Re: CLUEBAT: copyrights, infringement, violations, and legality

2003-01-29 Thread Alessandro Rubini
reconsider using the term intellectual property http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/words-to-avoid.html#IntellectualProperty The problem here is that no alternatives are suggested. We in Italy tendo to use intellectual patrimony (like heritage) or intellectual paternity (like parenthood), according

Re: CLUEBAT: copyrights, infringement, violations, and legality

2003-01-29 Thread Alessandro Rubini
According to how I read the FSF's page, the problem is not avoided by using another phrase to replace intellectual property. You are right. But I think I am too :) Any opinions you convey about copyright (for instance) probably are not true for patents, and vice versa. Definitely. I am

Re: Knoppix and GPL

2003-04-29 Thread Alessandro Rubini
Klaus Knopper: Is nobody gettng tired of this topic? I thought we already cleared things up. The written offer is present on each CD, which complies to the GPL. I have an email from Dave Turner from the FSF stating that Knoppix IS in compliance with the GPL. Is there anything more to

Re: [OT] Droit d'auteur vs. free software?

2003-05-22 Thread Alessandro Rubini
For Duchamp, violating the Mona Lisa was an integral part of the artistic statement being made. Whatever Duchamp has done, I'm sure he did it more than 50 (70) years after Leonardo died. He drew mustaches on a photograph of the painting, I think, and exposed it. He could show his

Re: Bug#282667: microcode.ctl: License clarification request: the microcode update file can't be distributed the way it is

2004-11-24 Thread Alessandro Rubini
2- Debian distributes an operating System, so we are allowed to distribute it. Maybe it's just that English is not my mother tongue, but I just can't help my reading the license statement as meaning: ``These microcode updates are distributed for the sole purpose of installation in

Re: GPL and command-line libraries

2004-12-05 Thread Alessandro Rubini
Henning Makholm (with my emphasis): If library L provides to program P an well-defined generic service with a simple black-box interface, and it is provided in a way that is essentially independent that the client is P rather than an unrelated program Q, then I think it is very hard to argue

Re: Doubts regarding the GPLv(2,3) compatibility of libpcap

2007-09-16 Thread Alessandro Rubini
* 3. All advertising materials mentioning features or use of this software *must display the following acknowledgement: * This product includes software developed by Yen Yen Lim and North Dakota State University * 4. The name of the author may not be used to endorse or

Re: Inappropriate use of Debian logo.

2010-11-28 Thread Alessandro Rubini
FYI - A computer shop has taken the Debian logo and used it for his business. http://imgur.com/gFKfs.jpg Thank you for making this jpeg, it's very clear. [...] The comapny Logo was created by photoshop and Logo software, we desgined it from the stretch. if you have somethins to say, give

Re: Inappropriate use of Debian logo.

2010-12-01 Thread Alessandro Rubini
Can it really be reasonable, in any sense of the word, to believe that this company would independently invent an identical logo, pixel for pixel, changing only the hue. No, not reasonable. Unless both copied from the same swirl. Which seems reasonable. See

Re: Lawyer request stop from downloading Debian

2011-04-26 Thread Alessandro Rubini
[...] Calling the German lawyer to find out who are his client might be a good idea. I heard from other sources, which I consider trustworthy, that this was discovered to be a fake letter, sent as a sort of bad joke. Therefore, the specific case is of no real interest, although I agree that

Re: picviz license (generated images as derivative work ?)

2012-02-25 Thread Alessandro Rubini
Note that the GPL places important restrictions on derived works, yet it does not provide a detailed definition of that term. It's so on purpose: it's copyright law that says what is a derived work. Authors can't extend the reach of their rights at will. At least when they don't sell devices

Re: Free as in speech, but not as in beer

2015-04-01 Thread Alessandro Rubini
[...] However, your intention is to apply a non-legally enforcable restriction that, were it in a license, would immediately and obviously fail the DFSG, [...] you are trying to (non-legally) force Debian to adopt a licensing scheme contrary to its values. How heated. This is exactly like