 
make sure all threads that are still unresolved are either really 
unresolved or just not closed (in the latter case I don't close threads 
myself but will comment to make sure that the relevant parties know 
there is a thread that looks like it is still TBD). I don't send 
personal emails but do everything via GitLab so that all can see responses.


The original cadence was 4 days but that was when we had far fewer 
active developers. It has only moved to 2 days because of the regularity 
of MRs and patches.


I sometimes deliberately make the cadence longer if there are many 
patches in the three queues so that everyone gets a chance.


So Log in, look at the MRs in countdown (and change them to push / leave 
them or move them down, i.e. to review) then I look at MRs in review and 
move them to countdown (or if there is still ongoig discussion I will 
leave it there) and finally I look at MRs in 'new' and check reg tests 
and set them to review.


So I start at the top so to speak and work down. (Coutdown/review/new). 
Pushing everything up one step and out to patch Push.


I then use the 'countdown.py' script in the infrastructure repo that 
generates the list you see in the emails. I add the date of the 
countdown in the subject of the email and change the 'next countdown 
date' in the body and then just send the email to dev.


My general rule is any patch in review that is less than 24 hours old 
stays there (i.e. doesn't get moved on). I rely on developers that 
resubmit patches, depending on where it was in the queue to either set 
it back to the new/review queue or state in a note why they don;t think 
it needs to start back at review again.


I try to avoid the 'this is trivial we should push this now' comment 
because after all unless it is something that is affecting release, it's 
only 48 hours before the next countdown. Some developers tend to be 
impatient and I just ilke to make sure everyone gets to comment.


No comment in a thread is the same as a LGTM. This saves me having to 
wait for people to approve explicitly every MR.


Sometimes I see a thread in a MR that is not going anywhere and no one 
is replying or making a decision, so I will comment in the thread that 
something must be done and if after the next countdown nothing has 
changed I will 'do something' (be it set it to push or set it to needs 
work) as that usually generates some attention. But some MRs have been 
known to sit in 'review' for multiple countdowns and even at 'countdown' 
until it is obvious that something needs to change. I just state why it 
has not been moved (reference a comment for example) and then teh 
developer can tell me why I am wrong or why X needs to wait or why Y can 
be ignored. I always defer to the developers.


It's more or less just shuffling papers and checking reg tests with a 
bit of comment and running the countdown script that I paste into the email.


Hope that helps.

James




If the time requirement is manageable, I could step in.  I don't have lots of 
time to spend on Lilypond (hence my lack of current development work), but I  
could plan to spend some.

Please help me understand the time you spend.

Carl


On 1/22/22, 11:09 AM, "lilypond-devel on behalf of Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on 
LilyPond development"  wrote:

 Am Donnerstag, dem 13.01.2022 um 22:42 +0100 schrieb David Kastrup:
 > Kevin Barry  writes:
 >
 > > Hi James,
 > >
 > > This is a big loss; you will be missed. Thank you for all of your hard 
work.
 > >
 > > > I want to stay a
 > > > developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
 > > > impartiality.
 > >
 > > Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
 > > would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.
 >
 > git shortlog --author Lowe
 >
 > should be some indication that this is not a conflict of interest as
 > such.  It may end up a conflict of resources.
 
 Yes, my initial message wasn't entirely clear, it's of course possible

 to contribute patches while being "Patch Meister". The "impartiality"
 aspect is that you should try to apply the same standards to your own
 submissions as to all other patches.
 
 So, there's around one week left until the end of January and this

 thread has more or less died down, thus last call for volunteers.
 
 Jonas
 





Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-23 Thread Jean Abou Samra




Le 22/01/2022 à 23:32, Colin Campbell a écrit :


On 2022-01-08 03:06, James wrote:

Hello,

I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.

I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be 
whatever the last date in January ends up being.


Thanks for your understanding.



Since James took over from me when I left the fold six years ago, 
perhaps I can return the favour now. Fair warning: I left at the start 
of what seems to have been a period of significant change, so I'm 
rather out of touch with current terms ("patch" as I knew it is now 
"merge request"?). With some coaching, and lashings of patience from 
the devs, I'm willing to take it on.




Awesome!

Yes, there has been quite a bit of change to the
processes used in the project. We are now hosted
on GitLab (instead of SourceForge and Rietveld).
“Merge requests” are here:

https://gitlab.com/lilypond/lilypond/-/merge_requests

You can find issues in the same place.

There is also a Continuous Integration (automated
testing) system that runs make, make check and make doc
on every merge request. This no longer has to be done
manually or by Patchy. The test results are found in
a link at the bottom of every make check run. When a
developer passes on the merge request (whether the author,
the Patch Meister or someone else) and finds the tests
to look good, they can paste screenshots in the merge
request (for easier review) and advance it to Review
(tagging with the appropriate label on GitLab,
Patch::review). The Patch Meister is the only one to
advance to Patch::countdown and Patch::push.

I think these would be the main differences in the
countdown process, but I wasn't there six years ago.
You may want to read the current CG, which normally
should be up-to-date with these processes.

