Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-15 Thread Donkey Hottie
14.1.2012 16:57, Marc Deop kirjoitti: ARP: In a traditional ethernet network, when you try to connect to a machine on your local network with the number 10.20.30.40 then your machine will send out an ARP broadcast packet whois 10.20.30.40 and then the machine in question will respond with its

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-15 Thread Marko Vojinovic
On Saturday 14 January 2012 21:43:00 Gordon Messmer wrote: On 01/14/2012 04:19 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: If running mediatomb avoids the necessity for Avahi, can you give a concrete example of a situation where Avahi_is_ needed? I did. If two PCs were running a collaborative editor, like

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Timothy Murphy
Gordon Messmer wrote: Wait a sec, I have that setup (just mediatomb instead of ps3mediaserver) and there's no avahi on my network. Yet the PS3 is perfectly capable of discovering and using the DLNA server. Avahi allows the workstation running it to advertise and solicit mDNS information.

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Timothy Murphy
Gordon Messmer wrote: On 01/11/2012 03:42 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. No, DHCP is used to assign network addresses and routes (and other optional configuration items). According to the Wikipedia entry for mDNS, Using mDNS allows to

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Stephen Harris
On Sat, Jan 14, 2012 at 12:29:05PM +, Timothy Murphy wrote: Gordon Messmer wrote: On 01/11/2012 03:42 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. No, DHCP is used to assign network addresses and routes (and other optional configuration

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Timothy Murphy
Stephen Harris wrote: As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. No, DHCP is used to assign network addresses and routes (and other optional configuration items). According to the Wikipedia entry for mDNS, Using mDNS allows to determine the IP address of a host without

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Mikael Fridh
On Jan 14, 2012 3:18 PM, Timothy Murphy gayle...@eircom.net wrote: Stephen Harris wrote: As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. No, DHCP is used to assign network addresses and routes (and other optional configuration items). According to the Wikipedia entry for

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Stephen Harris
On Sat, Jan 14, 2012 at 02:17:56PM +, Timothy Murphy wrote: OK, I should have said a rival to ARP + dhcp. But it's not; ARP+dhcp is all about mapping MAC-IP. mDNS is dealing with name-IP. mDNS competes with _DNS_; it's a way of doing local DNS without needing a DNS server. As I see it,

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Marc Deop
ARP: In a traditional ethernet network, when you try to connect to a machine on your local network with the number 10.20.30.40 then your machine will send out an ARP broadcast packet whois 10.20.30.40 and then the machine in question will respond with its MAC address and then the machines can talk

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Les Mikesell
On Sat, Jan 14, 2012 at 8:17 AM, Timothy Murphy gayle...@eircom.net wrote: Isn't that more or less what I said above? It's almost the opposite.  mDNS does name-IP and let's people find other machines; DHCP does MAC-IP and let's a machine find _itself_. Or, another way of looking at it.  

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Les Mikesell
On Sat, Jan 14, 2012 at 8:57 AM, Marc Deop damnsh...@gmail.com wrote: ARP: In a traditional ethernet network, when you try to connect to a machine on your local network with the number 10.20.30.40 then your machine will send out an ARP broadcast packet whois 10.20.30.40 and then the machine in

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-14 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 01/14/2012 04:19 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: If running mediatomb avoids the necessity for Avahi, can you give a concrete example of a situation where Avahi_is_ needed? I did. If two PCs were running a collaborative editor, like gobby, they'll use mDNS to find each other. Chat clients such

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-13 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 01/11/2012 03:42 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. No, DHCP is used to assign network addresses and routes (and other optional configuration items). mDNS is used to discover services using IP multicast. Is it only used within local LANs?

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-13 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 01/11/2012 05:40 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: I must admit I'm rather confused by UPnP. UPnP is something completely different. That protocol allows devices behind a NAT router to request that it open a port forward to them. It is commonly used by game consoles to open the ports required for

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-13 Thread Gordon Messmer
On 01/11/2012 05:10 PM, Florin Andrei wrote: Wait a sec, I have that setup (just mediatomb instead of ps3mediaserver) and there's no avahi on my network. Yet the PS3 is perfectly capable of discovering and using the DLNA server. Avahi allows the workstation running it to advertise and solicit

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-13 Thread Les Mikesell
On Fri, Jan 13, 2012 at 12:22 PM, Gordon Messmer yiny...@eburg.com wrote: As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. No, DHCP is used to assign network addresses and routes (and other optional configuration items). There is a larger 'zeroconf' context where if the request to a

