On Sun, 27 May 2007 10:21:26 +1000 Ben Finney wrote:
Matthew Johnson [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes:
what if the recording was of actual people playing actual
instruments? You know, like people always used to. How to you
generate that from 'source' at build time? what _is_ the source?
The
On Fri, 25 May 2007 11:30:07 -0400 Nathanael Nerode wrote:
Francesco Poli wrote:
We must determine what is the preferred form for making modifications
to the song. I'm not sure an Ogg Vorbis + MIDI form qualifies...
[...]
I believe that for a recording to be DFSG-free, we need *both*
Francesco Poli wrote:
Now, it would be preferable to be able to regenerate the
recording from the MIDI. Which would mean including the
soundfonts (instrument descriptions, basically) used. So the question
of whether they are free is also important.
Really important, IMO.
Francesco Poli wrote:
We must determine what is the preferred form for making modifications to
the song. I'm not sure an Ogg Vorbis + MIDI form qualifies...
What sort of modifications?
...Actually, a concept from copyright law may help here. There are
*two* copyrights on any given recording.
On Sun, 13 May 2007 01:06:01 +0100 (BST) MJ Ray wrote:
Francesco Poli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
[...]
There's another issue with the remaining four songs, though.
Is their source available?
I mean: what's the preferred form[1] for making modifications to the
songs? Is this form
--- Francesco Poli [EMAIL PROTECTED] escribió:
We must determine what is the preferred form for making modifications to
the song. I'm not sure an Ogg Vorbis + MIDI form qualifies...
I think that's quite complex to decide on a single-game basis, as that
decision might affect most of other
On Sun, 13 May 2007 19:11:32 +0200 (CEST) Miriam Ruiz wrote:
--- Francesco Poli [EMAIL PROTECTED] escribió:
We must determine what is the preferred form for making
modifications to the song. I'm not sure an Ogg Vorbis + MIDI form
qualifies...
I think that's quite complex to decide
Francesco Poli [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
However, if the author says that it's a metal version of Ryu's theme, I
think he means that the melody is the same, even though the musical
genre is changed.
*If* this is the case, I would call it a cover and hence I'm afraid it
qualifies as an
8 matches
Mail list logo
