Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-08-24 Thread Brian Potkin
tags 616718 + moreinfo thanks On Sun 06 Mar 2011 at 13:28:13 -0800, Aaron Barany wrote: Package: cups Version: 1.4.4-7 Severity: important After a fresh install of cups, if I attempt to add a printer from http://localhost:631; I get a forbidden error. This occurs on the first page

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
Hello Jonathan, You wrote: so presumably I ought to add myself to group lpadmin. But in any event, the inability to get back to step 2 (the dialog box allowing me to choose a username and password) is puzzling. If you repeated your first two steps but in step 3 gave an incorrect

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Brian Potkin wrote: Now you try again. The first stage is not repeated because PAM is to be trusted and would get upset if CUPS kept querying its decisions. Which is why you do not get the dialogue box back. CUPS already knows your status regarding group membership so just keeps pointing to

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 13:52:55 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: Brian Potkin wrote: Now you try again. The first stage is not repeated because PAM is to be trusted and would get upset if CUPS kept querying its decisions. Which is why you do not get the dialogue box back. CUPS already knows

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
tags 616718 + upstream quit Brian Potkin wrote: The 'Forbidden' message came as a result of the design of CUPS. In that sense it is not a bug, unless the implementation is lacking. The easy fix, of course, is lpadmin membership. Design bugs are still bugs. :) Thanks for investigating. --

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:04:13 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: Brian Potkin wrote: The 'Forbidden' message came as a result of the design of CUPS. In that sense it is not a bug, unless the implementation is lacking. The easy fix, of course, is lpadmin membership. Design bugs are still

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Brian Potkin wrote: On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:04:13 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: Design bugs are still bugs. :) Indeed. But that isn't the substance of this bug report. Ok, let's consider this for a second. The original submitter reported that there were (to him) mysterious Forbidden

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Brian Potkin
On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:30:48 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: Brian Potkin wrote: On Wed 21 Mar 2012 at 15:04:13 -0500, Jonathan Nieder wrote: Design bugs are still bugs. :) Indeed. But that isn't the substance of this bug report. Ok, let's consider this for a second. The original

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2012-03-21 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Brian Potkin wrote: I think we are agreed though that it is upstream which would have to deal with it. No, I disagree with that. It is affected users or kind hackers working on their behalf that would have to deal with it, by writing a patch and reporting this

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2011-03-24 Thread Jonathan Nieder
Hi, Aaron Barany wrote: After a fresh install of cups, if I attempt to add a printer from http://localhost:631; I get a forbidden error. This occurs on the first page before I have a chance to add any information. I tried something similar with cups 1.4.6-3. Here's what I did: 1. Visit

Bug#616718: cups: Attempting to add a printer gives a forbidden error

2011-03-06 Thread Aaron Barany
Package: cups Version: 1.4.4-7 Severity: important After a fresh install of cups, if I attempt to add a printer from http://localhost:631; I get a forbidden error. This occurs on the first page before I have a chance to add any information. -- System Information: Debian Release: 6.0 APT