Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-14 Thread Ole Streicher
Francesco Poli invernom...@paranoici.org writes: I am not aware of any update on the matter: I suppose the determination of the effective licenses of binary packages is still something to be done manually. I hope this answers Ole's question, although maybe in a disappointing way... I am not

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-14 Thread Riley Baird
On 14/11/14 19:19, Ole Streicher wrote: Francesco Poli invernom...@paranoici.org writes: I am not aware of any update on the matter: I suppose the determination of the effective licenses of binary packages is still something to be done manually. I hope this answers Ole's question, although

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-14 Thread Ben Finney
Ole Streicher oleb...@debian.org writes: I am not sure if this is legally so simple: As far as I understand licensing, it is the way to allow others to use the product (sorry for unprofessional wording here; I am not at all a specialist in that). Good enough; I'd just replace the term “use”

License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Ole Streicher
Hi, I asked this question already some months ago in debian-mentors, but didn't get an answer: How is the license of a binary Debian package determined? The file debian/copyright only contains the license of the sources; however the binary license may differ -- f.e. when a BSD source is linked

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Riley Baird
How is the license of a binary Debian package determined? The file debian/copyright only contains the license of the sources; however the binary license may differ -- f.e. when a BSD source is linked to a GPL library. Also there is usually more than one license used in the sources. I'd say

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Ben Finney
Ole Streicher oleb...@debian.org writes: How is the license of a binary Debian package determined? The file debian/copyright only contains the license of the sources; Not true. The ‘debian/copyright’ file is installed by each binary package ‘foopackage’ as the

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Riley Baird
however the binary license may differ -- f.e. when a BSD source is linked to a GPL library. Also there is usually more than one license used in the sources. Right, so the source package should have a ‘debian/copyright’ which specifies copyright information for all binary packages generated

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Francesco Poli
? Not that I know of, unfortunately. Hopefully someone else will have an idea. [...] I am not aware of any requirement (in the current Debian Policy) to document the effective license for binary packages. The debian/copyright file is intended for clearly documenting the licensing status

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Francesco Poli
On Thu, 13 Nov 2014 21:43:10 +0100 Francesco Poli wrote: [...] The debian/copyright file is intended for clearly documenting the licensing status of source packages, not the effective licenses of binary packages built from them. [...] Mmmmh, I wrote this too fast, on the basis of what was

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Charles Plessy
Le Thu, Nov 13, 2014 at 05:35:00PM +0100, Ole Streicher a écrit : I asked this question already some months ago in debian-mentors, but didn't get an answer: How is the license of a binary Debian package determined? The file debian/copyright only contains the license of the sources;

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread David Prévot
Hi, Le 13/11/2014 16:37, Ben Finney a écrit : The file debian/copyright only contains the license of the sources; Not true. That’s a strong affirmation. Policy 4.5 may deserve some clarification, but I wouldn’t be so affirmative (or negative).

Re: License of binary packages

2014-11-13 Thread Ben Finney
David Prévot taf...@debian.org writes: Le 13/11/2014 16:37, Ben Finney a écrit : The ‘debian/copyright’ file is installed by each binary package ‘foopackage’ as the ‘/usr/share/doc/foopackage/copyright’ file, and constitutes the copyright information for that binary package. That’s an