Re: 2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread David Kastrup
"Silas S. Brown" writes: >> > Thanks. In that case, can I request that any attempt to >> > add a note while "*" is in the duration should cause an >> > error, or at the very least a warning? >> >> That would turn into a real nuisance for "simile" triplets entered as >> durations with *2/3

Re: 2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread David Kastrup
"Silas S. Brown" writes: > On Mon, Nov 21, 2022 at 12:54:45PM +, Mark Knoop wrote: >> Hi Silas, >> Remember that in LilyPond, durations carry over from the previous event >> if not explicitly specified. This includes the duration of multimeasure >> rests. You have already found the solution

Re: 2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread Paul Scott
On 11/21/22 05:36, Silas S. Brown wrote: % In 2/4 time, I want to write 4 bars rest % followed by 2 minims (half-notes). % The bar numbering comes out differently: \version "2.22.2" \relative c' { \set Score.skipBars = ##t \time 2/4 R2*4 c ^"This is bar 5" \break d ^"I think this should be bar

Re: 2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread Silas S. Brown
On Mon, Nov 21, 2022 at 12:54:45PM +, Mark Knoop wrote: > Hi Silas, > Remember that in LilyPond, durations carry over from the previous event > if not explicitly specified. This includes the duration of multimeasure > rests. You have already found the solution - this is the expected >

CompressMMRests issue

2022-11-21 Thread Denis Penard
Dear all, I am now engraving Manhattan Symphony in Lilypond. I encouter an issue with CompressMMRests. Here is the code. I just take some bars not the whole score. After the third \partial (red one below), I attempt to get a 8 compressed rests bars but the eight bars are unfolded. If I

2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread Silas S. Brown
% In 2/4 time, I want to write 4 bars rest % followed by 2 minims (half-notes). % The bar numbering comes out differently: \version "2.22.2" \relative c' { \set Score.skipBars = ##t \time 2/4 R2*4 c ^"This is bar 5" \break d ^"I think this should be bar 6 but it is bar 9" } % The problem goes

Re: CompressMMRests issue

2022-11-21 Thread David Kastrup
Denis Penard writes: > Dear all, > > I am now engraving Manhattan Symphony in Lilypond. > > I encouter an issue with CompressMMRests. Here is the code. I just > take some bars not the whole score. > > After the third \partial (red one below), I attempt to get a 8 > compressed rests bars but the

Re: 2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread Mark Knoop
Hi Silas, At 12:36 on 21 Nov 2022, Silas S. Brown wrote: > % In 2/4 time, I want to write 4 bars rest > % followed by 2 minims (half-notes). > % The bar numbering comes out differently: > \version "2.22.2" > \relative c' { > \set Score.skipBars = ##t > \time 2/4 R2*4 c ^"This is bar 5" \break >

Re: 2.22: unexpected bar numbering when using * lengths and skipBars

2022-11-21 Thread Silas S. Brown
> > Thanks. In that case, can I request that any attempt to > > add a note while "*" is in the duration should cause an > > error, or at the very least a warning? > > That would turn into a real nuisance for "simile" triplets entered as > durations with *2/3 multiplier. OK, then we'd have to