Re: [delicious-discuss] allowing users to reorder their bookmarks

2006-01-13 Thread joshua schachter

Yes, ordering is something that is definitely on the todo list.

The problem with combining orderings seems challenging, though. Some  
per bookmark ranking inferred by the order and then reimposed in  
different listings? I dunno.


Joshua

On Jan 11, 2006, at 3:05 PM, Amir Michail wrote:


Hi,

I think it might be useful to allow users to reorder their bookmarks,
just as they can do in their browser.

However, to take things further, why not allow users to reorder their
bookmarks based on queries?

For example, although clicking on the tag search shows me my
bookmarks tagged with search, it would be good if I could also reorder
those bookmarks with respect to that tag.

In this way, users can get their own perfect rankings for queries.

Moreover, if the system keeps track of these reorderings, it can
construct a partial order of urls for each query.  (Note that if you
do not explicitly reorder any bookmarks, then there are no reorderings
for the system to consider.)

These partial orders can then be combined to produce better rankings
for a global search.  Although such rankings will no longer be perfect
for users, they might be quite good anyway.

Amir
___
discuss mailing list
discuss@del.icio.us
http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss



--
joshua schachter
[EMAIL PROTECTED]


___
discuss mailing list
discuss@del.icio.us
http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss


Re: [delicious-discuss] allowing users to reorder their bookmarks

2006-01-13 Thread Amir Michail
On 1/14/06, joshua schachter [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
 Yes, ordering is something that is definitely on the todo list.

 The problem with combining orderings seems challenging, though. Some
 per bookmark ranking inferred by the order and then reimposed in
 different listings? I dunno.


You need some way to break cycles to get a partial order for the global ranking.

This might be helpful:

Aggregation of Rankings in Figure Skating
http://www.wallis.rochester.edu/william04/Skating.pdf

Of course, you can weigh users differently when deciding on how to
break cycles.

Amir

 Joshua

 On Jan 11, 2006, at 3:05 PM, Amir Michail wrote:

  Hi,
 
  I think it might be useful to allow users to reorder their bookmarks,
  just as they can do in their browser.
 
  However, to take things further, why not allow users to reorder their
  bookmarks based on queries?
 
  For example, although clicking on the tag search shows me my
  bookmarks tagged with search, it would be good if I could also reorder
  those bookmarks with respect to that tag.
 
  In this way, users can get their own perfect rankings for queries.
 
  Moreover, if the system keeps track of these reorderings, it can
  construct a partial order of urls for each query.  (Note that if you
  do not explicitly reorder any bookmarks, then there are no reorderings
  for the system to consider.)
 
  These partial orders can then be combined to produce better rankings
  for a global search.  Although such rankings will no longer be perfect
  for users, they might be quite good anyway.
 
  Amir
  ___
  discuss mailing list
  discuss@del.icio.us
  http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss


 --
 joshua schachter
 [EMAIL PROTECTED]



___
discuss mailing list
discuss@del.icio.us
http://lists.del.icio.us/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/discuss