Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

Hi All, okay, so I conclude that we currently see no need to change our process. I’m fine with that. Thank you for sharing your thoughts on this topic! Benedikt > Am 29.06.2017 um 09:20 schrieb Jochen Wiedmann : > > On Wed, Jun 28, 2017 at 9:21 AM, Benedikt Ritter

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

On Wed, Jun 28, 2017 at 9:21 AM, Benedikt Ritter wrote: > do we still need a vote for moving components to git? We have done this so > often that I think we could change the process to a simply mail announcing > intents to move a component. No harm done by starting a lazy

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

I am OK with keeping the lazy vote since it is pretty frictionless, and gives people the opportunity to officially raise their hand and show why this is a problem for them. In practice though, moving everything to Git is just a matter of time. I can imagine that we would just move components to

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

The only objection I've seen to switching on any project so far was other projects using svn:external to sync up a commons project, but there are workarounds for that (e.g., the GitHub svn mirror). On 28 June 2017 at 03:45, Amey Jadiye wrote: > unless there is strong

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

unless there is strong reason to stick with svn we should move on git(as many other already moved). I agree that in few cases svn is preferred and that may open huge discussion but atleast for Commons I don't see much advantages to use svn. people who are using svn from long time usually comes in

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

On 2017-06-28, Amey Jadiye wrote: > I think just announcing with intention is enough as git is always better > than svn and at some point everyone will wish to move on git. There certainly are people who disagree with your (I'm not one of them) ;-) Stefan

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

On 2017-06-28, Benedikt Ritter wrote: > do we still need a vote for moving components to git? We have done > this so often that I think we could change the process to a simply > mail announcing intents to move a component. Hmm, what if one of the active developers of the component then says

Re: [DISCUSS] Do we need a vote for moving components to git?

I think just announcing with intention is enough as git is always better than svn and at some point everyone will wish to move on git. so +1 to just announce it. Regards, Amey On Wed, Jun 28, 2017, 12:51 PM Benedikt Ritter wrote: > Hi, > > do we still need a vote for