[shale] Progress on site build

2006-06-20 Thread Wendy Smoak
I changed the site url in the shale-parent and shale-apps-parent poms so we can deploy the website without overwriting the existing one. http://people.apache.org/builds/struts/shale/site/ To deploy the site here: mvn site site:deploy (Staging the site locally wasn't really working, and

[all] CheckStyle

2006-06-20 Thread James Mitchell
For anyone who cares, there are currently 4 different CheckStyle configurations in svn, but I believe we are only really using 1 of them for most of the builds. 1) ./maven/build/struts_checks.xml - currently up to date 2) ./action/taglib/src/conf/qa/CheckStyle.xml 3)

Location for nightly builds

2006-06-20 Thread James Mitchell
Craig and I were discussing a few offline items and one thing that came up was how we currently publish the nightlies. We agree that this is best discussed in public, so here I am :) Currently the nightly build can be found (or will be) on minotaur (people.apache.org) under

[Shale] Maven 2 parent pom

2006-06-20 Thread hermod.opstvedt
Hi I am having problems building Shale with the new Maven 2 build. I am not able to find the parent pom anywhere. Hermod * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * This email with attachments is solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is

Re: [Shale] Maven 2 parent pom

2006-06-20 Thread James Mitchell
How are you trying to build it? With a nightly? A test build? Or from the latest svn? -- James Mitchell On Jun 20, 2006, at 4:36 AM, [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Hi I am having problems building Shale with the new Maven 2 build. I am not able to find the parent pom anywhere. Hermod

RE: [Shale] Maven 2 parent pom

2006-06-20 Thread hermod.opstvedt
Hi This is a clean svn checkout from trunk. The pom file at the root references a parent pom. It tires to download: org.apache.struts/poms/struts-parent-2.pom from several repositories, but is not able to find one. Hermod -Original Message- From: James Mitchell [mailto:[EMAIL

Re: [Shale] Maven 2 parent pom

2006-06-20 Thread James Mitchell
That's right, you'll have to install it locally yourself. Sorry for the hassleit should only take a few minutes. If you checked out Shale from svn using the following URL: https://svn.apache.org/repos/asf/struts/current/ 1) cd to maven/pom/ 2) change pom.xml version from 3-SNAPSHOT to 2

RE: [Shale] Maven 2 parent pom

2006-06-20 Thread hermod.opstvedt
Hi Got it to work. (a little bug in your path, but figured it out) Thnx Hermod -Original Message- From: James Mitchell [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Sent: Tuesday, June 20, 2006 11:12 AM To: Struts Developers List Subject: Re: [Shale] Maven 2 parent pom That's right, you'll have to

Adding Value to AJAX (was Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit)

2006-06-20 Thread Ted Husted
I think when we start to say we're going to add value to a dependency, then we have to make it a hard dependency, and expect that everyone using the feature will be using the exact same version of the dependency. If we go the added value route, then everything related to adding value should be

RE: [Shale] Maven 2 parent pom

2006-06-20 Thread hermod.opstvedt
Hi Actually, I think there might be a problem with a profile definition in a pom somewhere. The reason I am saying that is that it never searched ibiblio. It searched 3 other repositories (people.apache etc) but did not find it there. Hermod -Original Message- From: Wendy Smoak

Re: [all] Struts Nightly builds [was Re: Continnum Is Up]

2006-06-20 Thread Wendy Smoak
On 6/19/06, James Mitchell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: My questions would have been about the POM changes that Sean eluded to during our mini hackathon. I could be wrong, but I thought he said there would be an issue with something we needed and it not being published yet and that may or may not

Re: SAF1 Checkstyle

2006-06-20 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
So, I'm looking through the Checkstyle results for all SAF1 subprojects to see if there is anything else that can and maybe should be addressed by rule changes... one particular complaint that shows up an awful lot is the Line has trailing spaces complaint. My own opinion is that all the

Re: SAF1 Checkstyle

2006-06-20 Thread Martin Cooper
On 6/20/06, Frank W. Zammetti [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So, I'm looking through the Checkstyle results for all SAF1 subprojects to see if there is anything else that can and maybe should be addressed by rule changes... one particular complaint that shows up an awful lot is the Line has trailing

Re: [all] CheckStyle

2006-06-20 Thread Martin Cooper
On 6/19/06, James Mitchell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: For anyone who cares, there are currently 4 different CheckStyle configurations in svn, but I believe we are only really using 1 of them for most of the builds. 1) ./maven/build/struts_checks.xml - currently up to date 2)

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread Jason Carreira
2. The current Dojo based widgets are simple enough to be used in some sample/tutorial like pages but for real life apps they don't work (or put it in another more realistic way: I haven't been able to have them working within a normal timeframe). I have to mention, that I haven't used

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread Patrick Lightbody
Just to add to what Jason already said: no one is suggesting getting rid of Dojo, just that we'd move the ajax theme as it exists today over to the new dojo theme and then the new ajax theme would be a simpler implementation based on DWR and possibly Prototype. When users need more, they are

