Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
From: Wendy Smoak [EMAIL PROTECTED] On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan wrote: Sorry for the late response and the bad news ... -1 on this because the sql-browser sample is not included in the shale-framework-1.0.1 artifact, and running ant download-dependencies release therefore fails to execute correctly :-(. Ah RATS! To make things even worse, it's *my* fault :-( ... the release target doesn't copy the SQL Browser demo app sources like it should. I'll fix that in a second. Sorry for the time you wasted on this Wendy. Not at all... most of the work carries forward. And I should have caught that. :( I went ahead and posted the 1.0.2 release plan so that the clock can start ticking, though I didn't add myself as release manager in case someone else wants to jump in. I haven't heard the official word from Martin yet but I might be able to help out if not this release, the next one. Gary A few other things: - I noticed (too late for 1.0.1) that there's a broken link on the release notes page. It points to a 'webapps' directory that doesn't exist in the distribution. - 38560 can be closed; Ryan noted that he's not having the issue any longer. - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. - Is the sql-browser app supposed to display columns of data? I only see the column headings. -- Wendy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
On 3/21/06, Gary VanMatre [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: From: Wendy Smoak [EMAIL PROTECTED] On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan wrote: Sorry for the late response and the bad news ... -1 on this because the sql-browser sample is not included in the shale-framework-1.0.1artifact, and running ant download-dependencies release therefore fails to execute correctly :-(. Ah RATS! To make things even worse, it's *my* fault :-( ... the release target doesn't copy the SQL Browser demo app sources like it should. I'll fix that in a second. Sorry for the time you wasted on this Wendy. Not at all... most of the work carries forward. And I should have caught that. :( I went ahead and posted the 1.0.2 release plan so that the clock can start ticking, though I didn't add myself as release manager in case someone else wants to jump in. I haven't heard the official word from Martin yet but I might be able to help out if not this release, the next one. Huh? Wha? Martin me? What word are you waiting for from me? -- Martin Cooper Gary A few other things: - I noticed (too late for 1.0.1) that there's a broken link on the release notes page. It points to a 'webapps' directory that doesn't exist in the distribution. - 38560 can be closed; Ryan noted that he's not having the issue any longer. - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. - Is the sql-browser app supposed to display columns of data? I only see the column headings. -- Wendy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
From: Martin Cooper [EMAIL PROTECTED] On 3/21/06, Gary VanMatre wrote: From: Wendy Smoak On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan wrote: Sorry for the late response and the bad news ... -1 on this because the sql-browser sample is not included in the shale-framework-1.0.1artifact, and running ant download-dependencies release therefore fails to execute correctly :-(. Ah RATS! To make things even worse, it's *my* fault :-( ... the release target doesn't copy the SQL Browser demo app sources like it should. I'll fix that in a second. Sorry for the time you wasted on this Wendy. Not at all... most of the work carries forward. And I should have caught that. :( I went ahead and posted the 1.0.2 release plan so that the clock can start ticking, though I didn't add myself as release manager in case someone else wants to jump in. I haven't heard the official word from Martin yet but I might be able to help out if not this release, the next one. Huh? Wha? Martin me? What word are you waiting for from me? :-) Ahhh, I must have miss understood. You asked me to give you a ping. Rock on! Gary Martin Cooper Gary A few other things: - I noticed (too late for 1.0.1) that there's a broken link on the release notes page. It points to a 'webapps' directory that doesn't exist in the distribution. - 38560 can be closed; Ryan noted that he's not having the issue any longer. - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. - Is the sql-browser app supposed to display columns of data? I only see the column headings. -- Wendy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. Just to clarify, omitting these from the distribution would mean you couldn't create the website from the source artifact, right? That doesn't seem like what we'd want if it's true. Neither shale/xdocs nor shale/build is included in shale-framework.x.x.x.zip, so you already can't build the website from the distribution. I also notice that only three apps (blank, mailreader, use-cases) actually have an xdocs/navigation.xml file ... should these really be removed from the repository instead? No, they belong in the repository, they control the website menus. There is an 'xdocs' in all of the subdirectories (core-library/xdocs, clay-plugin/xdocs, etc.) Only a few of them make it into the