Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-21 Thread Dom
On 21/04/11 02:56, Stan Hoeppner wrote: Dom put forth on 4/20/2011 1:25 PM: I run Smoothwall on an old Athlon (K6) system that I was given. I The K7 is the original Athlon. The K6 series chips had no marketing name other than K6, i.e. K6, K6-2, K6-2+, K6-3, K6-3+, etc. The only issue I

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed [question]

2011-04-21 Thread Klistvud
Thanx to all who shared their thoughts, you've been really helpful guys (as always). As many pointed out, the crux of the question is my ISP who's only giving me one IP number. You've helped me understand why a switch won't do and why a router is needed. So, for the time being, I will

[OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Klistvud
Howdie, fellow Debianites! Any networking guru lurking on the list? Here's the situation. There's basically two (interrelated) families sharing our broadband connection. In the other family, there's this person who's downloading large numbers of files around the clock. As we've just

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Jochen Schulz
Klistvud: And here's what I need advice for: I'm planning to purchase a wired (consumer grade) switch since I've heard they're inherently more robust than (consumer grade) routers, and I'm planning to connect it *directly* to our cable broadband modem. Then, the two families would connect

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Klistvud
Dne, 20. 04. 2011 11:25:27 je Jochen Schulz napisal(a): Klistvud: And here's what I need advice for: I'm planning to purchase a wired (consumer grade) switch since I've heard they're inherently more robust than (consumer grade) routers, and I'm planning to connect it *directly* to our cable

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Russell L. Harris
* Jochen Schulz m...@well-adjusted.de [110420 05:48]: Klistvud: And here's what I need advice for: You are looking for a router (OSI layer 3), not a switch (OSI layer 2). It needs to have three distinct interfaces (1xWAN, 2xLAN). If it runs ... I think even a simple Linksys WRT54GL would

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Jochen Schulz
Klistvud: Dne, 20. 04. 2011 11:25:27 je Jochen Schulz napisal(a): Klistvud: I'm planning to purchase a wired (consumer grade) switch since I've heard they're inherently more robust than (consumer grade) routers, and I'm planning to connect it *directly* to our cable broadband modem. Then,

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Tom Furie
On Wed, Apr 20, 2011 at 01:08:22PM +0200, Klistvud wrote: Unfortunately, there are many posts on the Internet affirming that such a configuration can't and won't work, because a switch can't give out two IP's if your ISP just gives you one. So, in doubt, I This is the crucial point. If your

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Andrew McGlashan
Hi, Klistvud wrote: I'm planning to purchase a wired (consumer grade) switch since I've heard they're inherently more robust than (consumer grade) routers, and I'm planning to connect it *directly* to our cable broadband modem. Then, the two families would connect their respective routers (we

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed [question]

2011-04-20 Thread Paul E Condon
On 20110421_003957, Andrew McGlashan wrote: Hi, Klistvud wrote: I'm planning to purchase a wired (consumer grade) switch since I've heard they're inherently more robust than (consumer grade) routers, and I'm planning to connect it *directly* to our cable broadband modem. Then, the two

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed [question]

2011-04-20 Thread PaulNM
Paul E Condon wrote: Andrew, I'm lurking here, looking to better understand a problem that I've never had to confront: NAT, I understand requires translation tables, one entry for each active tcp connection. This takes RAM. It also takes enough CPU cycles to maintain this table --- set

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Ron Johnson
On 04/20/2011 06:08 AM, Klistvud wrote: [snip] What I had in mind is something like this: http://www.ehow.com/how_6823201_use-switch-hub-instead-router.html . Unfortunately, there are many posts on the Internet affirming that such a configuration can't and won't work, because a switch can't

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Dom
On 20/04/11 18:52, Ron Johnson wrote: On 04/20/2011 06:08 AM, Klistvud wrote: [snip] What I had in mind is something like this: http://www.ehow.com/how_6823201_use-switch-hub-instead-router.html . Unfortunately, there are many posts on the Internet affirming that such a configuration can't and

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Stan Hoeppner
Dom put forth on 4/20/2011 1:25 PM: I run Smoothwall on an old Athlon (K6) system that I was given. I The K7 is the original Athlon. The K6 series chips had no marketing name other than K6, i.e. K6, K6-2, K6-2+, K6-3, K6-3+, etc. The only issue I have is that the latest upgrade to Smoothwall

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed [question]

2011-04-20 Thread Andrew McGlashan
Hi Paul, Paul E Condon wrote: I'm lurking here, looking to better understand a problem that I've never had to confront: NAT, I understand requires translation tables, one entry for each active tcp connection. This takes RAM. It also takes enough CPU cycles to maintain this table --- set up

Re: [OT] Purchasing a wired switch; advice needed

2011-04-20 Thread Zoran Kolic
Howdy! I already found good advice in one of the posts on your question. Personally, I'd stick with pair of linksys wrt54gl, putting dd-wrt on both or three of them and ma- king it do the work. The site has tutorials for all of situations one might experience. For another approach, there is better