Re: mplayer / divx

2001-08-30 Thread John Galt
The sperry patent is international. http://www.cpe.surrey.ac.uk/support/faq/gif_lzw.htm The funny part is the selfsame stuff that makes GIF viewers non-free is blithely in gzip. Ah well, consistency has never been a hallmark of patents WRT non-free. On Wed, 29 Aug 2001, Hamish Moffatt wrote:

patents and non-free

2001-08-30 Thread Edmund GRIMLEY EVANS
John Galt [EMAIL PROTECTED]: The funny part is the selfsame stuff that makes GIF viewers non-free is blithely in gzip. Ah well, consistency has never been a hallmark of patents WRT non-free. Does Debian have any kind of policy on patents at all? Some random observations and questions:

Re: patents and non-free

2001-08-30 Thread jcdubacq
On Thu, 30 Aug 2001, Edmund GRIMLEY EVANS wrote: Nothing in the DFSG seems to refer to patents, so I don't see how a patent can make a program non-free in the DFSG sense. Also, the USA isn't the only country in the world to have software patents (there's also Japan), so non-us doesn't seem

Re: patents and non-free

2001-08-30 Thread Joseph Carter
On Thu, Aug 30, 2001 at 12:14:44PM +0100, Edmund GRIMLEY EVANS wrote: The funny part is the selfsame stuff that makes GIF viewers non-free is blithely in gzip. Ah well, consistency has never been a hallmark of patents WRT non-free. Does Debian have any kind of policy on patents at all?

Re: patents and non-free

2001-08-30 Thread Edmund GRIMLEY EVANS
[EMAIL PROTECTED] [EMAIL PROTECTED]: Nothing in the DFSG seems to refer to patents, so I don't see how a patent can make a program non-free in the DFSG sense. Also, the USA isn't the only country in the world to have software patents (there's also Japan), so non-us doesn't seem very

Re: patents and non-free

2001-08-30 Thread Will Newton
On Thursday 30 Aug 2001 1:14 pm, Joseph Carter wrote: Now maybe that's probably reaching a little bit given the fact that the judges seem to be too easily swayed by lawyers who make more in a week than some of us make in a year, but it's also reaching to say that laws designed to keep other

Re: patents and non-free

2001-08-30 Thread Raul Miller
On Thu, Aug 30, 2001 at 12:14:44PM +0100, Edmund GRIMLEY EVANS wrote: Does Debian have any kind of policy on patents at all? Debian's policy on patents has been to deal with them on a case-by-case basis. [1] It's not possible for any software vendor anywhere to avoid infringing patents. That

Re: mplayer / divx

2001-08-30 Thread Steve Greenland
On 29-Aug-01, 23:08 (CDT), John Galt [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The funny part is the selfsame stuff that makes GIF viewers non-free is blithely in gzip. Ah well, consistency has never been a hallmark of patents WRT non-free. You're confused. There are plenty of GIF viewers in us/main. The