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-13 Thread Les Mikesell
On Fri, Jan 13, 2012 at 12:24 PM, Gordon Messmer yiny...@eburg.com wrote: On 01/11/2012 05:40 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: I must admit I'm rather confused by UPnP. UPnP is something completely different.  That protocol allows devices behind a NAT router to request that it open a port forward to

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Timothy Murphy
Rilindo Foster wrote: So I looked up avahi on the web, but as far as I could see it is not doing anything essential; so I was wondering if stopping avahi-daemon would have any bad effect? Avahi is a mdns daemon. You can safely disable it in most cases. But what applications use mdns? As

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread William Warren
On 1/11/2012 6:42 AM, Timothy Murphy wrote: Rilindo Foster wrote: So I looked up avahi on the web, but as far as I could see it is not doing anything essential; so I was wondering if stopping avahi-daemon would have any bad effect? Avahi is a mdns daemon. You can safely disable it in most

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread John R Pierce
On 01/11/12 3:47 AM, William Warren wrote: multicast dns. How it applies to cent though i don't know at this instant. its part of multimedia home network plug and play, I believe... lets media boxes find media servers, and such.if you were to serve up streaming media on a home network,

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Timothy Murphy
William Warren wrote: Avahi is a mdns daemon. You can safely disable it in most cases. But what applications use mdns? As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. Is it only used within local LANs? Is it used, for example, by CUPS to identify printers? When, if ever, would it

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Nicolas Thierry-Mieg
Timothy Murphy wrote: William Warren wrote: Avahi is a mdns daemon. You can safely disable it in most cases. But what applications use mdns? As far as I can see, it is some sort of rival to dhcpd. Is it only used within local LANs? Is it used, for example, by CUPS to identify printers?

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Timothy Murphy
John R Pierce wrote: its part of multimedia home network plug and play, I believe... lets media boxes find media servers, and such.if you were to serve up streaming media on a home network, it would be a useful thing to have. otherwise? meh. Could you give a concrete example of such a

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Les Mikesell
On Wed, Jan 11, 2012 at 7:40 AM, Timothy Murphy gayle...@eircom.net wrote: John R Pierce wrote: its part of multimedia home network plug and play, I believe...  lets media boxes find media servers, and such.    if you were to serve up streaming media on a home network, it would be a useful

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread John R Pierce
On 01/11/12 6:03 AM, Les Mikesell wrote: It is for devices with IP, but to find names that aren't officially registered in a DNS server. For example if you have a Playstation 3, or a newer blu-ray player that supports network streaming it will use DHCP to get an address. But then suppose you

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Peter Brady
On 11/01/12 11:16 PM, John R Pierce wrote: its part of multimedia home network plug and play, I believe... lets media boxes find media servers, and such.if you were to serve up streaming media on a home network, it would be a useful thing to have. otherwise? meh. I use AVAHI for an

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Florin Andrei
On 01/11/2012 06:03 AM, Les Mikesell wrote: It is for devices with IP, but to find names that aren't officially registered in a DNS server. For example if you have a Playstation 3, or a newer blu-ray player that supports network streaming it will use DHCP to get an address. But then suppose

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Warren Young
On 1/11/2012 6:10 PM, Florin Andrei wrote: On 01/11/2012 06:03 AM, Les Mikesell wrote: It is for devices with IP, but to find names that aren't officially registered in a DNS server. For example if you have a Playstation 3, or a newer blu-ray player that supports network streaming it will

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-11 Thread Les Mikesell
On Wed, Jan 11, 2012 at 8:12 PM, Warren Young war...@etr-usa.com wrote: It is for devices with IP, but to find names that aren't officially registered in a DNS server.  For example if you have a Playstation 3, or a newer blu-ray player that supports network streaming it will use DHCP to get

[CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-10 Thread Timothy Murphy
I've been getting a few avahi-daemon errors in /var/log/messages, eg --- Jan 11 00:40:24 helen avahi-daemon[12732]: Invalid query packet. Jan 11 00:40:29 helen last message repeated 17 times

Re: [CentOS] Is avahi essential?

2012-01-10 Thread Rilindo Foster
On Jan 10, 2012, at 7:51 PM, Timothy Murphy gayle...@eircom.net wrote: I've been getting a few avahi-daemon errors in /var/log/messages, eg --- Jan 11 00:40:24 helen avahi-daemon[12732]: Invalid query packet.