By the way: glad to meet you!

Cheers,
Jean




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-22 Thread Colin Campbell



On 2022-01-08 03:06, James wrote:

Hello,

I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.

I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be 
whatever the last date in January ends up being.


Thanks for your understanding.



Since James took over from me when I left the fold six years ago, 
perhaps I can return the favour now. Fair warning: I left at the start 
of what seems to have been a period of significant change, so I'm rather 
out of touch with current terms ("patch" as I knew it is now "merge 
request"?). With some coaching, and lashings of patience from the devs, 
I'm willing to take it on.



Cheers,

Colin





Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-22 Thread Carl Sorensen
James,

How much time do you spend per week as Patch Meister?

If the time requirement is manageable, I could step in.  I don't have lots of 
time to spend on Lilypond (hence my lack of current development work), but I  
could plan to spend some.

Please help me understand the time you spend.

Carl


On 1/22/22, 11:09 AM, "lilypond-devel on behalf of Jonas Hahnfeld via 
Discussions on LilyPond development" 
 wrote:

Am Donnerstag, dem 13.01.2022 um 22:42 +0100 schrieb David Kastrup:
> Kevin Barry  writes:
> 
> > Hi James,
> > 
> > This is a big loss; you will be missed. Thank you for all of your hard 
work.
> > 
> > > I want to stay a
> > > developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
> > > impartiality.
> > 
> > Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
> > would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.
> 
> git shortlog --author Lowe
> 
> should be some indication that this is not a conflict of interest as
> such.  It may end up a conflict of resources.

Yes, my initial message wasn't entirely clear, it's of course possible
to contribute patches while being "Patch Meister". The "impartiality"
aspect is that you should try to apply the same standards to your own
submissions as to all other patches.

So, there's around one week left until the end of January and this
thread has more or less died down, thus last call for volunteers.

Jonas




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-22 Thread Jean Abou Samra

Le 22/01/2022 à 20:31, Han-Wen Nienhuys a écrit :

On Sat, Jan 22, 2022 at 7:09 PM Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on
LilyPond development  wrote:

Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.

git shortlog --author Lowe

should be some indication that this is not a conflict of interest as
such.  It may end up a conflict of resources.

Yes, my initial message wasn't entirely clear, it's of course possible
to contribute patches while being "Patch Meister". The "impartiality"
aspect is that you should try to apply the same standards to your own
submissions as to all other patches.

So, there's around one week left until the end of January and this
thread has more or less died down, thus last call for volunteers.

One thought: maybe we could rotate the patch meister between different
volunteers? That would also help with the impartiality: if one is this
week's patch meister, you could simply leave your own MRs alone.



Maybe James can comment here. Without ever having
done these countdowns, my instinctive reaction is that
it might work well, but it might also mean a bit more
work at each countdown because you have to read
the threads from the start if you haven't been
following them on the previous countdown.

Personally, while I'd be ready to do the countdowns if
necessary, I'd prefer not to hold that responsibility
on the long term because I tend to be somewhat too
emotional with patches already.

Also, one advantage of the countdown is that it
enables someone without any technical experience
to advance the project, thus freeing time for
programmers. It has not been true with James
that this has allowed someone to participate
who would not have participated otherwise, given
all his valuable documentation contributions,
but there might be an opportunity to take now
for finding someone who would not be in a position
to immediately contribute in another way.

Perhaps we could ask on the user list? Not sure
how bug squad members were recruited when
that existed, but lilypond-user would appear
like the place where we have the best chances
of finding new people ready to get involved.

Jean




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-22 Thread Han-Wen Nienhuys
On Sat, Jan 22, 2022 at 7:09 PM Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on
LilyPond development  wrote:
> > > Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
> > > would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.
> >
> > git shortlog --author Lowe
> >
> > should be some indication that this is not a conflict of interest as
> > such.  It may end up a conflict of resources.
>
> Yes, my initial message wasn't entirely clear, it's of course possible
> to contribute patches while being "Patch Meister". The "impartiality"
> aspect is that you should try to apply the same standards to your own
> submissions as to all other patches.
>
> So, there's around one week left until the end of January and this
> thread has more or less died down, thus last call for volunteers.

One thought: maybe we could rotate the patch meister between different
volunteers? That would also help with the impartiality: if one is this
week's patch meister, you could simply leave your own MRs alone.

-- 
Han-Wen Nienhuys - hanw...@gmail.com - http://www.xs4all.nl/~hanwen



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-22 Thread Han-Wen Nienhuys
On Sat, Jan 8, 2022 at 11:07 AM James  wrote:
> I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.
>
> I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be
> whatever the last date in January ends up being.
>
> Thanks for your understanding.

Thanks for your tireless work over the many years!  Your persistent
shepherding certainly has helped many contributions land that would
have otherwise languished.

