Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-21 Thread Martin Klingensmith



Darryl McMahon wrote:

 I know there are motors called brushless DC, but for my purposes these are 
 effectively AC motors.  There are also universal motors, which can run on AC 
 or DC, 
 but in effect, these are AC motors with brushes, and seldom are found in 
 sizes 
 above 1/2 hp.

Hi Darryl, I saw an article in IEEE Spectrum just last week about the 
new US military prototype humvee hybrid. It has a 50kW PM BLDC in each hub.

-- 
--
Martin Klingensmith
http://infoarchive.net/
http://nnytech.net/


 Yahoo! Groups Sponsor -~--
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com. Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US  Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/FGYolB/TM
-~-

Biofuel at Journey to Forever:
http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html

Biofuels list archives:
http://infoarchive.net/sgroup/biofuel/

Please do NOT send Unsubscribe messages to the list address.
To unsubscribe, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Yahoo! Groups Links

* To visit your group on the web, go to:
 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuel/

* To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
 http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 




Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-20 Thread Hakan Falk


Darryl,

At 14:43 19/03/2004, you wrote:
snip
Picking the right size AC or heat pump unit for a house is difficult 
(based on
correct scientific and mathematical formulae), which is why those in the 
trade rely
on rules of thumb.

The problem arise when the thumb replaces the brain. Empirical dimensioning 
served the humanity well, it is the revenual (new word) dimensioning that 
causes the problems.

And the rules of thumb almost always are based on the worst
case (slightly overestimate the area of the building, assume worst 
orientation to
the sun, no shade, no thermal mass, maximum human occupancy... )  Because 
it is
cheaper for the installer to put in too large a unit (the home owner pays 
for the
extra size, and the inefficiency of the unit) than to have to come back, 
remove the
unit that has turned out to be too small (perhaps only once and in a 
completely
unusual situation) and replace it with a larger one.  So long as energy 
prices
remain cheap and hidden (one hydro bill for 60 days at a time, provided to 
the
customer a full month after that period is over, for the entire building) 
instead
of realistic and up front (appliance-based readouts, instantaneous and 
with logs),
given my experience with human nature, I don't see much hope for change 
with the
mass of consumers.  To borrow a phrase from my business consulting days, 
you can't
manage what you can't measure.  It certainly applies to our energy 
consumption.

It seems almost innate, we try to maximize what we can measure or sense.  Put
somebody in a conventional gasoline-powered car today, equipped with a 
speedometer
and little else in the way of instrumentation, they will drive to maximize 
speed.
Put in instrumentation that displays fuel economy (e.g. the Prius hybrid 
or a
Chryser New Yorker I owned a long time ago), and people start to drive to 
maximize
fuel economy.

Your point makes sense.

snip


Hakan





 Yahoo! Groups Sponsor -~--
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com. Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US  Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/FGYolB/TM
-~-

Biofuel at Journey to Forever:
http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html

Biofuels list archives:
http://infoarchive.net/sgroup/biofuel/

Please do NOT send Unsubscribe messages to the list address.
To unsubscribe, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Yahoo! Groups Links

* To visit your group on the web, go to:
 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuel/

* To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
 http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 




Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-19 Thread Hakan Falk


MM,

I thought that I was loosing this very interesting issue. Regarding links 
of appliances, we can revisit SunDanzer.

http://www.sundanzer.com/PDF/SunDanzer_Batt_Free_Tech_Sh.pdfhttp://www.sundanzer.com/PDF/SunDanzer_Batt_Free_Tech_Sh.pdf
 


At the beginning they say The unit operates using a variable speed 
compressor, peak power tracking, thick insulation, and a internal thermal 
storage to optimize cooling efficiency.. They are actually describing what 
I have been saying so many times. It works for fridges and it works for 
large office buildings. The large efficiency gains are not because it runs 
from solar panel, because if it ran from a AC driven AC to DC converter, it 
would still be a very efficient fridge and outperform most fridges in the 
market with large margin, in the very worst case using 10W more. The large 
gains are from variable output and control methods. Then it have added 
insulation and thermal storage, instead of charging batteries, also very 
smart and necessary for a solar only driven unit.

