Songs don't explain it; they just slide the register. The problem is
associative - sound with action/object, more or less along the lines of
proto-language. Given that there would be fuzzy symbols associated with
fuzzy meanings, and gestures associated with the same, it doesn't seem a
far cry from this to simple sounds associated with these other registers.
So there are bee stings, indicating a hive; one notices it, others notice,
the swelling is associated with bee/hive, it's there written on the body,
and I think that given communal behaviour that a sounding - just a grunt
for example - would be associated, and passed on accordingly. The issue is
then the differentiation of sounds; this would be different modulations as
information is transmitted to those who didn't see the sting in the first
place, or those who wanted to recall it. Language on this level isn't all
that much different from alarm-calls of animals and birds, which can also
be somewhat specific; the difference is in the relative plasticity of
primate behaviour coupled with the body already as palimsest. I hope I'm
not begging the issue here by the way.
In relation to singing, field calls were used in the manner you describe,
and I certainly think that the register of singing is important here - for
example humming or cooing to an infant; I think that primates might also
do this. The issue for me is the leap into language, written or spoken -
in other words, the leap into the symbolic, which seems qualitatively
different between hominids and other primates or animals. Or further,
given that all animals possess culture (which I believe), how did this
'leap' - whatever it is - evolve?
- Alan
On Tue, 5 Sep 2006, Michael H Goldhaber wrote:
Alan's account seems plausible, but still leaves question of where spoken
language came from. My earlier thought has been that singing was the
essential step. Different songs for different activities would then lead,
implicitly and directly to verbs. My back is turned but I hear the eating
song or the chipping song, or the running song and I know what that other is
doing. Nouns arise as verbs that go with persons or things.
...
blog at http://nikuko.blogspot.com - for URLs, DVDs, CDs, books/etc. see
http://www.asondheim.org/advert.txt - contact [EMAIL PROTECTED], -
general directory of work: http://www.asondheim.org
Trace at: http://tracearchive.ntu.ac.uk - search Alan Sondheim
http://clc.as.wvu.edu:8080/clc/Members/sondheim
# distributed via nettime: no commercial use without permission
# nettime is a moderated mailing list for net criticism,
# collaborative text filtering and cultural politics of the nets
# more info: [EMAIL PROTECTED] and info nettime-l in the msg body
# archive: http://www.nettime.org contact: nettime@bbs.thing.net
