Re: Don't mess with the PASTHRU semantics.

2003-08-14 Thread Alan Burlison
Michael G Schwern wrote:

Here's my official stance on the whole PASTHRU issue:  Don't fuck with it.
Not like this, rushing it into 5.8.1.  Sure, Tk's happy but its not the
only module out there.  I haven't had a chance to evaluate other large,
complex modules and what effect it will have on them.  I haven't had a
chance to look through CPAN to see how people are using PASTHRU_* if
at all.
Leave it be.  If it gets rushed into 5.8.1, something's going to break
because of it.  Its been broken for a long time, it can wait.  After 5.8.1
we'll take a stab at fixing it, Steve's problem is not urgent enough to
risk breaking other modules.  You can always install a new version of MM 
later, but you can't patch everyone's copy of 5.8.1 if you introduce
a new bug.

Conservative?  Hell yes, but its MakeMaker and its a maintenance release.
I'm inclined to agree with this... but then I'm pretty risk averse ;-)

--
Alan Burlison
--


Re: Don't mess with the PASTHRU semantics.

2003-08-08 Thread Ken Williams
On Thursday, August 7, 2003, at 10:27  PM, Michael G Schwern wrote:
Leave it be.  If it gets rushed into 5.8.1, something's going to break
because of it.  Its been broken for a long time, it can wait.  After 
5.8.1
we'll take a stab at fixing it, Steve's problem is not urgent enough to
risk breaking other modules.
I agree, the right time to try fixing something like this is right 
*after* a release like 5.8.1, not right before.

 -Ken