Re: [Bug 586660] Re: Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume

2010-08-03 Thread Tudor Holton
I am *not* arguing that zero volume and mute should be the same. I am arguing that, when the speaker is mute, and the user requests to *increase* the volume, that that increase should be assumed to mean from zero volume, because, at that point, there is no sound, and the term increase is

[Bug 586660] Re: Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume

2010-08-02 Thread Dana Goyette
I disagree. Just because something is consistent, that doesn't mean it is sensible or intuitive. That may be true, but it's far more likely to find something INconsistent, confusing and counter-intuitive. I would likely find it impossible to adapt to your desired behavior. Every device I've

[Bug 586660] Re: Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume

2010-05-27 Thread Daniel T Chen
** Package changed: pulseaudio (Ubuntu) = gnome-media (Ubuntu) ** Changed in: gnome-media (Ubuntu) Importance: Undecided = Wishlist -- Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/586660 You received this bug notification because you are a member of

[Bug 586660] Re: Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume

2010-05-27 Thread David Henningsson
Even if the argument might make sense, the current behavior is consistent with every volume controller I know, e g the one on my TV, so I guess this is a won't fix. -- Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/586660 You received this bug notification

Re: [Bug 586660] Re: Increase volume after mute defaults to previous volume

2010-05-27 Thread Tudor Holton
I disagree. Just because something is consistent, that doesn't mean it is sensible or intuitive. On 28/05/10 14:54, David Henningsson wrote: Even if the argument might make sense, the current behavior is consistent with every volume controller I know, e g the one on my TV, so I guess this is