Re: [agi] What Must a World Be That a Humanlike Intelligence May Develop In It?

2009-01-12 Thread Benjamin Johnston
I think this sort of virtual world is an excellent idea. I agree with Benjamin Johnston's idea of a unified object model where everything consists of beads. I notice you mentioned distributing the computation. This would certainly be valuable in the long run, but for the first version I would

RE: [agi] What Must a World Be That a Humanlike Intelligence May Develop In It?

2009-01-11 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi Ben, I've been looking at the same problem from a different angle... rather than searching for simplified artificial worlds for an agent to live in, I've been searching for models of the world to be used directly for reasoning (i.e., the internal world for an agent situated in the real world).

Free Association, Creativity and AGI (was RE: [agi] The Smushaby of Flatway.)

2009-01-11 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi Mike (Tintner), You've often made bold claims about what all AGIers do or don't do. This is despite the fact that you haven't met me in person and I haven't revealed many of my own long term plans on this list (and I'm sure I'm not the only one): you're making bold claims about *all* of us,

Re: [agi] Should I get a PhD?

2008-12-17 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi YKY, I'm considering getting a PhD somewhere, and I've accumulated some material for a thesis in my 50%-finished AGI book. I think getting a PhD will put my work in a more rigorous form and get it published. Also it may help me get funding afterwards, either in academia or in the business

RE: [agi] My prospective plan to neutralize AGI and other dangerous technologies...

2008-11-18 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Could we please stick to discussion of AGI? -Ben From: Steve Richfield [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Wednesday, 19 November 2008 10:39 AM To: agi@v2.listbox.com Subject: Re: [agi] My prospective plan to neutralize AGI and other dangerous technologies... Richard and Bill, On

Re: [agi] A paper that actually does solve the problem of consciousness

2008-11-16 Thread Benjamin Johnston
I completed the first draft of a technical paper on consciousness the other day. It is intended for the AGI-09 conference, and it can be found at: Hi Richard, I don't have any comments yet about what you have written, because I'm not sure I fully understand what you're trying to say...

RE: [agi] OT: More thoughts Technological Censorship

2008-11-05 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Rather than assuming idiocy, censorship or ill intent; why not give them the benefit of the doubt? Maybe they felt that offering anybody the chance to sign up as a speaker with a session title, your name, a link to your bio or website, and perhaps a picture of you was enough. You have

RE: [agi] Unification by index?

2008-11-02 Thread Benjamin Johnston
that is helpful, -Benjamin Johnston --- agi Archives: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/303/=now RSS Feed: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/rss/303/ Modify Your Subscription: https://www.listbox.com/member/?member_id=8660244id_secret

RE: [agi] virtual credits again

2008-10-29 Thread Benjamin Johnston
if there were more people here like YKY. This is already off topic for this mailing list, so if you would like to discuss it further please feel free to email me directly. Sincerely, -Benjamin Johnston --- agi Archives: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive

RE: [agi] If your AGI can't learn to play chess it is no AGI

2008-10-23 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Within the domain of chess there is everything to know about chess. So if it comes up to be a good chess player learning chess from playing chess must be sufficient. Thus, an AGI which is not able to enhance its abilities in chess from playing chess alone is no AGI.   I'm jumping into this

[agi] Does prior knowledge/learning cause GAs to converge too fast on sub-optimal solutions?

2008-09-07 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi, I have a general question for those (such as Novamente) working on AGI systems that use genetic algorithms as part of their search strategy. A GA researcher recently explained to me some of his experiments in embedding prior knowledge into systems. For example, when attempting to

RE: [agi] draft paper: a hybrid logic for AGI

2008-08-31 Thread Benjamin Johnston
This is a draft of my paper =) I need some feedback before releasing it officially Comments, suggestions, are welcome! Hi YKY, I found your paper interesting to read. You've got a nice story about combining P and Z inference, and your integration of the two sounds quite sensible.

Re: [agi] Any further comments from lurkers??? [WAS do we need a stronger politeness code on this list?]

2008-08-04 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Thanks a lot, I really appreciate your message. It is good to get contributions on these META themes from individuals who are *not* among the 5-10% of list members who frequently post. If any other lurkers or semi-lurkers have opinions on these META issues, I and others would be interested

RE: [agi] a fuzzy reasoning problem

2008-07-30 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Can you define that difference in an abstract, general way? I mean, what is the *qualitative* difference that makes: cybersex is a kind of sex different from: penguin is a kind of bird? I believe that cybersex and phone sex are called sex in a metaphoric way. The keyboard or

RE: [agi] a fuzzy reasoning problem

2008-07-29 Thread Benjamin Johnston
you're using them in the face of limited information. -Benjamin Johnston --- agi Archives: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/303/=now RSS Feed: https://www.listbox.com/member/archive/rss/303/ Modify Your Subscription: https://www.listbox.com/member

RE: [agi] a fuzzy reasoning problem

2008-07-28 Thread Benjamin Johnston
I see the failure in this argument at step 2. Cybersex is a kind of erotic interaction. Erotic interactions are often called sex in general conversation, even though there are many kinds of erotic interactions that don't result in the transmission of STDs, that can't lead to children, that don't

Re: [agi] Computing's coming Theory of Everything

2008-07-22 Thread Benjamin Johnston
/Restating (not copying) my original posting, the challenge of effective unstructured learning is to utilize every clue and NOT just go with static clusters, etc. This includes temporal as well as positional clues, information content, etc. PCA does some but certainly not all of this, but