distribution, though. -- Wendy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Sorry for the late response and the bad news ... -1 on this because the sql-browser sample is not included in the shale-framework-1.0.1 artifact, and running ant download-dependencies release therefore fails to execute correctly :-(. Ah RATS! To make things even worse, it's *my* fault :-( ... the release target doesn't copy the SQL Browser demo app sources like it should. I'll fix that in a second. Sorry for the time you wasted on this Wendy. Not at all... most of the work carries forward. And I should have caught that. :( I went ahead and posted the 1.0.2 release plan so that the clock can start ticking, though I didn't add myself as release manager in case someone else wants to jump in. A few other things: - I noticed (too late for 1.0.1) that there's a broken link on the release notes page. It points to a 'webapps' directory that doesn't exist in the distribution. - 38560 can be closed; Ryan noted that he's not having the issue any longer. - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. - Is the sql-browser app supposed to display columns of data? I only see the column headings. -- Wendy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
On 3/20/06, Wendy Smoak [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Sorry for the late response and the bad news ... -1 on this because the sql-browser sample is not included in the shale-framework-1.0.1artifact, and running ant download-dependencies release therefore fails to execute correctly :-(. Ah RATS! To make things even worse, it's *my* fault :-( ... the release target doesn't copy the SQL Browser demo app sources like it should. I'll fix that in a second. Sorry for the time you wasted on this Wendy. Not at all... most of the work carries forward. And I should have caught that. :( I'm running a pretty full suite of tests on the output of a trunk build right now, to make sure there are no other hidden ghosts. I went ahead and posted the 1.0.2 release plan so that the clock can start ticking, though I didn't add myself as release manager in case someone else wants to jump in. If you're willing, I'm certainly glad to support and test. A few other things: - I noticed (too late for 1.0.1) that there's a broken link on the release notes page. It points to a 'webapps' directory that doesn't exist in the distribution. Should I go ahead and fix that now? - 38560 can be closed; Ryan noted that he's not having the issue any longer. Will take care of that. - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. I'll look for those too if you want these fixed before rolling 1.0.2. - Is the sql-browser app supposed to display columns of data? I only see the column headings. It is supposed to display data -- we're seeing an artifact of a bug in MyFaces 1.1.1 (it works with the RI) when the DataModel you are using returns -1 for a getRowCount() call. This is theoretically fixed in the trunk ... after we roll this out, 1.1.2 should be available with the fix and we can upgrade if it's actually fixed. It's also amusing to execute SELECT * FROM ZIP_CODES and then SELECT CITY, STATE FROM ZIP_CODES and watch the table columns get drawn dynamically based on the returned metadata from the query. Not particularly easy to do with Struts tags :-). -- Wendy Craig
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
On 3/20/06, Craig McClanahan [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: On 3/20/06, Wendy Smoak [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: - There are a couple of 'xdocs/navigation.xml' files that could be excluded from the distribution. Just to clarify, omitting these from the distribution would mean you couldn't create the website from the source artifact, right? That doesn't seem like what we'd want if it's true. I also notice that only three apps (blank, mailreader, use-cases) actually have an xdocs/navigation.xml file ... should these really be removed from the repository instead? Either way, I'll wait for confirmation before actually changing this (or fixing the release notes link). Craig
[VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
Following the release plan which is available on the Wiki, http://wiki.apache.org/struts/ShaleRelease101 the Struts Shale v1.0.1 test build has been completed and deployed to http://svn.apache.org/dist/struts/shale/v1.0.1/ including checksums and signatures, which may be verified against http://www.apache.org/dist/struts/KEYS . Once you have had a chance to review this test build, please respond with a vote on its quality: [ ] Alpha [ ] Beta [ ] General Availability (GA) We welcome votes from all community members, however, only the votes of Struts PMC members are binding. -- Wendy Smoak - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Re: [VOTE] Struts Shale v1.0.1 Quality
On 3/19/06, Wendy Smoak [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Once you have had a chance to review this test build, please respond with a vote on its quality: [X] Alpha [ ] Beta [ ] General Availability (GA) My vote is for Alpha quality due to Shale's dependence on a snapshot of Standalone Tiles. -- Wendy - To unsubscribe, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED] For additional commands, e-mail: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
