Re: Rousseau's boustrophedon notation [but OT, really]

2024-02-24 Thread Kieren MacMillan
Hi Aaron,

Rather incredibly, I had never heard of the word “boustrophedon” and this is 
the second reference in just under a week! The first time was when someone 
asked me (last week) whether there was a perfect rhyme for “anthropomorphic” — 
the only one I could find was “boustorphic” (which derives from the same root 
as boustrophedon).

I know about the frequency illusion bias (a.k.a. Baader–Meinhof phenomenon), 
but I honestly don’t think this is that.  :)

Cheers,
Kieren.

> On Feb 23, 2024, at 4:55 PM, Aaron Hill  wrote:
> 
> Just read a side note on Wikipedia about a supposed "boustrophedon" notation. 
>  The citation does not link to the image in question, which is an unfortunate 
> oversight.  I was curious whether this approach applied only to Rousseau's 
> numeric notation or if it was intended to work with standard notation.  I 
> suspect his numeric notation is more vulnerable to misreading as it would be 
> harder to jump from the end of one line to the beginning of the next.
> 
> It seems like LilyPond could theoretically support this by alternately 
> reflecting every other system, assuming the intention is to mirror image all 
> symbols in the right-to-left systems.
> 
> Does anyone have more details about this?



RE: Rousseau's boustrophedon notation

2024-02-23 Thread carsonmark
Aaron,

One in Arabic:
https://www.quora.com/Musical-notation-is-written-from-left-to-right-but-Ara
bic-is-written-from-right-to-left-How-is-it-possible-to-show-the-words-and-m
usic-for-songs-in-Arabic
One for mixed quintette:
https://www.sheetmusicdirect.com/en-US/se/ID_No/552679/Product.aspx

Mark

-Original Message-
From: lilypond-user-bounces+carsonmark=ca.rr@gnu.org
 On Behalf Of Aaron Hill
Sent: Friday, February 23, 2024 1:55 PM
To: lilypond-user 
Subject: Rousseau's boustrophedon notation

Just read a side note on Wikipedia about a supposed "boustrophedon" 
notation.  The citation does not link to the image in question, which is an
unfortunate oversight.  I was curious whether this approach applied only to
Rousseau's numeric notation or if it was intended to work with standard
notation.  I suspect his numeric notation is more vulnerable to misreading
as it would be harder to jump from the end of one line to the beginning of
the next.

It seems like LilyPond could theoretically support this by alternately
reflecting every other system, assuming the intention is to mirror image all
symbols in the right-to-left systems.

Does anyone have more details about this?


-- Aaron Hill




Rousseau's boustrophedon notation

2024-02-23 Thread Aaron Hill
Just read a side note on Wikipedia about a supposed "boustrophedon" 
notation.  The citation does not link to the image in question, which is 
an unfortunate oversight.  I was curious whether this approach applied 
only to Rousseau's numeric notation or if it was intended to work with 
standard notation.  I suspect his numeric notation is more vulnerable to 
misreading as it would be harder to jump from the end of one line to the 
beginning of the next.


It seems like LilyPond could theoretically support this by alternately 
reflecting every other system, assuming the intention is to mirror image 
all symbols in the right-to-left systems.


Does anyone have more details about this?


-- Aaron Hill