Re: [Aoetools-discuss] AoE Target implementaion for LIO?

2012-10-21 Thread Gernot Schmied
Hi Tracy, very thoughtful posting, I've arrived at similar conclusions and I am in a similar way from an early stage emotionally attached to a protocol of fine craftsmanship that has potential per se. In the beginning I've advocated the AoE protocol to be converted into an RFC, that would have

Re: [Aoetools-discuss] AoE Target implementaion for LIO?

2012-10-21 Thread Nicolas Jungers
On 2012-10-19 15:19, Ed Cashin wrote: AoE use is accelerating rapidly, and iSCSI persists because even though it's not the best fit for same-LAN data storage, folks can still get it to work if they are willing and able to deal with the complexity, sacrifice the performance, and don't need the

Re: [Aoetools-discuss] AoE Target implementaion for LIO?

2012-10-21 Thread Ed Cashin
On Oct 21, 2012, at 9:03 AM, Nicolas Jungers wrote: On 2012-10-19 15:19, Ed Cashin wrote: AoE use is accelerating rapidly, and iSCSI persists because even though it's not the best fit for same-LAN data storage, folks can still get it to work if they are willing and able to deal with the

Re: [Aoetools-discuss] AoE Target implementaion for LIO?

2012-10-19 Thread Ed Cashin
AoE use is accelerating rapidly, and iSCSI persists because even though it's not the best fit for same-LAN data storage, folks can still get it to work if they are willing and able to deal with the complexity, sacrifice the performance, and don't need the kind of scaling that virtualization and

Re: [Aoetools-discuss] AoE Target implementaion for LIO?

2012-10-19 Thread Torbjørn Thorsen
I'm happy to hear that there is now progress on getting the initiator updated in upstream, hopefully this will help to correct the assumption that AoE is dead or dying. Not that I'm very knowledgeable about the storage sector, but it seems to me that AoEs main problem as a technology is

Re: [Aoetools-discuss] AoE Target implementaion for LIO?

2012-10-19 Thread Alexandre
Hi, Happy to sse that Coraid is contributing to the kernel.org initiator! I have tryed for a while to convince customers of my former company to give AoE a try. After presenting them the technology they had no doubt about AoE superiority over iSCSI. However, they often chose iscsi as it appeared