Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-07 Thread John Hodrien
On Wed, 6 Apr 2011, Scott Robbins wrote: Not all that unique, but a bit better--I think it's VolumeGroup00/lvm_root, VolumeGroup00/lvm_swap, and things like that. (Keeping both LVs in the same VG by default.) As far as I know it's much better than that: The volume group by default with EL6

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-06 Thread Jussi Hirvi
On 5.4.2011 21.49, compdoc wrote: For reasons of speed and ease of maintenance and backups, what I've settled on is: a small separate drive for the host to boot from, a small separate drive for the guest OSes (I like using qcow2 on WD Raptors), and then a large array on a raid controller for

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-06 Thread John Hodrien
On Wed, 6 Apr 2011, Jussi Hirvi wrote: On 5.4.2011 21.49, compdoc wrote: For reasons of speed and ease of maintenance and backups, what I've settled on is: a small separate drive for the host to boot from, a small separate drive for the guest OSes (I like using qcow2 on WD Raptors), and then

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-05 Thread compdoc
Direct comparisons between the two were difficult to judge, but the general result was that the Host was between 2:1 and 3:1 better than the Guest, which seems to be a rather large performance gap. Latency differences were all over the map, which I find puzzling. The Host is 64-bit and the

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-05 Thread Iain Morris
On Tue, Apr 5, 2011 at 11:49 AM, compdoc comp...@hotrodpc.com wrote: I've been working with VMs for a while now and have tried various ways to set up guests. Block devices can be done with or without LVM, although I've stopped using LVM on my systems these days. Just curious, why have you

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-05 Thread compdoc
Just curious, why have you stopped using LVM? Simply for ease of maintenance: some recovery and backup utilities like clonezilla can't work with LVM. And because the same names for volume groups are used for each centos install, so trying to attach a drive or volume to a new system for

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-05 Thread Scott Robbins
On Tue, Apr 05, 2011 at 08:22:08PM -0600, compdoc wrote: Just curious, why have you stopped using LVM? Simply for ease of maintenance: some recovery and backup utilities like clonezilla can't work with LVM. And because the same names for volume groups are used for each centos install, so

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-04 Thread Chuck Munro
On 04/04/2011 09:00 AM, compdoc wrote: It's possible to set up guests to use a block device that will get you the same disk I/O as the underlying storage. Is that what you're seeing? What speed does the host see when benchmarking the RAID volumes, and what speeds do the guests see? Yes,

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-04 Thread John R Pierce
On 04/04/11 11:32 AM, Chuck Munro wrote: I'd love to hear what other software RAID users think, especially regarding large-capacity drives. It's rare for a modern drive to hand out bad data without an accompanying error condition (which the md driver should handle), but I have read that

[CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-03 Thread Chuck Munro
Hello all, I'm having quite an interesting time getting up to speed with KVM/QEMU and the various ways of creating virtual Guest VMs. But disk I/O performance remains a bit of a question mark for me. I'm looking for suggestions and opinions This new machine has tons of disk space, lots

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-03 Thread Dawid Horacio Golebiewski
List Subject: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance Hello all, I'm having quite an interesting time getting up to speed with KVM/QEMU and the various ways of creating virtual Guest VMs. But disk I/O performance remains a bit of a question mark for me. I'm looking for suggestions and opinions

Re: [CentOS] KVM Host Disk Performance

2011-04-03 Thread compdoc
I'm having quite an interesting time getting up to speed with KVM/QEMU and the various ways of creating virtual Guest VMs. But disk I/O performance remains a bit of a question mark for me. I'm looking for suggestions and opinions It's possible to set up guests to use a block device that