http://www.toshiba-aircon.co.uk/products/flysheets/DIGITAL%20INVERTER%20BROCHURE.PDF
 


http://www.aar.co.nz/brands/toshiba.html

http://www.eastsiderefrigeration.co.nz/Heat_Pumps.shtml
Look at Inverter Technology.

http://www.fujitsugeneral.co.jp/english/new/spl/spl.html

http://www.infineon.com/cmc_upload/migrated_files/document_files/Others/Airconbrochure-2.pdf
 


http://www.bdt.co.nz/comfortmaster/apps.asp

http://www.bdt.co.nz/comfortmaster/apps.asp

Search for air conditioner inverter technology or variants, you get a lot 
of non US sites. I was surprised about that.

They are using a lot of marketing BS, but it is simple - DC driven 
compressor - and control to utilize it.
I already explained how it worked. Have been used in large computer room AC 
systems for years, were it important to keep both temperature and humidity 
within certain limits. It is so long time ago, that I encountered the 
technology, that I do not remember when. Only needed development of 
consumer products.

As I said ready for use energy saving and maybe a silver bullet type of 
technology. Have been there and known for many years, not a new and exiting 
technology, only a technology that does the job..

They say that the purchase price is around 10% of the life time cost, so 
you can easily claim that the first you buy would be paid back by savings 
in 3 to 5 years. VERY GOOD INVESTMENT IN ENERGY EFFICIENCY !

Hakan


At 00:35 19/03/2004, you wrote:
I'm not sure what you're talking about as far as offending anyone, so
I don't think there's any danger of that, except that to some extent
we get off-topic.

Could I please ask you to go over this a bit more:

 My belief is that variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and
 heat pumps, are very important. These (up to 30% savings), together with
 CFL lamps (more than 60% savings), are probably the closest we can come to
 simple silver bullet and ready for use saving technologies, in
 domestic  electricity use.

When you say variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and
heat pumps, what are you saying?  That variable output DC engines
are a potential 30% savings *over* comparable AC units, or they can be
'part of' the technology inside of AC units?

I just want to make sure I understand precisely what you're saying
here.  Maybe you could provide a link to an example appliance?  A lot
of work, I know.




 Yahoo! Groups Sponsor -~--
Buy Ink Cartridges or Refill Kits for your HP, Epson, Canon or Lexmark
Printer at MyInks.com.  Free s/h on orders $50 or more to the US  Canada.
http://www.c1tracking.com/l.asp?cid=5511
http://us.click.yahoo.com/mOAaAA/3exGAA/qnsNAA/FGYolB/TM
-~-

Biofuel at Journey to Forever:
http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html

Biofuels list archives:
http://infoarchive.net/sgroup/biofuel/

Please do NOT send Unsubscribe messages to the list address.
To unsubscribe, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Yahoo! Groups Links

* To visit your group on the web, go to:
 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuel/

* To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
 http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 




Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-19 Thread Darryl McMahon

Actually Hakan, I thought you pretty much covered the topic for electric motors 
at 
a high level.  For me, the AC vs. DC decision comes down to what each one is 
good 
at.  I have some experience with the subject (and the electric vehicles and 
appliances from antique to modern to back that up).

AC motors strengths.
No brushes, for reduced maintenance, and reduced drag.
Best in low torque, fixed-speed, relatively constant load operation.  
Work-around 
for demands with high start torque is to use a capacitor start.  So, with some 
good 
design work around sizing, they should be good for things like refrigerator 
compressors and furnace fans (with the capacitor start), and also cooling fans, 
pumps, rotisseries, clocks, etc.
AC motors weaknesses.
Providing efficient operation at varying speeds and loads requires modifying 
frequency in conjunction with voltage and current in non-linear fashion, a 
complex 
control issue.  Therefore, varying loads and speeds are a headache for AC 
control.  
Certainly can't just hook it up to the mains and expect reasonable operation 
and 
efficiency.

