Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-15 Thread Toby Speight
Tags: patch thanks Despite Jamie's misgivings, I believe it's possible to provide the functionality I need without inconvenience users who like the existing action; I attached a patch that adds a config file option leaveDpmsAlone (no UI or documentation - I could perhaps have a stab at that later

Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-15 Thread Jamie Zawinski
Sorry, I think this is only going to confuse people. Applications should not have UI elements that just magically get ignored if some forgotten text-only preference is set. I'm not going to install this patch upstream. -- To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-bugs-dist-requ...@lists.debian.org

Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-15 Thread Toby Speight
Jamie == Jamie Zawinski j...@jwz.org writes: Jamie Sorry, I think this is only going to confuse people. Jamie Applications should not have UI elements that just magically Jamie get ignored if some forgotten text-only preference is set. Jamie I'm not going to install this patch

Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-14 Thread Toby Speight
Jamie == Jamie Zawinski j...@jwz.org writes: Jamie Intended behavior. Won't fix. It's impossible to allow use Jamie of both xset and a GUI and know which setting should take Jamie priority, since changes to settings don't have timestamps on Jamie them. Therefore, xscreensaver

Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-14 Thread Jamie Zawinski
I'm not asking to use both xset and a GUI; I'm asking to to use only xset, and have the GUI leave DPMS well alone. At present, there's a ./configure option to do so, but no run-time equivalent. I understand what you're asking for. You want this, but more people want the opposite. Sorry, but

Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-13 Thread Toby Speight
Package: xscreensaver Version: 5.15-2 Severity: wishlist XScreenSaver imposes its idea of DPMS settings every time it does something. However, I prefer to set DPMS externally (in particular, I set a much shorter timeout when away, according to pam-usb). One might expect that setting the

Bug#659802: xscreensaver: Option to leave DPMS alone

2012-02-13 Thread Jamie Zawinski
Intended behavior. Won't fix. It's impossible to allow use of both xset and a GUI and know which setting should take priority, since changes to settings don't have timestamps on them. Therefore, xscreensaver has to be 100% in charge of these settings for it to work at all. -- To