Re: [Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-04 Thread Joerg Schilling
Pavel Raiskup prais...@redhat.com wrote: Hi tar community, we are working on the xattrs|selinux|acl listing feature for command tar -tf --xattrs and tar -tvf --xattrs (or --selinux, --acls) and we would like to consult possible format of listing output even if xattr support is not

Re: [Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-04 Thread Joerg Schilling
Tim Kientzle t...@kientzle.com wrote: YAML would be reasonable, or JSON or XML. I'm not very particular. I would like to see a written proposal for such a format. If it looks reasonable, we could easily add it to bsdtar as well. Are you talking about the listing format or about the archive

Re: [Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-04 Thread Tim Kientzle
On May 3, 2012, at 11:27 AM, Andreas Dilger wrote: On 2012-05-03, at 6:10 AM, Pavel Raiskup wrote: Something like that looks reasonable. One major comment, though, is that the output of tar should be parsable, i.e., it should be possible to look at the output, figure out what format it is,

Re: [Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-03 Thread Pavel Raiskup
Hello Paul, thanks for your comment! Something like that looks reasonable. One major comment, though, is that the output of tar should be parsable, i.e., it should be possible to look at the output, figure out what format it is, and parse it reliably. The current format doesn't have that

Re: [Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-03 Thread Andreas Dilger
On 2012-05-03, at 6:10 AM, Pavel Raiskup wrote: Something like that looks reasonable. One major comment, though, is that the output of tar should be parsable, i.e., it should be possible to look at the output, figure out what format it is, and parse it reliably. The current format doesn't

[Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-02 Thread Pavel Raiskup
Hi tar community, we are working on the xattrs|selinux|acl listing feature for command tar -tf --xattrs and tar -tvf --xattrs (or --selinux, --acls) and we would like to consult possible format of listing output even if xattr support is not yet upstream. There are few existing

Re: [Bug-tar] Tar's --xattrs | --selinux | --acls listing feature

2012-05-02 Thread Paul Eggert
Something like that looks reasonable. One major comment, though, is that the output of tar should be parsable, i.e., it should be possible to look at the output, figure out what format it is, and parse it reliably. The current format doesn't have that property, but these extended formats ought