Re: [vfs] About hadoop-hdfs-client dependency

2022-05-16 Thread Gary Gregory 
The better solution would be to move this provider to its own Maven module.
Thoughts?

Gary

On Mon, May 16, 2022, 05:26 Xavier Courangon 
wrote:

> Hello,
>
> We are using commons-vfs2 to create files in memory.
> However we are wondering why hadoop-hdfs-client dependency is not optional
> ?
> We don't really need support for HDFS in our case.
> Moreover it brings these additional transitive dependencies (vfs 2.9.0):
>
>- org.apache.hadoop : hadoop-hdfs-client : 3.3.1
>   - com.squareup.okhttp : okhttp : 2.7.5
>  - com.squareup.okio : okio : 1.6.0
>
>
> Can we explicitly exclude  hadoop-hdfs-client dependency without fear of
> side effects ?
> If so, shouldn't this dependency be optional ?
>
> Thanks
>
> Xavier C
>

Re: [vfs] About hadoop-hdfs-client dependency

2022-05-16 Thread Bernd Eckenfels 
Yes, those dependencies can be left out. The optional=True seems to be missing 
for one of the libs. If you get a new manager it will not load the provide if 
it can’t load the dependencies.

If you want you could contribute a jira ticket and a patch. Thanks for 
notifying us.

Gruss
Bernd
--
http://bernd.eckenfels.net

Von: Xavier Courangon 
Gesendet: Monday, May 16, 2022 10:35:18 AM
An: user@commons.apache.org 
Betreff: [vfs] About hadoop-hdfs-client dependency

Hello,

We are using commons-vfs2 to create files in memory.
However we are wondering why hadoop-hdfs-client dependency is not optional ?
We don't really need support for HDFS in our case.
Moreover it brings these additional transitive dependencies (vfs 2.9.0):

   - org.apache.hadoop : hadoop-hdfs-client : 3.3.1
  - com.squareup.okhttp : okhttp : 2.7.5
 - com.squareup.okio : okio : 1.6.0


Can we explicitly exclude  hadoop-hdfs-client dependency without fear of
side effects ?
If so, shouldn't this dependency be optional ?

Thanks

Xavier C

[vfs] About hadoop-hdfs-client dependency

2022-05-16 Thread Xavier Courangon 
Hello,

We are using commons-vfs2 to create files in memory.
However we are wondering why hadoop-hdfs-client dependency is not optional ?
We don't really need support for HDFS in our case.
Moreover it brings these additional transitive dependencies (vfs 2.9.0):

   - org.apache.hadoop : hadoop-hdfs-client : 3.3.1
  - com.squareup.okhttp : okhttp : 2.7.5
 - com.squareup.okio : okio : 1.6.0


Can we explicitly exclude  hadoop-hdfs-client dependency without fear of
side effects ?
If so, shouldn't this dependency be optional ?

Thanks

Xavier C