DC motors strengths.
Several configurations available, series, shunt, compound, separately excited, 
which can be tailored to meet specific load and speed requirements.  Typically 
can 
handle heavy starting torque demands quite easily.  Varying speed and load 
fairly 
easy by simply controlling voltage.
DC motors weaknesses.
Brushes reduce efficiency, increase maintenance.

I know there are motors called brushless DC, but for my purposes these are 
effectively AC motors.  There are also universal motors, which can run on AC or 
DC, 
but in effect, these are AC motors with brushes, and seldom are found in sizes 
above 1/2 hp.

So, if you want your electric motor to operate efficiently, the most important 
things are to pick the right type of motor for the job to be done, then pick 
the 
right size for the expected load, then focus on getting a quality unit that 
will 
reduce operational losses.

In my opinion, in most commercial appliances, the motor and control are usually 
not 
the main focus for efficiency gains.  Outside of mass-produced automotive 
units, 
motor efficiencies will exceed 85% in their specified operational range.  
Better 
than 90% is not unusual.  Especially in household applications, where lack of 
efficiency is expressed as objectionable noise and heat, there is an incentive 
for 
manufacturers to keep those losses to a minimum.  (In automobiles, there is 
already 
so much heat and noise being produced that the amounts coming from electric 
motors 
simply is not noticed, so the standards are lower.)  

For example, in the case of a refrigerator or freezer, it would probably make 
more 
sense (energy saved per dollar invested) to improve/increase the insulation in 
the 
refrigerator to reduce heat infiltration, and improve the seal of the door(s) 
to 
reduce air exchange.

Where DC motors in refrigerators were deemed to be more efficient than AC 
motors, 
my analysis concluded that the gains actually came from operating the unit from 
batteries rather than mains (AC) power, or the refrigerator was smaller 
(because 
battery power, usually off-grid, is more precious than mains power), or the 
unit 
was better insulated and sealed (again to meet the different needs and values 
of 
off-grid customers).  In areas that get more insolation than we do, it usually 
turned out to be cheaper to buy an additional solar panel, an extra battery and 
an 
efficient, relatively small, mass-market refrigerator (one that would qualify 
for 
an Energy Star rating now) than to buy one of the specialty, hyper-efficient 
DC-
powered refrigerators developed for the off-grid market.  (The analysis assumed 
there would already be an inverter in the household that could be used.)

Now, you probably wished you had killed the thread. grin

Darryl McMahon
(off to do some sewing on an antique Pfaff sewing machine - the kind where the 
foot-
powered treadle was replaced by a small electric motor with a pulley to the 
same 
pulley driven by the treadle)

To: biofuel@yahoogroups.com
From:   Hakan Falk [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Date sent:  Thu, 18 Mar 2004 22:31:38 +0100
Subject:Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity 
storage
solutions.
Send reply to:  biofuel@yahoogroups.com

 
 MM,
 
 I seams to have done it again! Killed off a very interesting discussion.
 
 I do not know if I maybe am to abusive or what is wrong? Not good for me 
 and the goals that I thought that I was championed. If I offended you or 
 anyone else, I must apologize to both you and the list, but I hoped that 
 this could lead to an important energy saving discussion.
 
 My belief is that variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and 
 heat pumps, are very important. These (up to 30% savings), together with 
 CFL lamps (more than 60% savings), are probably the closest

Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-19 Thread Hakan Falk
was better insulated and sealed (again to meet the different needs and 
values of
off-grid customers).  In areas that get more insolation than we do, it 
usually
turned out to be cheaper to buy an additional solar panel, an extra 
battery and an
efficient, relatively small, mass-market refrigerator (one that would 
qualify for
an Energy Star rating now) than to buy one of the specialty, 
hyper-efficient DC-
powered refrigerators developed for the off-grid market.  (The analysis 
assumed
there would already be an inverter in the household that could be used.)

Now, you probably wished you had killed the thread. grin

Darryl McMahon
(off to do some sewing on an antique Pfaff sewing machine - the kind where 
the foot-
powered treadle was replaced by a small electric motor with a pulley to 
the same
pulley driven by the treadle)

To:   biofuel@yahoogroups.com
From: Hakan Falk [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Date sent:Thu, 18 Mar 2004 22:31:38 +0100
Subject:  Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: 
Electricity storage
   solutions.
Send reply to:biofuel@yahoogroups.com

 
  MM,
 
  I seams to have done it again! Killed off a very interesting discussion.
 
  I do not know if I maybe am to abusive or what is wrong? Not good for me
  and the goals that I thought that I was championed. If I offended you or
  anyone else, I must apologize to both you and the list, but I hoped that
  this could lead to an important energy saving discussion.
 
  My belief is that variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and
  heat pumps, are very important. These (up to 30% savings), together with
  CFL lamps (more than 60% savings), are probably the closest we can come to
  simple silver bullet and ready for use saving technologies, in
  domestic  electricity use.
 
  Hakan
 
 
  At 02:44 17/03/2004, you wrote:
 
  MM,
  
  Before we get too exited about savings by using DC instead of AC, we might
  look at where and why we have this large differences in the energy use by
  appliances. Let us first establish the fact that a conversion as such, 
 will
  cost us between 3 to 10%, depending on method, size and application.
  
  When you talk about appliances, we should also include the AC/Heat pump
  unit in this and very large savings can be done. The losses are more
  created by the use of electrical engines/compressors, than by the use of
  alternate current or direct current. The large differences in energy use
  does not come from the type of current, but from the way the capacity
  control is done. The revelation control in AC engine used in the 
 appliances
  is governed by the fixed AC frequency and the capacity control is done by
  starting and stopping the compressor. The revelation control in the DC
  engine is governed by voltage/current and the capacity control is done by
  varying the speed/force of the engine.  Since you already are very 
 familiar
  with electrical engines, you are probably ahead of me now, about the
  consequences of the different methods. I will anyway mention that the
  consequences can be somewhere between 30 to 45% more energy use by the
  capacity control of the AC engine. After the conversation losses, we 
 end up
  with around 25-30% difference in energy use for appliances.
  
  In the past it was very large differences cost and durability between the
  AC and DC engines, in favor to the AC engines. By new development, these
  differences are no longer an critical issue and the energy use have 
 started
  to be the absolute critical issue for certain engine applications.
  
  If you look at losses in distribution of DC, we must agree with the much
  higher efficiency of AC. One very important issue is also the security
  aspects, which more or less totally disqualifies high voltage DC in homes
  and for general use in appliances. It is better and more manageable of
  security design, if the conversion is done in the appliance and close to
  the engine. The large loss of lives, that a general high voltage DC
  distribution would cause, is not worth it.
  
  Hakan
  
  
  At 22:13 16/03/2004, you wrote:
   On Mon, 15 Mar 2004 23:48:36 -0800 (PST), you wrote:
   

Monday, March 15/04
murdoch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

What about the issue of efficiency in converting from AC to DC and
then back to AC?

Each of these conversion actions may have
consequences in terms of lost energy, but I haven't yet figured out
the losses.  This has come up for me recently, so it's on my mind.

According to an Inverter comparison chart, supplied by West Marine
Co.  Maximum efficiency of the inverters they list range from 88% to
94%.  All of the products that they list appear to be made by Xantrex,
(Heart Interface, Trace Engineering and Statpower are all now owned by
Xantrex making them probably the biggest manufacture of
inverters).   Many of these products have built in battery chargers.  I

Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-19 Thread Darryl McMahon

There are definitely AC motors (and DC motors) that are built (even designed) 
so 
badly that they are inefficient.  As I stated in my last post, the automotive 
industry is noted for these.

Even when we start with a good motor, there are situations where it is 
misapplied, 
and that affects efficiency.  You have pointed out one, where the motor cycles 
on 
and off frequently, which forces the motor into its inefficient operation 
region 
frequently (e.g. capacitor start mode).  Another cause is a commercial decision 
to 
use a single type of motor across a line of different sized products to get a 
longer production run of motors (hoping for economies of scale in manufacture 
of 
the motors and the goods in process inventory for manufacture of the units that 
use 
the motor).  In the case of refrigerators, this means that there may be a 
mid-line 
unit that uses the motor efficiently, a small unit for which the motor is too 
big 
(so it runs often for short periods, so spends a higher ratio of its time in an 
inefficient mode), and a larger unit where the motor is too small, so the load 
may 
force the motor to work too hard, saturating the field, producing excess heat, 
thus 
lowering efficiency.

It is hard for the consumer to know what design work and decisions went into 
the 
creation of a specific appliance or machine they are purchasing.  However, the 
EnerGuide and EnergyStar (and similar in other jurisdictions) systems give some 
idea of relative efficiencies (not absolute efficiencies, and the consumer also 
needs to know to keep as many other variables constant as possible).

For heat pumps and air conditioners, there are also standards related to the 
CoP 
(Co-efficient of Performance).  Provided this data is available from a reliable 
source, it should be possible to compare across machines to establish relative 
efficiency.

Picking the right size AC or heat pump unit for a house is difficult (based on 
correct scientific and mathematical formulae), which is why those in the trade 
rely 
on rules of thumb.  And the rules of thumb almost always are based on the worst 
case (slightly overestimate the area of the building, assume worst orientation 
to 
the sun, no shade, no thermal mass, maximum human occupancy... )  Because it is 
cheaper for the installer to put in too large a unit (the home owner pays for 
the 
extra size, and the inefficiency of the unit) than to have to come back, remove 
the 
unit that has turned out to be too small (perhaps only once and in a completely 
unusual situation) and replace it with a larger one.  So long as energy prices 
remain cheap and hidden (one hydro bill for 60 days at a time, provided to the 
customer a full month after that period is over, for the entire building) 
instead 
of realistic and up front (appliance-based readouts, instantaneous and with 
logs), 
given my experience with human nature, I don't see much hope for change with 
the 
mass of consumers.  To borrow a phrase from my business consulting days, you 
can't 
manage what you can't measure.  It certainly applies to our energy consumption.

It seems almost innate, we try to maximize what we can measure or sense.  Put 
somebody in a conventional gasoline-powered car today, equipped with a 
speedometer 
and little else in the way of instrumentation, they will drive to maximize 
speed.  
Put in instrumentation that displays fuel economy (e.g. the Prius hybrid or a 
Chryser New Yorker I owned a long time ago), and people start to drive to 
maximize 
fuel economy.

For appliances, this is probably a ways off.  I have built a set-up with 
batteries, 
DC ammeter and an inverter that permits me to get a good sense of what any 
specific 
machine (12 volts DC or 120 volts AC, with alllowance for inverter losses) is 
using 
in the way of energy.  No automated logging.  There are such units available 
commerically as well.  However, until these are in widespread use, and possibly 
built into large devices (e.g. household-scale heat pumps), I think mass 
concern 
over the efficiency of such devices will not happen.

Darryl McMahon

To: biofuel@yahoogroups.com
From:   Hakan Falk [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Date sent:  Fri, 19 Mar 2004 06:56:22 +0100
Subject:Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity 
storage
solutions.
Send reply to:  biofuel@yahoogroups.com

 
 Thanks Darryl,
 
 I appreciate your explanation and your support. Because of several factors, 
 the common equipment for compressors are very in inefficient, especially 
 AC/Heat pump units. The way they have been designed and then dimensioned, 
 are a great robbery and rip off. The customers know nothing and the common 
 HVAC engineer is trained by the suppliers. It must be someone in the design 
 and development of them, that know much more than me. The large majority of 
 people involved, are probably quite ignorant and belive what they learn in 
 school

Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-19 Thread murdoch

It seems almost innate, we try to maximize what we can measure or sense.  Put 
somebody in a conventional gasoline-powered car today, equipped with a 
speedometer 
and little else in the way of instrumentation, they will drive to maximize 
speed.  
Put in instrumentation that displays fuel economy (e.g. the Prius hybrid or 
a 
Chryser New Yorker I owned a long time ago), and people start to drive to 
maximize 
fuel economy.


We seem to be of like mind on this issue of addressing human behaviour
and the technology-human interface.  You weren't responding to my post
directly, but I'll assume that you read through it.  Obviously you're
way ahead of me if you've already built some of these devices.

What I wanted to add was even a bit more offbeat.  I was thinking the
other day of some of the excellent farming-related and rural-related
posts that we sometimes see here and elsewhere.  And I was asking
myself why we see relatively little coverage of such matters in major
press-areas.  And I think it's in part because city-folks, including
many journalists, have little but city-issues in front of their faces.
So, even though they may want to take some interest in other issues,
they go with the lifestyle and issues that present themselves readily
rather than issues that might make a more well-rounded presentation
and might appeal to a broader range of readers.  This is not to say
this can't be changed in part just to try to figure out why there
is (in my view) this disconnect where some challenging rural issues
don't seem to get as much 4th estate coverage as I would have thought
they warranted.

For appliances, this is probably a ways off.  I have built a set-up with 
batteries, 
DC ammeter and an inverter that permits me to get a good sense of what any 
specific 
machine (12 volts DC or 120 volts AC, with alllowance for inverter losses) is 
using 
in the way of energy.  No automated logging.  There are such units available 
commerically as well.  However, until these are in widespread use, and 
possibly 
built into large devices (e.g. household-scale heat pumps), I think mass 
concern 
over the efficiency of such devices will not happen.

Darryl McMahon



Biofuel at Journey to Forever:
http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html

Biofuels list archives:
http://infoarchive.net/sgroup/biofuel/

Please do NOT send Unsubscribe messages to the list address.
To unsubscribe, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Yahoo! Groups Links

* To visit your group on the web, go to:
 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuel/

* To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
 http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
 




Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-18 Thread Hakan Falk


MM,

I seams to have done it again! Killed off a very interesting discussion.

I do not know if I maybe am to abusive or what is wrong? Not good for me 
and the goals that I thought that I was championed. If I offended you or 
anyone else, I must apologize to both you and the list, but I hoped that 
this could lead to an important energy saving discussion.

My belief is that variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and 
heat pumps, are very important. These (up to 30% savings), together with 
CFL lamps (more than 60% savings), are probably the closest we can come to 
simple silver bullet and ready for use saving technologies, in 
domestic  electricity use.

Hakan


At 02:44 17/03/2004, you wrote:

MM,

Before we get too exited about savings by using DC instead of AC, we might
look at where and why we have this large differences in the energy use by
appliances. Let us first establish the fact that a conversion as such, will
cost us between 3 to 10%, depending on method, size and application.

When you talk about appliances, we should also include the AC/Heat pump
unit in this and very large savings can be done. The losses are more
created by the use of electrical engines/compressors, than by the use of
alternate current or direct current. The large differences in energy use
does not come from the type of current, but from the way the capacity
control is done. The revelation control in AC engine used in the appliances
is governed by the fixed AC frequency and the capacity control is done by
starting and stopping the compressor. The revelation control in the DC
engine is governed by voltage/current and the capacity control is done by
varying the speed/force of the engine.  Since you already are very familiar
with electrical engines, you are probably ahead of me now, about the
consequences of the different methods. I will anyway mention that the
consequences can be somewhere between 30 to 45% more energy use by the
capacity control of the AC engine. After the conversation losses, we end up
with around 25-30% difference in energy use for appliances.

