Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-27 Thread Ralph
[maximilian attems] if you change fstab you have to also pass the corresponding bootflag. if you have manualy set this, you just have to fix your bootloader. if debian installer sets it which i don't know, then it is up to debian installer to pass the right rootflags. Changing fstab has no

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-27 Thread Peter Samuelson
[Ralph] There should be a hint written as a comment in /etc/fstab that some mount options modifying the rootfs only have an effect via bootflag or initrd ! For most flags, it does not matter. The initrd mounts the root filesystem read-only, but early in the boot process, an init script runs

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-27 Thread maximilian attems
On Fri, Mar 27, 2009 at 04:21:21PM +0100, Ralph wrote: [maximilian attems] if you change fstab you have to also pass the corresponding bootflag. if you have manualy set this, you just have to fix your bootloader. if debian installer sets it which i don't know, then it is up to debian

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-19 Thread maximilian attems
On Wed, 18 Mar 2009, Peter Samuelson wrote: So, if I understand you correctly, the reason you can't fix this is because you have no desire to support a configuration that was not produced by debian-installer? well your usage falls under advanced messing with your box, so i'd expect such a

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-18 Thread maximilian attems
On Tue, 17 Mar 2009, Peter Samuelson wrote: initramfs-tools should not pick up data= from /etc/fstab, but it does not. [maximilian attems] too many negations in one line, what are you trying to say? Yes, I meant to say: initramfs-tools should pick up data= from /etc/fstab, but

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-17 Thread maximilian attems
On Mon, 16 Mar 2009, Peter Samuelson wrote: However, it also has a restriction that you cannot change the 'data=' parameter with 'remount'. Therefore, you have to pass the correct one at initial mount time, even though the data= parameter does not directly affect a read-only fs. If you

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-17 Thread Peter Samuelson
initramfs-tools should not pick up data= from /etc/fstab, but it does not. [maximilian attems] too many negations in one line, what are you trying to say? Yes, I meant to say: initramfs-tools should pick up data= from /etc/fstab, but it does not. The workaround is 'rootflags=data=foo'

Bug#520009: ext3 'data=foo' on root fs is broken

2009-03-16 Thread Peter Samuelson
Package: initramfs-tools Version: 0.92o Severity: normal ext3 includes mount option 'data={ordered,writeback,journal}'. However, it also has a restriction that you cannot change the 'data=' parameter with 'remount'. Therefore, you have to pass the correct one at initial mount time, even though