RE: [agi] the uncomputable

2008-06-18 Thread Benjamin Johnston
My own interpretation of the work is that an individual person is no more powerful than a Turing machine (though, this point isn't discussed in the paper), but that society as a whole is capable of hypercomputation because we can keep drawing upon more resources to solve a problem:

RE: [agi] the uncomputable

2008-06-16 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi Abram, I believe the key point of the paper is: ...human minds develop through time over generations, they invent new concepts and techniques, which in turn allow previously resistant problems to be solved. There seems to be no upward bound whatsoever to this ascension. This is captured in

Re: [agi] AGI-08 videos

2008-05-06 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Richard Loosemore said: But instead of deep-foundation topics like these, what do we get? Mostly what we get is hacks. People just want to dive right and make quick assumptions about the answers to all of these issues, then they get hacking and build something - *anything* - to make it look

Re: [agi] An Open Letter to AGI Investors

2008-04-20 Thread Benjamin Johnston
First, I think there is a world of difference between passionate researchers at the beginning of the field, in 1956, and passionate researchers in 2008 who have a half-century of other people's mistakes to learn from. The secret of success is to try and fail, then to try again with a fresh

Re: [agi] An Open Letter to AGI Investors

2008-04-17 Thread Benjamin Johnston
I have stuck my neck out and written an Open Letter to AGI (Artificial General Intelligence) Investors on my website at http://susaro.com. All part of a campaign to get this field jumpstarted. Next week I am going to put up a road map for my own development project. Hi Richard, If I were

Re: [agi] Comments from a lurker...

2008-04-16 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Steve Richfield said (regarding his Dr Eliza system): I cannot see ANY argument that it is NOT novel AI. Certainly no one expressed any such doubts at the WORLDCOMP conferences where it was presented and demonstrated. Maybe, but WORLDCOMP doesn't appear to be a particularly serious

Re: [agi] Comments from a lurker...

2008-04-13 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi Steve, I've read the papers you've posted on this list, and looked at your Access database... Text-to-speech, speech-to-text and the simple textual preprocessing can enhance usability, but they tend to make a system *appear* more intelligent rather than adding real depth to a system. So

Re: [agi] The Test

2008-02-07 Thread Benjamin Johnston
swear were highly original and creative (themed and patterned in parts, but neither entirely random nor entirely structured) if you had never seen an L-system before. -Benjamin Johnston - This list is sponsored by AGIRI: http://www.agiri.org/email To unsubscribe or change your options

RE: [agi] The Test

2008-02-05 Thread Benjamin Johnston
on the centuries/millennia old question of what exactly is intelligence. -Benjamin Johnston - This list is sponsored by AGIRI: http://www.agiri.org/email To unsubscribe or change your options, please go to: http://v2.listbox.com/member/?member_id=8660244id_secret=93749339-13e4f1

Re: [agi] The Test

2008-02-05 Thread Benjamin Johnston
website that you would swear were highly original and creative (themed and patterned in parts, but neither entirely random nor entirely structured) if you had never seen an L-system before. -Benjamin Johnston - This list is sponsored by AGIRI: http://www.agiri.org/email To unsubscribe

Re: [agi] The Test

2008-02-05 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Very briefly, my focus a while back in attacking programs was not on the sign/ semiotic - and more particularly, symbolic - form of programs, although that is v. important too. My focus was on the *structure* of programs - that's what they are: structured and usually sequenced sets of

Re: [agi] The Test

2008-02-04 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Er, you don't ask that in AGI. The general culture here is not to recognize the crux, or the test of AGI. You are the first person here to express the basic requirement of any creative project. You should only embark on a true creative project - in the sense of committing to it - if you have

RE: [agi] Request for Help

2008-01-30 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Hi Mike, When the Flash code on your machine contacts the server, I assume it would use a fairly straightforward communications format (XML over HTTP maybe?). If you install a program to monitor the communications, you might be able to figure out how to get at the data without using Flash. There

[agi] Real-time Java-based vision libraries?

2008-01-28 Thread Benjamin Johnston
before I dive deeper into the machine vision literature and attempt to write my own. I’m capturing video frames via the Java Media Framework, but could convert the stream into images of any reasonable format. Any pointers would be very much appreciated. Thank you, -Benjamin Johnston

RE: [agi] Real-time Java-based vision libraries?

2008-01-28 Thread Benjamin Johnston
Ah, well, appearances can be deceptive. There are many papers in computer vision in which you can see fancy 3D reconstructions produced from camera images. However, when you really get into the nitty gritty of how these work you'll usually find that they were either produced under highly

Re: [agi] advice-level dev collaboration

2007-11-13 Thread Benjamin Johnston
be on-topic for this mailing list. Why not try this list, and then move to the private discussion model (or start an [agi-developer] list) if there's a backlash? -Benjamin Johnston Jiri Jelinek wrote: I'm looking for a skilled coder from the AGI community who is well familiar with Java/JEE

Re: [agi] definition source?

2007-11-08 Thread Benjamin Johnston
', 'context' and 'correctly': these could be interpreted very widely depending on the ... uh... context. -Benjamin Johnston Jiri Jelinek wrote: BillK, thanks for the link. All, I don't want to trigger a long AGI definition talk, but can one or two of you briefly tell me what might be wrong