Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Steven M. Bellovin
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Perry E. Metzger writes: I don't know anyone who trades video files -- they're pretty big and bulky. A song takes moments to download, but a movie takes many many hours even on a high speed link. I have yet to meet someone who pirates films -- but I know lots of

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Sandy Harris
Pete Chown wrote: John S. Denker wrote: Note that in the absence of market segmentation, the society as a whole is worse off. I see what you mean, but do you think it applies to DVDs? The segmentation needs to be in each market, between rich and poor consumers. What we actually have is

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread bear
On Tue, 7 Jan 2003, alan wrote: Not to mention the two seasons of Futurama that are only available on Region 2 PAL DVDs. (Or the other movies and TV shows not allowed by your corporate masters.) They Live is another film only available from Region 2. Maybe it tells too much about the

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread James A. Donald
-- I wote: I pirate films routinely Correction. I watch made for TV shows distributed through the internet routinely. Full length films are not shared to any great extent, because their sheer size makes them such a pain. --digsig James A. Donald

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Pete Chown
Eric Rescorla wrote: No, this isn't true. Say that Americans are willing to pay 50% more for DVDs than Europeans. It would make sense for producers to attempt to segment the market. You are right that producers would want to segment the market, but we have no reason to introduce extra laws to

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread John Gilmore
The truly amazing thing about this case is that the crime would not have occured if the studios had used decently-strong crypto. It's ironic that in an age when for cryptographers enjoy a historically-unprecedented lopsided advantage over cryptanalysts, the industry adopted a system that

Re: DeCSS, crypto, (regions removed??!)

2003-01-08 Thread Martin Olsson
Hi, I dont know if this is relevant to the discussion, but in Sweden (not a region-1 country) people where so pissed at the regionsystem (and the fact that most computer geeks could go around it, but the average person could not) that the whole region concept had to be removed. Ie. this forced

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Eric Rescorla
Pete Chown [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: One last point is that governments serve the interests primarily of their own people. So the job of Britain's government is to get me, and other Brits, the best possible deal on films within the UK. This might mean balancing the interests of British

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread bear
On Wed, 8 Jan 2003, Pete Chown wrote: One last point is that governments serve the interests primarily of their own people. So the job of Britain's government is to get me, and other Brits, the best possible deal on films within the UK. This might mean balancing the interests of British

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Ed Gerck
Nomen Nescio wrote: John S. Denker writes: The main thing the industry really had at stake in this case is the zone locking aka region code system. I don't see much evidence for this. As you go on to admit, multi-region players are easily available overseas. You seem to be claiming

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Eric Rescorla
Karsten M. Self [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: on Tue, Jan 07, 2003 at 04:10:27PM -0800, Eric Rescorla ([EMAIL PROTECTED]) wrote: However, if he can price discriminate, he can sell two copies, one at 3 and one at 6. This makes it profitable for him to produce the book.

Re: Pretty Good Update for E-Mail Privacy

2003-01-08 Thread Udhay Shankar N
At 10:03 AM 1/7/03 -0500, R. A. Hettinga wrote: http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn/A8488-2003Jan3?language=printer washingtonpost.com Pretty Good Update for E-Mail Privacy snip Are there any reasonably up-to-date comparisions of PGP and GPG around? *Especially* with regard to the

[p2p-hackers] Anonymity tutorial at MIT, Wed Jan 15, 7-10pm (fwd)

2003-01-08 Thread R. A. Hettinga
--- begin forwarded text Status: RO Mailing-List: contact [EMAIL PROTECTED]; run by ezmlm Date: Wed, 8 Jan 2003 23:38:14 +0100 (CET) From: Eugen Leitl [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: [p2p-hackers] Anonymity tutorial at MIT, Wed Jan 15, 7-10pm (fwd) -- -- Eugen* Leitl a

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Matt Blaze
Isn't it about a million times more probable that the industry's main concern was PEOPLE RIPPING DVDS AND TRADING THE FILES? Well, zone locking helps curb this because it *reduces* the market for each copy. The finer the zone locking resolution, the more effort an attacker needs to make

Re: DeCSS, crypto, law, and economics

2003-01-08 Thread Sandy Harris
John Gilmore wrote: For normal products, market segmentation is neither forbidden by law nor protected by law. ... The law is silent on the issue. This is false. Market segmentation by country is deliberately outlawed by free trade laws and treaties, which exist to benefit consumers by