-- 
Han-Wen Nienhuys - hanw...@gmail.com - http://www.xs4all.nl/~hanwen



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-22 Thread Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on LilyPond development
Am Donnerstag, dem 13.01.2022 um 22:42 +0100 schrieb David Kastrup:
> Kevin Barry  writes:
> 
> > Hi James,
> > 
> > This is a big loss; you will be missed. Thank you for all of your hard work.
> > 
> > > I want to stay a
> > > developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
> > > impartiality.
> > 
> > Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
> > would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.
> 
> git shortlog --author Lowe
> 
> should be some indication that this is not a conflict of interest as
> such.  It may end up a conflict of resources.

Yes, my initial message wasn't entirely clear, it's of course possible
to contribute patches while being "Patch Meister". The "impartiality"
aspect is that you should try to apply the same standards to your own
submissions as to all other patches.

So, there's around one week left until the end of January and this
thread has more or less died down, thus last call for volunteers.

Jonas


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part


Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-13 Thread David Kastrup
Kevin Barry  writes:

> Hi James,
>
> This is a big loss; you will be missed. Thank you for all of your hard work.
>
>> I want to stay a
>> developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
>> impartiality.
>
> Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
> would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.

git shortlog --author Lowe

should be some indication that this is not a conflict of interest as
such.  It may end up a conflict of resources.

-- 
David Kastrup



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-13 Thread Kevin Barry
Hi James,

This is a big loss; you will be missed. Thank you for all of your hard work.

> I want to stay a
> developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
> impartiality.

Finding a non-developer to fill James's shoes sounds difficult. I
would volunteer, but I still plan to contribute patches.

Kevin



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-08 Thread Jean Abou Samra

Le 08/01/2022 à 11:06, James a écrit :

Hello,

I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.

I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be 
whatever the last date in January ends up being.


Thanks for your understanding.



You definitely deserve a ton of thanks. I was already
amazed at your perseverance and regularity in this
task, and I hadn't realized you had been doing it for
so long. Thank you for keeping the project running
during all these years.




As said before off-list, thanks a lot for all the work you've been
doing. I had a look at the mailing list archives and it appears you
started doing the countdowns in February 2013, almost nine years ago.
Your contributions reach back further than that (including testing of
patches, not sure) and in any case that's an incredible time span!

This also means we need to do at least one of two things:
a) find a new person to take on the Patch Meister role and continue
doing the countdowns,
b) think about and agree on a "new" process to decide when patches can
be pushed / merged.

I personally like the countdown process for a number of reasons (as a
contributor, it's nice to have a human "on the other side", and for
reviewers it's relieving to have some amount of grace period). In the
event that we have neither a) nor b) by the end of January, I can offer
to take the role temporarily to "keep things going". That said, I'm
definitely not a good fit in the longer term because I want to stay a
developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
impartiality.



I also appreciate the current process. It ensures
contributions from new contributors without commit
access are not forgotten about and sets clear
expectations for the moment at which a patch can
be merged. If we can find another person for it,
that would be ideal in my view.

Best,
Jean




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-08 Thread Werner LEMBERG


> As said before off-list, thanks a lot for all the work you've been
> doing.

Yes. Thanks, James!


Werner



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-08 Thread Dan Eble
On Jan 8, 2022, at 05:06, James  wrote:
> 
> I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.
> 

Thanks for the many years of steady contribution, James.
— 
Dan




Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-08 Thread Thomas Morley
Am Sa., 8. Jan. 2022 um 11:06 Uhr schrieb James :
>
> Hello,
>
> I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.
>
> I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be
> whatever the last date in January ends up being.
>
> Thanks for your understanding.
>
> --
> Regards
>
> James
>

Hi James,

thanks a lot for all your work!
You did a fabulous job!

Best,
  Harm



Re: Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-08 Thread Jonas Hahnfeld via Discussions on LilyPond development
Am Samstag, dem 08.01.2022 um 10:06 + schrieb James:
> Hello,
> 
> I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.
> 
> I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be 
> whatever the last date in January ends up being.
> 
> Thanks for your understanding.

As said before off-list, thanks a lot for all the work you've been
doing. I had a look at the mailing list archives and it appears you
started doing the countdowns in February 2013, almost nine years ago.
Your contributions reach back further than that (including testing of
patches, not sure) and in any case that's an incredible time span!

This also means we need to do at least one of two things:
a) find a new person to take on the Patch Meister role and continue
doing the countdowns,
b) think about and agree on a "new" process to decide when patches can
be pushed / merged.

I personally like the countdown process for a number of reasons (as a
contributor, it's nice to have a human "on the other side", and for
reviewers it's relieving to have some amount of grace period). In the
event that we have neither a) nor b) by the end of January, I can offer
to take the role temporarily to "keep things going". That said, I'm
definitely not a good fit in the longer term because I want to stay a
developer and that conflicts both time-wise and with respect to
impartiality.

If you have thoughts on b), I'd suggest starting a new thread on the
mailing list.

Regards
Jonas


signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part


Stepping down from Patch Meister role

2022-01-08 Thread James

Hello,

I am going to stop doing the Patch countdown at the end of this month.

I'll continue for the next few weeks, but my last countdown will be 
whatever the last date in January ends up being.


Thanks for your understanding.

--
Regards

James