how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Frank Küster
Hi, Summary: If there's a file in one of my packages that only declares to be in the public domain, do I have to contact the author and let him clarify this, or can I leave things as they are? I recall to have been told that, in order to make a piece of software free, it is not sufficient to

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Patrick Herzig
Maybe this thread helps: http://lists.debian.org/debian-legal/2005/06/msg00018.html On 30/03/06, Frank Küster [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi, Summary: If there's a file in one of my packages that only declares to be in the public domain, do I have to contact the author and let him clarify

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Frank Küster
Patrick Herzig [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Maybe this thread helps: http://lists.debian.org/debian-legal/2005/06/msg00018.html Sorry, not really (or I've missed the relevant mails). I read a lot about whether public domain licenses work as they are intended, and something about how to properly

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread JC Helary
On 2006/03/30, at 21:04, Frank Küster wrote: On the other hand, I have learned meanwhile that in some legislations the term Public Domain does indeed have a defined meaning. From this I would conclude that declaring something Public Domain should be sufficient, and that effectively no

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Frank Küster
JC Helary [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Public domain is clearly defined in copyright law, and that should be so in any country that has any kind of copyright law. I fear there are a couple of countries that didn't obey your should. Copyright only extends to a certain period of time after which

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Batist Paklons
This file is in the public domain is sufficient in Belgian legislation, and in any droit d'auteur legislation I know of. sincerely, Batist On 30/03/06, Frank Küster [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi, Summary: If there's a file in one of my packages that only declares to be in the public domain,

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Don Armstrong
On Thu, 30 Mar 2006, Frank Küster wrote: JC Helary [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Public domain is clearly defined in copyright law, and that should be so in any country that has any kind of copyright law. I fear there are a couple of countries that didn't obey your should. And all that

Re: Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Nathanael Nerode
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: And all that doesn't answer my question: Whether it's debian-legal's consensus that This file is in the public domain grants us enough rights to distribute it in main, or non-free, or not at all. It's good enough, if it's placed there by the author/former copyright

Re: how to properly specify Public Domain?

2006-03-30 Thread Frank Küster
Don Armstrong [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: If you've got the time to communicate with the author to request that, it'd be good. Otherwise, I don't believe the ftpmasters are requiring this from public domain works yet. Thank you, and to Nathanael. I'll interpret that as note that down, but care