Re: Civil Disobedience, History and Greenpeace

2003-11-03 Thread Keith E. Whittington
Whittington Keith E. Whittington Associate Professor of Politics Director of the Undergraduate Program Corwin Hall Princeton University Princeton, NJ 08544 www.princeton.edu/~kewhitt

Re: Presidents and the Court

2003-10-01 Thread Keith E. Whittington
That would be Andrew Jackson in response to Worcester v. Georgia, and it is generally regarded as apocryphal (though somewhat consistent with other things that he did say, predicting that such a decision would be unenforceable). He did write in a letter, the decision of the supreme court has

Re: Janice Rogers Brown

2003-09-19 Thread Keith E. Whittington
There are similar sounding things (though not those exact quotes) reported in the People for the American Way's brief against Brown's confirmation, which cites unpublished speeches she gave to various organizations and which were on file with the Senate Judiciary Committee. The PAW report

Re: Non-Governmental Emancipation of Slaves Say what?

2003-09-10 Thread Keith E. Whittington
Marshall was a supporter of colonization, including raising money from the federal government and other sources to purchase the freedom of slaves and facilitate their immigration to Africa. He was one of the organizers of the American Society for Colonizing the Free People of Color in 1816

Re: Non-Governmental Emancipation of Slaves Say what?

2003-09-10 Thread Keith E. Whittington
This seems somewhat unfair to Marshall. According to Jean Smith's biography, Marshall, who was not a planter (and thus had little direct stake in the slave economy), owned only a few domestic servants during his lifetime and provided for the manumission of his primary slave in his will

Re: Agenda and persecution of Mormons

2003-07-13 Thread Keith E. Whittington
The end of Mormon polygamy was announced via an 1890 Manifesto by Wilford Woodruff, then president of LDS. A copy can be found on an anti-Mormon website at http://www.polygamyinfo.com/manfesto.htm. A more elaborate discussion of the Manifesto and its follow-up can be found at

Re: The Initiation of Judicial Review

2003-07-01 Thread Keith E. Whittington
ich sense was the term being used? Why would history written after the Civil War be written as 'whiggish' in either sense, come to think of it? Who was doing the writing? Bob Sheridan SFLS - Original Message - From: Keith E. Whittingto

Thomas on privacy

2003-06-26 Thread Keith E. Whittington
rights and other issues; Thomas very distinctly did not, and Biden clearly wasn't very satisfied at the time and thought Thomas at best had a very cramped notion of constitutional privacy rights. I think the real test on this question would have to come in a different case. Keith Whittington Keith E

Re: Texas Pledge of Allegiance

2003-06-17 Thread Keith E. Whittington
Despite Chase's thundering, I notice that the Citizen Handbook on the Texas State Senate page explains that Texas remained a state until 1861 when it seceded from the Union . . [and] was readmitted to the United States in 1870. On the division question, apparently the Reconstruction federal

Re: Texas Pledge of Allegiance

2003-06-16 Thread Keith E. Whittington
The new Texas statute includes a parental option to excuse a student from reciting either pledge. keith whittington -Original Message- From: Discussion list for con law professors [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Gilbert, Lauren Sent: Monday, June 16, 2003 12:15 PM To: [EMAIL