[Marxism] The truth about Syria

2017-09-02 Thread Michael Yates via Marxism
  POSTING RULES & NOTES  
#1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
#2 This mail-list, like most, is publicly & permanently archived.
#3 Subscribe and post under an alias if #2 is a concern.
*

This Facebook post is stated with remarkable clarity. Geopolitics are 
important, but they can only take us so far. Many on the left give lip service 
to democracy and popular uprisings, but they don't really believe what they 
say. I remember arguing with colleagues at college about postwar Vietnam. They 
were going on and on about the plight of the boat people. They didn't seem to 
grasp that when a nation's people are slaughtered, even under the best of 
circumstances (the Vietnamese liberation was, after all, due to the North 
Vietnamese communists and their allies in the NLF), radical democracy is 
unlikely to flourish and those who had aided the enemy unlikely to be treated 
with compassion. What government could do this and survive? Matters will be 
much worse when the government, such as it is, is run by a fascist murderer 
like Assad. And given the circumstances, isn't it likely that fanatics would 
have soon enough emerged, irrespective of any US efforts to crush them. Extreme 
misery n
 ever brings out the best in people. Of course, the US has never cared, and 
still doesn't, if Assad stays in power. It surely has never wanted a real 
democracy to flourish anywhere in the world.
_
Full posting guidelines at: http://www.marxmail.org/sub.htm
Set your options at: 
http://lists.csbs.utah.edu/options/marxism/archive%40mail-archive.com


[Marxism] The truth about Syria

2017-09-01 Thread Louis Proyect via Marxism

  POSTING RULES & NOTES  
#1 YOU MUST clip all extraneous text when replying to a message.
#2 This mail-list, like most, is publicly & permanently archived.
#3 Subscribe and post under an alias if #2 is a concern.
*

Usman Butt on FB:

The truth is Syria is finished as a country. That's the reality that 
nobody is willing to admit to. The Syrian army has fallen to bits and 
can scarcely be called an army anymore. There is no economy, limited 
electricity, health system has been decimated and state infrastructure 
has been pounded to the point of near collapse. The only thing 
sustaining the idea of Syria were the Syrian people, but now for the 
sake of the political survival of one man, the people have been crushed 
and their place has been taken by disaster capitalists from Iran and Russia.


Places like Damascus were among the oldest continual inhabited cities in 
the world, pre-Islamic civilisation built great cultural, political and 
intellectual centres. The arrival of Islam expanded upon this and 
cemented the reputation of the land as holy for billions today. 50 years 
of Ba'athists rule, 17 years of Assad rule, Syria has reached a new low, 
it is barely fit enough to call itself a brothel. 17 years of 'secular' 
Assadist rule, 470,000 dead, 11 million displaced (including 6 million 
refugees at least), 60,000 in prisons/internment camps and a trillion 
dollars worth of damage is all his regime has to show for itself.
The country will be ruled by a mishmash of different militias whose 
loyalty to the Assad regime will begin to wane as they increasingly 
don't see the need for him and want to grab more power for themselves by 
attacking other militias loyal to Assad. A civil war between the 
different loyalist militias will erupt. Iran and Russia will come to 
blows in Syria (via proxy) as their agendas begin to diverge. Al Qaeda 
and the next generation of ISIS will find a permanent home in Syria, 
radicalisation caused by Assad's supposed victory will create fertile 
ground for the next generation of Jihadis. Sectarianism will intensify 
and soon nobody will be able to control any of the militias. The Iraqi 
Shia militias operating in Syria will increasingly break from Tehran and 
will openly disobey Iraqi clerics they currently have loyalty too, as 
the aggressive radicalisation of the group members intensifies to new 
levels. What they will morph into should be of great international concern.


Syria educated and connected middle class facing the spectacle of more 
war and corruption will continue to leave the country and invest abroad. 
Iran and Russia will be unable to reconstruct Syria as their economies 
are far too weak.


Assad's 'victory' is also the victory for normalised Islamophobia, which 
will farther alienate Western Muslims who are still in the eye of the 
storm of Islamophobia. Most western Muslims don't realise that the 
inaction of western states to support liberated Syria, the decision to 
support Assad by other states, is rooted in the deepening entrenchment 
of Islamophobia in the international system. Right wing groups, the 
popular mood in various country, and left wing movements, are all 
reflecting this growing problem. While they might have different 
attitudes towards Muslims, Syria has created a shared well of 
Islamophobia for both the left and right to drink from. Of course ISIS 
and Al Qaeda loves this as Assad's 'victory' grantees their future and 
no amount of 'this doesn't represent Islam' is going to get us out of 
this problem.


Only the people of Syria could have saved us from this fate. But instead 
we chose comfortable lies and have condemned them and us to a new cycle 
of violence.

_
Full posting guidelines at: http://www.marxmail.org/sub.htm
Set your options at: 
http://lists.csbs.utah.edu/options/marxism/archive%40mail-archive.com