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread tm jee
Thanks for the informative reply Jason. Its good to get things cleared out. :-) we do a lot of custom tags based on Dojo Is it possible to contribute those tags to SAF2? Its ok if we get a dump of the source, I could work on it, make sure they get documented propertly and have examples for

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread tm jee
and of course, Jason could go through my doings just to make sure i get it right. :-) - Original Message From: tm jee [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Developers List dev@struts.apache.org Sent: Tuesday, 20 June, 2006 11:55:29 PM Subject: Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit Thanks for the

Re: SAF1 Checkstyle

2006-06-20 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
Martin Cooper wrote: I'm with you - I'd prefer to fix them, rather than ignore them. Cool. I suspect most would agree with that as well. The consensus I believe was to hold off on any actual changes until after the next milestone (or was it after GA? I'm not sure), so as soon as we hit

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread Joe Germuska
At 10:32 AM -0500 6/20/06, Patrick Lightbody wrote: Just to add to what Jason already said: no one is suggesting getting rid of Dojo, just that we'd move the ajax theme as it exists today over to the new dojo theme and then the new ajax theme would be a simpler implementation based on DWR and

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread Martin Cooper
On 6/20/06, Jason Carreira [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: 2. The current Dojo based widgets are simple enough to be used in some sample/tutorial like pages but for real life apps they don't work (or put it in another more realistic way: I haven't been able to have them working within a normal

Re: [action2] Upgrade Dojo toolkit

2006-06-20 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
For what it's worth, this sounds like a good approach to me too. The theme concept of WW is one of the things that I think a lot of people that come to SAF2 are going to really appreciate, especially if all of a sudden there are more themes out there to choose from... I can already envision

[Shale] IllegalArgumentException when not synchronized with state machine

2006-06-20 Thread Dominique Jean-Prost
Hello, Concerning the use of back button in the browser: When used, the back button causes an IllegalArgumentException for having desychronized the state machine. I would like to if it would be possible to change the exception type so that I get a more typed exception, for example :

Re: Location for nightly builds

2006-06-20 Thread Martin Cooper
On 6/20/06, James Mitchell [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Craig and I were discussing a few offline items and one thing that came up was how we currently publish the nightlies. We agree that this is best discussed in public, so here I am :) Currently the nightly build can be found (or will be) on

Does Struts really need two frameworks? (long)

2006-06-20 Thread Don Brown
As Shale and Action zero in on their first GA release, I don't think it is too late to ask the question, Does Struts really need two frameworks? We have been putting out the message, two frameworks, one community, for almost a year now, but I still sense a lot of confusion and even rejection

Re: Does Struts really need two frameworks? (long)

2006-06-20 Thread Michael Jouravlev
On 6/20/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: As Shale and Action zero in on their first GA release, I don't think it is too late to ask the question, Does Struts really need two frameworks? I bet DJ and JR are laughing their asses off.

Re: Does Struts really need two frameworks? (long)

2006-06-20 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
Just last week I was talking to another senior architect at my company, and he was asking me how a developer knows what they should get when they go to the Struts site? He was asking me what Struts was at this point. It was more than just a navigation issue, he thought there was a very

Re: Does Struts really need two frameworks? (long)

2006-06-20 Thread Michael Jouravlev
On 6/20/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: As Shale and Action zero in on their first GA release, I don't think it is too late to ask the question, Does Struts really need two frameworks? We have been putting out the message, two frameworks, one community, for almost a year now, but I still

Nested Collections and Beans

2006-06-20 Thread jmicciche
pI have a collection of beans and within each of those beans is a collection of another type of bean. When I use the following code the values display correctly. However the problem is when the page submits the set methods of the inner bean never gets called. All of the data changed on the

Re: Does Struts really need two frameworks? (long)

2006-06-20 Thread Ted Husted
Yes, it would be helpful to find a good way to make JSF easier to use in a conventional Action-based application, much the same way we are trying to make Ajax easier to use in SAF2. Our first attempt (as a project) at JSF/Action integration was the Struts JSF taglib. The promise here was to

Re: SAF1 Checkstyle

2006-06-20 Thread Ted Husted
On 6/20/06, Frank W. Zammetti [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: after the next milestone (or was it after GA? I'm not sure), so as soon as we hit that, I'll jump right on all this. We don't like to make sweeping changes right *after* a popular release, because it fouls up patches people might submit

Re: SAF1 Checkstyle

2006-06-20 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
Ted Husted wrote: We don't like to make sweeping changes right *after* a popular release, because it fouls up patches people might submit based on the source for that release.It's a matter of degree and how many files are touched. Ok, sorry, I wasn't remembering the previous conversations

Re: Does Struts really need two frameworks? (long)

2006-06-20 Thread Don Brown
Ted Husted wrote: As for making the UI tags an independant extension, a al Tiles, that sounds good too. (Even better if we include the value added Ajax support.) But I don't know if we want to hold back the SAF 2.0.0 to make it happen. But, for phase 2, sure! Actually, I'm thinking splitting off