Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-18 Thread James A. Donald
Alex Alten wrote: Generally any standard encrypted protocols will probably eventually have to support some sort of CALEA capability. For example, using a Verisign ICA certificate to do MITM of SSL, or possibly requiring Ebay to provide some sort of legal access to Skype private keys. And

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-18 Thread Ray Dillinger
On Fri, 2008-01-18 at 02:31 -0800, Alex Alten wrote: At 07:35 PM 1/18/2008 +1000, James A. Donald wrote: And all the criminals will of course obey the law. Why not just require them to set an evil flag on all their packets? These are trite responses. Of course not. My point is that

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-18 Thread Jonathan Thornburg
Alex Alten wrote: Generally any standard encrypted protocols will probably eventually have to support some sort of CALEA capability. For example, using a Verisign ICA certificate to do MITM of SSL, or possibly requiring Ebay to provide some sort of legal access to Skype private keys. I can

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-18 Thread Alex Alten
At 07:35 PM 1/18/2008 +1000, James A. Donald wrote: Alex Alten wrote: Generally any standard encrypted protocols will probably eventually have to support some sort of CALEA capability. For example, using a Verisign ICA certificate to do MITM of SSL, or possibly requiring Ebay to provide

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-18 Thread Allen
Alex Alten wrote: [snip] These are trite responses. Of course not. My point is that if the criminals are lazy enough to use a standard security protocol then they can't expect us not to put something in place to decrypt that traffic at will if necessary. [snip] Look, the criminals have

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-14 Thread Sandy Harris
On Jan 12, 2008 9:32 AM, Alex Alten [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Generally any standard encrypted protocols will probably eventually have to support some sort of CALEA capability. ... That's a rather large and distinctly dangerous assumption. Here's the IETF's official line on the question, the

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-14 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
On Fri, 11 Jan 2008 17:32:04 -0800 Alex Alten [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Generally any standard encrypted protocols will probably eventually have to support some sort of CALEA capability. For example, using a Verisign ICA certificate to do MITM of SSL, or possibly requiring Ebay to provide

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-14 Thread lists
From: Alex Alten [EMAIL PROTECTED] Writing in support of CALEA capability to assist prosecuting botnet operators etc ... Generally any standard encrypted protocols will probably eventually have to support some sort of CALEA capability. So you havn't heard that the UK has closed down the

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-04 Thread James A. Donald
Perry E. Metzger wrote: I think Steve is completely correct in the case of cryptography. We have a lot of experience of real world security failures these days, and they're not generally the sort that crypto would fix. They are the sort that a different sort of way of using crypto could fix.

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-04 Thread Dan Kaminsky
Crypto solves certain problems very well. Against others, it's worse than useless -- worse, because it blocks out friendly IDSs as well as hostile parties. Yawn. IDS is dead, has been for a while now. The bottom line discovery has been that: 1) Anomaly detection doesn't work because

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-04 Thread Alex Alten
At 11:23 PM 1/3/2008 +, Steven M. Bellovin wrote: On Thu, 03 Jan 2008 11:52:21 -0500 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The aspect of this that is directly relevant to this list is that while we have labored to make network comms safe in an unsafe transmission medium, the world has now reached

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-03 Thread Ivan Krstić
On Dec 31, 2007, at 4:46 PM, Bill Frantz wrote: My favorite virtual machine use is for the virus to install itself as a virtual machine, and run the OS in the virtual machine. This technique should be really good for hiding from virus scanners. It's not, and despite the press handwaving

virtualizaton and security cfp (was Re: Death of antivirus software imminent)

2008-01-03 Thread Sean W. Smith
With this discussion of virtualization and security, it might be a good time to note: IEEE Security Privacy Special issue on virtualization September/October 2008 Deadline for submissions: 6 February 2008 Visit www.computer.org/portal/pages/security/author.xml to submit a manuscript

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-03 Thread Anne Lynn Wheeler
Leichter, Jerry wrote: Virtualization has become the magic pixie dust of the decade. When IBM originally developed VMM technology, security was not a primary goal. People expected the OS to provide security, and at the time it was believed that OS's would be able to solve the security

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-03 Thread alien
Today's VMMs aren't even designed to fit the formal criteria for a VMM (at least as expressed, intelligently, by Popek and Goldberg back in the 70s). VMM-aware malware leverages this: for example, by making calls to VMware's backdoor communications channel from the guest (ie. jerry.c). If the

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-03 Thread dan
however, another interpretation is that the defenders have chosen extremely poor position to defend ... and are therefor at enormous disadvantage. it may be necessary to change the paradigm (and/or find the high ground) in order to successfully defend. First, it is evident that the

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-03 Thread Bill Frantz
[EMAIL PROTECTED] (Jason) on Wednesday, January 2, 2008 wrote: On the other hand, writing an OS that doesn't get infected in the first place is a fundamentally winning battle: OSes are insecure because people make mistakes, not because they're fundamentally insecurable. I fully agree that a

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-03 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
On Thu, 03 Jan 2008 11:52:21 -0500 [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The aspect of this that is directly relevant to this list is that while we have labored to make network comms safe in an unsafe transmission medium, the world has now reached the point where the odds favor the hypothesis that

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-02 Thread Bill Frantz
On Dec 29, 2007, at 6:37 PM, Anne Lynn Wheeler wrote: Virtualization still hot, death of antivirus software imminent My favorite virtual machine use is for the virus to install itself as a virtual machine, and run the OS in the virtual machine. This technique should be really good for hiding

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-02 Thread Anne Lynn Wheeler
imminent http://www.garlic.com/~lynn/aadsm28.htm#4 Death of antivirus software imminent i commented on that in reference posts mentioning that there have been uses of virtual machines to study virus/trojans ... but that some of the new generation virus/trojans are now looking to see

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-02 Thread Angelos D. Keromytis
in the virtual machine. This technique should be really good for hiding from virus scanners. re: http://www.garlic.com/~lynn/aadsm28.htm#2 Death of antivirus software imminent http://www.garlic.com/~lynn/aadsm28.htm#4 Death of antivirus software imminent i commented on that in reference posts

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2008-01-02 Thread Leichter, Jerry
Virtualization has become the magic pixie dust of the decade. When IBM originally developed VMM technology, security was not a primary goal. People expected the OS to provide security, and at the time it was believed that OS's would be able to solve the security problems. As far as I know, the

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2007-12-31 Thread Sherri Davidoff
Anne Lynn Wheeler wrote: Virtualization still hot, death of antivirus software imminent, VC says http://www.networkworld.com/news/2007/121707-crystal-ball-virtualization.html Interesting how virtualization seems to imply safe in the public mind (and explicitly in that article) right now

Re: Death of antivirus software imminent

2007-12-31 Thread Ivan Krstić
On Dec 29, 2007, at 6:37 PM, Anne Lynn Wheeler wrote: Virtualization still hot, death of antivirus software imminent My, that sounds awfully familiar: http://radian.org/~krstic/talks/2007/auscert/slides.pdf I note that, come the January OLPC software update, I will be using my XO laptop

Death of antivirus software imminent

2007-12-30 Thread Anne Lynn Wheeler
Virtualization still hot, death of antivirus software imminent, VC says http://www.networkworld.com/news/2007/121707-crystal-ball-virtualization.html from above: Another trend Maeder predicts for 2008 is, at long last, the death of antivirus software and other security products that allow employees