DNSSEC validation works with DLV, but not with just trusted-key

2009-11-25 Thread Hanno Böck
Hi, Maybe I'm getting something wrong here, but as far as I understand, when I enable dnssec and dnssec-validation and have a zone with a trusted-key, bind should not answer to requests for bad dnssec signatures. This is my config: trusted-keys { org. 257 3 7

Re: DNSSEC validation works with DLV, but not with just trusted-key

2009-11-25 Thread Alan Clegg
Hanno Böck wrote: dig baddata-A.test.dnssec-tools.org @localhost There is no DS record for dnssec-tools.org in .org (chain of trust is broken), so you can't validate the response -- thus the data being passed back to you. AlanC ___ bind-users

Re: DNSSEC validation works with DLV, but not with just trusted-key

2009-11-25 Thread Hanno Böck
Am Mittwoch 25 November 2009 schrieb Alan Clegg: There is no DS record for dnssec-tools.org in .org (chain of trust is broken), so you can't validate the response -- thus the data being passed back to you. Ok, that explains it. Are there any example domains with known-broken dnssec records

Re: DNSSEC validation works with DLV, but not with just trusted-key

2009-11-25 Thread Alan Clegg
Hanno Böck wrote: Am Mittwoch 25 November 2009 schrieb Alan Clegg: There is no DS record for dnssec-tools.org in .org (chain of trust is broken), so you can't validate the response -- thus the data being passed back to you. Ok, that explains it. Are there any example domains with

Re: DNSSEC validation works with DLV, but not with just trusted-key

2009-11-25 Thread Mark Andrews
Or one could use DLV to provide the trust linkage. dnssec-tools.org.dlv.isc.org. 3499 IN DLV 54556 5 1 11A4026F4E09B1C106AAF3AC81A37AA537B8A3E6 dnssec-tools.org.dlv.isc.org. 3499 IN DLV 54556 5 2 6B026928292D452A5CC37B3EF327F27F50A29936CB31E664EB066D71 A476E282 -- Mark Andrews,

Re: DNSSEC validation works with DLV, but not with just trusted-key

2009-11-25 Thread Mark Andrews
In message 200911252202.napm2asg000...@drugs.dv.isc.org, Mark Andrews writes: Or one could use DLV to provide the trust linkage. dnssec-tools.org.dlv.isc.org. 3499 IN DLV 54556 5 1 11A4026F4E09B1C106AAF3AC81A37AA537B8A3E6 dnssec-tools.org.dlv.isc.org. 3499 IN DLV 54556 5 2