Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-04 Thread Martin Cooper
On 4/30/06, Ian Roughley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Martin Cooper wrote: On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-04 Thread Don Brown
Martin Cooper wrote: On 4/30/06, Ian Roughley [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Martin Cooper wrote: On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-04 Thread Ian Roughley
I'm ok if you want to just remove the copyright. BTW - the copyright assignment form was faxed monday (5/1). /Ian -- From Down Around, Inc. Innovative IT Solutions Software Architecture * Design * Development ~ web: www.fdar.com email

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-01 Thread Claus Ibsen
+1 - great work guys. I had a computer crash at home last weekend and couldn't be online ;( - Posted via Jive Forums http://forums.opensymphony.com/thread.jspa?threadID=28608messageID=55964#55964

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-01 Thread Wendy Smoak
On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. Status: http://incubator.apache.org/projects/webwork2.html [ ] +1

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-01 Thread Don Brown
Martin Cooper wrote: On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. A couple of things I noticed on a quick scan:

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-05-01 Thread Martin Cooper
On 5/1/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Martin Cooper wrote: On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-30 Thread Rainer Hermanns
See comments inline... * There are still quite a few files that have OS copyrights but not ASF ones. * PortletUrlTagTest.java has a copyright for BEKK Consulting but not one for the ASF. Are we sure we're OK for IP on this one? Just contacted Nils-Helge Garli about this. He contributed the

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-30 Thread Rainer Hermanns
* PortletUrlTagTest.java has a copyright for BEKK Consulting but not one for the ASF. Are we sure we're OK for IP on this one? Just contacted Nils-Helge Garli about this. He contributed the code and I remember that for all other contributed files the copyright was changed. Looks like this

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-30 Thread Ian Roughley
Martin Cooper wrote: On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. A couple of things I noticed on a quick

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Eric Molitor
+1 (Not that my vote counts but it runs all my apps) On 4/28/06, Rainer Hermanns [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +1 from me and a big thank you to everyone involved On Apr 28, 2006, at 20:19 , Don Brown wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Question: looking at the status page, I don't seem to find any mention of some of the licensing issues that were being discussed a while back... IIRC, there was some concern about a calendar widget for example, among other things. Am I just missing it on the page? Or

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread tm jee
+1 rgds - Original Message From: Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Developers List dev@struts.apache.org Sent: Saturday, 29 April, 2006 2:19:30 AM Subject: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Gabe
+1 - Original Message From: tm jee [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Developers List dev@struts.apache.org Sent: Saturday, April 29, 2006 9:37:53 AM Subject: Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts +1 rgds - Original Message From: Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Alexandru Popescu
, 2006 9:37:53 AM Subject: Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts +1 rgds - Original Message From: Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Developers List dev@struts.apache.org Sent: Saturday, 29 April, 2006 2:19:30 AM Subject: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Ian Roughley
@struts.apache.org Sent: Saturday, April 29, 2006 9:37:53 AM Subject: Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts +1 rgds - Original Message From: Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: Struts Developers List dev@struts.apache.org Sent: Saturday, 29 April, 2006 2:19:30 AM Subject

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Craig McClanahan
On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. Status: http://incubator.apache.org/projects/webwork2.html [X] +1

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-29 Thread Martin Cooper
On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. A couple of things I noticed on a quick scan: * One of the files

[VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Don Brown
I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. Status: http://incubator.apache.org/projects/webwork2.html [ ] +1 Let's bring it in, and I'm committed to the

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread James Mitchell
+1 Git 'r dun!! -- James Mitchell On Apr 28, 2006, at 2:19 PM, Don Brown wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. Status:

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Bob Lee
+1 - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Frank W. Zammetti
Question: looking at the status page, I don't seem to find any mention of some of the licensing issues that were being discussed a while back... IIRC, there was some concern about a calendar widget for example, among other things. Am I just missing it on the page? Or have they not been resolved?

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Don Brown
All those issues have been resolved, but are not listed specifically in that status page. They are covered under the IP checklist, however. Don Frank W. Zammetti wrote: Question: looking at the status page, I don't seem to find any mention of some of the licensing issues that were being

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Jason Carreira
+1 - Posted via Jive Forums http://forums.opensymphony.com/thread.jspa?threadID=28608messageID=55540#55540 - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Greg Reddin
+0. I'd say +1, but it looks like it will be a bit before I have a chance to get more involved. Greg On Apr 28, 2006, at 1:19 PM, Don Brown wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Jonathan Revusky
Jason Carreira wrote: +1 I wonder... has anybody in the history of this whole incubator thing who was getting incubated ever vote against being graduated? As in: Hey, I wanna stay in here longer... it's nice and warm... or... I don't think I quite get the Apache Way yet. I need to get

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Laurie Harper
+0 (non-binding) with the same caveat. L. Greg Reddin wrote: +0. I'd say +1, but it looks like it will be a bit before I have a chance to get more involved. Greg On Apr 28, 2006, at 1:19 PM, Don Brown wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Ted Husted
+1 On 4/28/06, Don Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2.

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Philip Luppens
+1 Show time ! On 4/28/06, Laurie Harper [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: +0 (non-binding) with the same caveat. L. Greg Reddin wrote: +0. I'd say +1, but it looks like it will be a bit before I have a chance to get more involved. Greg On Apr 28, 2006, at 1:19 PM, Don Brown wrote: I call a

Re: [VOTE] Accept and Graduate WebWork 2 Podling to Struts

2006-04-28 Thread Rainer Hermanns
+1 from me and a big thank you to everyone involved On Apr 28, 2006, at 20:19 , Don Brown wrote: I call a vote that the Struts PMC accept the WebWork 2 podling as having met the incubation requirements and thereby be accepted by the Apache Struts project as Struts Action 2. Status: