Re: Is the Editor's Draft public?

[Ken Whistler via Unicode]

Henri,

There is no formal concept of a public "Editor's Draft" for the Unicode 
core specification. This is mostly the result of the tools used for 
editing the core specification, which is still structured more like a 
book than the usual online internet specification.


Currently the Unicode editors are finishing up the 11.0 core 
specification editing -- and the chapters for that will be available in 
June, 2018, as noted on the current draft of the Unicode 11.0 page. 
There is no Version 12.0 "Editor's Draft" right now; instead, work on 
the 12.0 core specification will start once the 11.0 chapters have been 
frozen and published.


If you have feedback on the core specification, the best thing to do is 
simply to submit it now as part of the current 11.0 beta review, 
referring to the published 10.0 core specification text. If it is a 
small item, such as a typo, there is always the possibility that it has 
already been reported and fixed, of course -- but it won't hurt to 
report and check. Suggestions for larger changes in the text will be 
added to the pile for future consideration by the UTC and the editors, 
and likely would be taken up for the 12.0 core specification.


--Ken


On 4/20/2018 3:14 AM, Henri Sivonen via Unicode wrote:

Thank you. I checked this review announcement (I should have said so
in my email; sorry), but it leads me to
https://unicode.org/versions/Unicode11.0.0/  which says the chapters
will be "Available June 2018". But even if the 11.0 chapters were
available, I'd expect there to exist an Editor's Draft that's now in a
post-11.0 but pre-12.0 state.

I guess I should just send my comments and take the risk of my
concerns already having been addressed.

Re: Is the Editor's Draft public?

[Henri Sivonen via Unicode]

On Fri, Apr 20, 2018 at 12:16 PM, Martin J. Dürst
 wrote:
> On 2018/04/20 18:12, Martin J. Dürst wrote:
>
>> There was an announcement for a public review period just recently. The
>> review period is up to the 23rd of April. I'm not sure whether the
>> announcement is up somewhere on the Web, but I'll forward it to you
>> directly.
>
> Sorry, found the Web address of the announcement at the very bottom of the
> mail: http://blog.unicode.org/2018/04/last-call-on-unicode-110-review.html

Thank you. I checked this review announcement (I should have said so
in my email; sorry), but it leads me to
https://unicode.org/versions/Unicode11.0.0/ which says the chapters
will be "Available June 2018". But even if the 11.0 chapters were
available, I'd expect there to exist an Editor's Draft that's now in a
post-11.0 but pre-12.0 state.

I guess I should just send my comments and take the risk of my
concerns already having been addressed.

-- 
Henri Sivonen
hsivo...@hsivonen.fi
https://hsivonen.fi/

Re: Is the Editor's Draft public?

[Martin J. Dürst via Unicode]

On 2018/04/20 18:12, Martin J. Dürst wrote:

There was an announcement for a public review period just recently. The 
review period is up to the 23rd of April. I'm not sure whether the 
announcement is up somewhere on the Web, but I'll forward it to you 
directly.


Sorry, found the Web address of the announcement at the very bottom of 
the mail: 
http://blog.unicode.org/2018/04/last-call-on-unicode-110-review.html


Regards,   Martin.

Re: Is the Editor's Draft public?

[Martin J. Dürst via Unicode]

Hello Henri,

On 2018/04/20 17:15, Henri Sivonen via Unicode wrote:

Is the Editor's Draft of the Unicode Standard visible publicly?

Use case: Checking if things that I might send feedback about have
already been addressed since the publication of Unicode 10.0.


There was an announcement for a public review period just recently. The 
review period is up to the 23rd of April. I'm not sure whether the 
announcement is up somewhere on the Web, but I'll forward it to you 
directly.


Regards,   Martin.

Is the Editor's Draft public?

[Henri Sivonen via Unicode]

Is the Editor's Draft of the Unicode Standard visible publicly?

Use case: Checking if things that I might send feedback about have
already been addressed since the publication of Unicode 10.0.

-- 
Henri Sivonen
hsivo...@hsivonen.fi
https://hsivonen.fi/