Re: Greider

2003-07-22 Thread Bryan Caplan
Robert A. Book wrote:
Greider also has interesting material on the Democrats' connection to 
the SL industry.  I'd never heard about any of this, but he seems to 
have his facts straight on this point.

Wrong hasn't been so much fun in years!
--


Bryan, if he's wrong about the material you know a lot about, what
makes you think he has his facts straight on the subjects you know
less about?
Shouldn't his obvious errors on cost/benefit, risk analysis, and
corporate accountability reduce the prior probability (to you) that
he's right on anything?
Good question.  Sure, errors in one area raise the probability of errors 
in other areas.  But he's a journalist.  I expect him to be weak on 
analytics.  The 5 W's of who-what-when-where-why are what he's trained 
to get right.


--Robert Book





--
Prof. Bryan Caplan
   Department of Economics  George Mason University
http://www.bcaplan.com  [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Infancy conforms to nobody: all conform to it, so that
 one babe commonly makes four or five out of the adults
 who prattle and play to it.
 --Ralph Waldo Emerson, Self-Reliance




Re: Greider

2003-07-21 Thread Robert A. Book
 Greider also has interesting material on the Democrats' connection to 
 the SL industry.  I'd never heard about any of this, but he seems to 
 have his facts straight on this point.
 
 Wrong hasn't been so much fun in years!
 -- 


Bryan, if he's wrong about the material you know a lot about, what
makes you think he has his facts straight on the subjects you know
less about?

Shouldn't his obvious errors on cost/benefit, risk analysis, and
corporate accountability reduce the prior probability (to you) that
he's right on anything?


--Robert Book