In the past it was very large differences cost and durability between the
AC and DC engines, in favor to the AC engines. By new development, these
differences are no longer an critical issue and the energy use have started
to be the absolute critical issue for certain engine applications.

If you look at losses in distribution of DC, we must agree with the much
higher efficiency of AC. One very important issue is also the security
aspects, which more or less totally disqualifies high voltage DC in homes
and for general use in appliances. It is better and more manageable of
security design, if the conversion is done in the appliance and close to
the engine. The large loss of lives, that a general high voltage DC
distribution would cause, is not worth it.

Hakan


At 22:13 16/03/2004, you wrote:
 On Mon, 15 Mar 2004 23:48:36 -0800 (PST), you wrote:
 
  
  Monday, March 15/04
  murdoch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
  
  What about the issue of efficiency in converting from AC to DC and
  then back to AC?
  
  Each of these conversion actions may have
  consequences in terms of lost energy, but I haven't yet figured out
  the losses.  This has come up for me recently, so it's on my mind.
  
  According to an Inverter comparison chart, supplied by West Marine
  Co.  Maximum efficiency of the inverters they list range from 88% to
  94%.  All of the products that they list appear to be made by Xantrex,
  (Heart Interface, Trace Engineering and Statpower are all now owned by
  Xantrex making them probably the biggest manufacture of
  inverters).   Many of these products have built in battery chargers.  I
  don't know if the efficiency of the charging circuit is equal to that of
  the inverting circuit.  I don't have efficiency data on chargers.
  
  If we assume that a good charger will deliver about 90% efficiency on
  the conversion from 120 VAC to DC, and a good inverter will deliver about
  90% back to AC, you can expect to lose about 20% in conversion.
  
  I hope this helps put you in the ballpark regarding efficiency.
 
 Yes, it does help, thank you.  I was looking into a converter, to go
 from AC to DC, because there is a DC refrigerator out there
 (Sundanzer) that appears to be so efficient that I thought it might be
 worthwhile to consider.
 
 The price for an AC-to-DC converter was reasonable, but the salesman
 wasn't 100% sure about efficiency losses.  We made sort of a little
 side-project about this, because nobody had really asked these
 questions before, and they're just starting to sell Sundanzer,
 alongside Equator and Sun Frost.
 
 He got a figure of 5% that we used as a sort of stop-gap.  But I think
 to be safe, I'd add a bit more on to that 5%, and that bit-more
 jibes with your research.
 
 In the end, I think I'm going to get a Sun Frost RF-12, and eschew the
 separate Fridge-separate-freezer idea.  I had that thought because
 there are 

Re: [biofuel] AC vs. DC electricity, was: Electricity storage solutions.

2004-03-18 Thread murdoch

I'm not sure what you're talking about as far as offending anyone, so
I don't think there's any danger of that, except that to some extent
we get off-topic.  

Could I please ask you to go over this a bit more:

My belief is that variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and 
heat pumps, are very important. These (up to 30% savings), together with 
CFL lamps (more than 60% savings), are probably the closest we can come to 
simple silver bullet and ready for use saving technologies, in 
domestic  electricity use.

When you say variable output DC engines in appliances, AC units and
heat pumps, what are you saying?  That variable output DC engines
are a potential 30% savings *over* comparable AC units, or they can be
'part of' the technology inside of AC units?

I just want to make sure I understand precisely what you're saying
here.  Maybe you could provide a link to an example appliance?  A lot
of work, I know.


Biofuel at Journey to Forever:
http://journeytoforever.org/biofuel.html

Biofuels list archives:
http://infoarchive.net/sgroup/biofuel/

Please do NOT send Unsubscribe messages to the list address.
To unsubscribe, send an email to:
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 
Yahoo! Groups Links

* To visit your group on the web, go to:
 http://groups.yahoo.com/group/biofuel/

* To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]

* Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
 http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/