Re: [wp-testers] No comment notification using WP 3.0-alpha

2010-03-22 Thread Kirk M
Andrew - That fixed it! I uploaded the patched comment.php file, made 
a few test comments and the email notifications came rolling in. Many 
thanks for tracking the problem down and patching! It was something I 
couldn't have done on my own.


Even though it will probably be pushed out with tomorrow's nightly, 
I'll pass on the patched files to the folks I was testing with. Nice to 
know I was seeing things or just being dense (I worry about that since 
I'm certainly not getting any younger).


On 3/22/2010 12:08 PM, Andrew Nacin wrote:


Perhaps I should just ask straight out. Are any of the members of this
mailing list receiving comment notifications from the WP 3.0-alpha builds?



I managed to track this down. Fixed in trunk:
http://core.trac.wordpress.org/changeset/13801
___
wp-testers mailing list
wp-testers@lists.automattic.com
http://lists.automattic.com/mailman/listinfo/wp-testers

___
wp-testers mailing list
wp-testers@lists.automattic.com
http://lists.automattic.com/mailman/listinfo/wp-testers


Re: [wp-testers] No comment notification using WP 3.0-alpha

2010-03-20 Thread Kirk M

Hi Dion,

The email address associated with the test site is not a Gmail address 
but one directly associated with my web host. This used to be required 
by WordPress as email addresses external to the web host/site itself 
were not allowed as many hosts added this check as a security measure. 
The standard format for a site related email address was 
wordpr...@domainname.***. (This info was located in the WP docs 
somewhere but I can't recall exactly where off the top of my head.)


*Note*: Westi once made me a small plugin that circumvented this 
requirement (requirement came in WP 2.5 I believe?) called 
php-no-sender which worked great back then but does not help the 
problem in WP 3.0.


I did state that the Subscribe to Comments plugin was correctly 
sending notifications to a couple Gmail addresses I had set up for 
testing purposes.


Also, I confirmed this problem last night with a couple of friends of 
mine who are also running WP 3.0-alpha test sites. They're both 
experiencing the same exact problem of receiving every notification I 
mentioned previously except the standard comment notifications as 
described in my original post. All 3 of us are running the PHP5 (5.2.11 
in my case).


Deactivating plugins does not change the problem by the way. I wish I 
could recall when the WP 3.0 nightly builds stopped sending comment 
notifications but I haven't been able to track it down.


Sorry if this is too much info. I tend to be wordy.

On 03/19/2010 09:27 PM, Dion Hulse (dd32) wrote:

Have you checked your gmail spam?

For quite awhile i wasn't receiving comment notifications, turned out,
it was due to gmail eating comment notifications (While passing through
user notifications)..



On Sat, 20 Mar 2010 07:20:37 +1200, Kirk M kmb4...@gmail.com wrote:


Hi all - I've encountered a rather hair pulling glitch with a WordPress
3.0-alpha test site in that it's not sending out any comment
notifications whatsoever. The email address in both my User Profile
(administrator) and under Settings/General is the same and associated
with my web host (wordpr...@mysitename.us) just like my other 2 sites
are. My other two sites are running WP 2.9.2 and receive comment
notifications without problem. (web host is Bluehost--never had a
problem with this until WP 3.0-alpha builds).

I seem to recall that comment notifications were working initially and
then just quit between one nightly build and another. Unfortunately, I
was rather busy at the time and I don't remember which builds.

The kicker here is that I'm also running the Subscribe to Comments
plugin on the test site and I'm receiving notifications of additional
comments on a post I'm subscribed to with no problem.

In further troubleshooting, I even receive New User notifications not
only to the email address associated with my User Profile and under
Settings/General but also to the email address (a Gmail address) I
used for the new user (the new user was myself of course using a
different name.

Bottom line test results are:

-Comment notifications to site owner: -No-

-Subscribe to Comments notifications sent to subscriber's email
address: -Yes-

-New user notifications to site owner: -Yes-

-New user username and password sent to their email address: -Yes-

I have Settings/Discussion set to email me whenever Anyone posts a
comment. I've checked everything that's even remotely associated with
the standard comment notifications and I can't find the problem and I
can't figure out for the life of me why all the other email
notifications related to the site are working fine EXCEPT the standard
comment notifications. Nothing in the error logs either.

I'm running out of hair which is dangerous at my age as I have so little
to begin with so any help would be very welcome.

___
wp-testers mailing list
wp-testers@lists.automattic.com
http://lists.automattic.com/mailman/listinfo/wp-testers





___
wp-testers mailing list
wp-testers@lists.automattic.com
http://lists.automattic.com/mailman/listinfo/wp-testers