Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-05-01 Thread giovanni
WLBL code currently committed in trunk seems fully functional to me and I cannot spot any issues. I am currently running trunk r1900387 on a server and r1899446 on all other servers. Just updated to rc1 most servers without issues so far. kb@ told me that he has better code for

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Kevin A. McGrail
It's not a commit war. I rescind my request to go away from rtc. I will work to see what we can escalate on the known issues. On Sat, Apr 30, 2022, 19:04 Sidney Markowitz wrote: > This is wrong, from the point of view of proper process. > > I'm glad you are accepting "fault", Kevin, "for not

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Sidney Markowitz
This is wrong, from the point of view of proper process. I'm glad you are accepting "fault", Kevin, "for not being more communicative", but the process is that we have issues that are opened in Bugzilla, work on them is coordinated in the comments of those issues, issues that we decide to

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Henrik K
I don't understand what you refer to with different ways? There's commands and functions that can be renamed in only one way. What is the current trunk lacking compared to your patch? On Sat, Apr 30, 2022 at 12:39:43PM -0400, Kevin A. McGrail wrote: > The switch to making sure that the

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Kevin A. McGrail
The switch to making sure that the patches were without any issues led to significant delays. To my knowledge there is nobody testing the code in any live production systems. I expect we will find bugs because of that. As I said the fault is mine for not being more communicative. But yes right

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Henrik K
Why are you expecting massive issues? I completed all the WLBL work in few days in meticulous detail, there's extensive tests and many people tested it. I think there was about one alias that was missing which Giovanni noticed (cheers). I would have rather not participated, but as you went

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Kevin A. McGrail
Well it was out fault for working on diffs and not giving visibility. Others then did work on some of the same bugs in a new branch. We are reconciling it against the same work others did on the WLBL, for example. And I expect with RC1 to find some pretty massive issues there since I don't think

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Henrik K
Wtf? If you or someone have "giant diffs" or work being done, then post them on the appropriate bugs, reopening if necessary. I don't understand why even waste time posting something vague like this. On Sat, Apr 30, 2022 at 09:50:15AM -0400, Kevin A. McGrail wrote: > Should we delay RTC? I

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Kevin A. McGrail
Should we delay RTC? I know there are some bugs being worked on in some of the bugs that have been closed. I also know there's some patches that Giovanni might or might not have gotten to for the WLBL. We had a giant diff for that was collided. On Sat, Apr 30, 2022, 05:55 Axb wrote: > Doh!

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Axb
Doh! Henrik already did it. Thanks! On 4/30/22 11:52, Axb wrote: Should we update 20_aux_tlds.cf for this relesase? I can't do it at the moment - any taker? On 4/30/22 11:27, Sidney Markowitz wrote: It's time for a code freeze in preparation for the release of 4.0.0 release candidates.

Re: Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Axb
Should we update 20_aux_tlds.cf for this relesase? I can't do it at the moment - any taker? On 4/30/22 11:27, Sidney Markowitz wrote: It's time for a code freeze in preparation for the release of 4.0.0 release candidates. Please do not commit anything to trunk other than the usual ongoing

Moving to R-T-C mode for 4.0.0 release - No commits without review

2022-04-30 Thread Sidney Markowitz
It's time for a code freeze in preparation for the release of 4.0.0 release candidates. Please do not commit anything to trunk other than the usual ongoing rules stuff that finds its way into the rule update process. Any new bug fixes that need to be committed for 4.0.0 should be associated