Re: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread Matthew Somerville
James Cridland wrote: http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio3/breakfast/pip/jrjen/ - good. http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio3/breakfast/archive/07/07/10/ - better. That's not better; URLs are supposed to be unique. Okay, Breakfast isn't a great example for my case, but even with that, if it's ever repeated,

RE: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread Gordon Joly
At 12:17 +0100 16/7/07, Andrew Bowden wrote: Another example (from the same area): http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/x9qv/ - good http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/elton_john/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/elton_john/ - better Okay, I can't follow that one - I guess if you had two

Re: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread Tom Coates
Yeah this is another classic problem. The way I think about this stuff is as follows: A specific URI should refer to a unique concept in the world and should be as human readable as possible but NO MORE. Meaning, that if making the URI more human readable fucks up the way it refers to the

RE: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread Andrew Bowden
Another example (from the same area): http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/x9qv/ - good http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/elton_john/ http://www.bbc.co.uk/music/artist/elton_john/ - better Okay, I can't follow that one - I guess if you had two artists of the same name? But then I'd go

Re: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread Michael Smethurst
Last fm used to use musicbrainz to disambiguate artists Then they stopped paying the data licence and turned off musicbrainz Which means they just match on strings According to brainz there are 3 oasis' in existence (last fm has one) And something like 13 auroras (again last fm has one).

Re: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread Kim Plowright
On 16/07/07, Matthew Somerville [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: James Cridland wrote: http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio3/breakfast/pip/jrjen/ - good. http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio3/breakfast/archive/07/07/10/ - better. That's not better; URLs are supposed to be unique. Okay, Breakfast isn't a great example

[backstage] Tivo StopWatch beginner questions...

2007-07-16 Thread James Ockenden
Interesting news from Tivo, it has been measuring 20,000 users second-by-second viewing habits. The results show people actually like the direct response ads better... more interesting i thought was how StopWatch managed the 20,000 CRID/URI-style info streaming in every second for two months

Re: [backstage] Links to video/audio for specific shows

2007-07-16 Thread James Cridland
On 7/16/07, Tom Coates [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hey - as the person who developed the URL stuff for the programme information pages project (PIPs - hence pip in the URL), I can assure you that the one you're proposing is not generally better. That's me told! Though thank you... ;) In terms

Re: [backstage] Tivo StopWatch beginner questions...

2007-07-16 Thread James Cridland
On 7/16/07, James Ockenden [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: more interesting i thought was how StopWatch managed the 20,000 CRID/URI-style info streaming in every second for two months (that's a lot of data no?) and how it measured and identified each program, and, since this was primarliy for

[backstage] About our API

2007-07-16 Thread Mr I Forrester
Following from the debate about links for programmes... how about this? http://blogs.sun.com/sandoz/entry/bbc_web_api_beta - found via George. Ian Forrester - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group. To unsubscribe, please visit