Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-10 Thread Andy
Etienne Pollard wrote: You might be interested to learn about a new project that has just been launched by TheyWorkForYou.com - an online video archive of the House of Commons, with video clips posted in Flash video format alongside the text of speeches from Hansard. Just tried it out. I did

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-10 Thread Billy Abbott
On Tue, 10 Jun 2008, Andy wrote: Just tried it out. I did notice the text from Hansard was not actually the same as what was said, is this common? As it says in the bullet points to the right of the video and text: Hansard is not a verbatim transcript, so spoken words might differ slightly

RE: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-06 Thread John O'Donovan
Now that you know what happens I bet you won't do that again... Cheers, jod From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] on behalf of Frank Wales Sent: Thu 6/5/2008 22:57 To: backstage@lists.bbc.co.uk Subject: Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-06 Thread Frank Wales
John O'Donovan wrote: Now that you know what happens I bet you won't do that again... Actually, I think that behaviour is a bug, but as I'm now out of scratch pantaloons to test with, I'll leave it for others more versed in surprise linguo-tailoring incidents to investigate. -- Frank Wales

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-05 Thread Etienne Pollard
On Wed, Jun 4, 2008 at 7:17 PM, John O'Donovan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The way MySociety have approached this simplifies a difficult task and makes the video more accessible as a result. It is a great way to democratise the process of democratising democracy Glad to hear that you like it!

RE: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-05 Thread Thomas Leitch
Well done Etienne, A fantastic piece of work... But I would have to take issue with your view John, of Hansard being an entirely representative view of what went on in the various chambers... http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/uk_politics/7187907.stm ;-)

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-05 Thread Etienne Pollard
On Thu, Jun 5, 2008 at 10:34 AM, Thomas Leitch [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Well done Etienne, A fantastic piece of work... Thank you for the compliment. It wasn't just me, by any means - there were also very significant amounts of work done by Matthew Somerville and other members of the

RE: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-05 Thread John O'Donovan
No comment. There are of course many ways to ensure unparliamentarily language is not used. The BBC has it's own. If you swear on this list for example, your trousers will fall down like a comedy clown. Cheers, jod From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-05 Thread Frank Wales
John O'Donovan wrote: If you swear on this list for example, your trousers will fall down like a comedy clown. Huh. I did not know that. But how sensitive is this language-sensitive depant-o-tron? Let's find out... What word starts with 'f' and ends in 'uck'? Firetruck!

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Brian Butterworth
Generally a great idea. But why on earth is this being done this way? The Astons on the channel carry the information anyway, and we know that this can be fed into another computer system, as the MHEG5 version of BBC Parliament. I can't be that hard for BBC Parliament to provide the feed of

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Matthew Somerville
Brian Butterworth wrote: But why on earth is this being done this way? If by Astons you mean the superimposed captions, then if you had read the text below (and the blog posting linked to), you would see that we did try exactly that and it sadly just wasn't good enough. ATB, Matthew The

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Phil Wilson
However, a clear text feed of the data would keep the data pure, surely? Seriously, where would the fun in that be? Phil 'timestamp-tastic' Wilson - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group. To unsubscribe, please visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html.

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Brian Butterworth
Phil, I'm sure one of the first computing acronyms I ever leant was GIGO... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GIGO 2008/6/4 Phil Wilson [EMAIL PROTECTED]: However, a clear text feed of the data would keep the data pure, surely? Seriously, where would the fun in that be? Phil

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Matthew Somerville
Phil Wilson wrote: Phil 'timestamp-tastic' Wilson People are catching up on you, Phil, better get back to it! ;-) ATB, Matthew - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk discussion group. To unsubscribe, please visit http://backstage.bbc.co.uk/archives/2005/01/mailing_list.html. Unofficial list

RE: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Andrew Bowden
Forgive my ignorance, but what is an Aston? Aston is a company who provide systems for generating on-screen graphics for live programmes - however it's also used as a generic term for those same graphics. So the kind of graphics like you get on the News where they'll say Nick Higham reporting,

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Phil Wilson
I'm sure one of the first computing acronyms I ever leant was GIGO... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GIGO Yes, I know it. Take a look at Etienne's reply for one aspect of the details and why the captions may also count as garbage. Another important point is that the video captioner they've

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Matthew Somerville
Brian Butterworth wrote: I thought they were trying to do OCR on the captions from the DVB-T stream. No, we have clear text. As it says in the blog post :-) However, a clear text feed of the data would keep the data pure, surely? Sadly not (trust me, I've spent some time on this!) - even

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Brian Butterworth
2008/6/4 Etienne Pollard [EMAIL PROTECTED]: On Wed, Jun 4, 2008 at 10:55 AM, Brian Butterworth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I thought they were trying to do OCR on the captions from the DVB-T stream. What I was saying was that the old Freeview version of BBC Parliament used to have a

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Brian Butterworth
Phil, 2008/6/4 Phil Wilson [EMAIL PROTECTED]: I'm sure one of the first computing acronyms I ever leant was GIGO... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GIGO Yes, I know it. Take a look at Etienne's reply for one aspect of the details and why the captions may also count as garbage. Another

RE: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Christopher Woods
Aston is a company who provide systems for generating on-screen graphics for live programmes - however it's also used as a generic term for those same graphics. So the kind of graphics like you get on the News where they'll say Nick Higham reporting, the name of an interviewee or

Re: [backstage] Video recordings of the House of Commons on TheyWorkForYou.com

2008-06-04 Thread Martin Deutsch
On 6/4/08, Etienne Pollard [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On Wed, Jun 4, 2008 at 10:55 AM, Brian Butterworth [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: What I was saying was that the old Freeview version of BBC Parliament used to have a quarter-screen picture and the information that is now in the Astons was