[digitalradio] Re: interesting piece by K1ZZ

2007-10-02 Thread jgorman01
The only problem I see with this is how several tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of hams are going to do 10-20 seconds of sounding even using whole segments of bands. There won't be any room or time for actually talking! I just don't see this being good for most HF communications.

Re: [digitalradio] Re: interesting piece by K1ZZ

2007-10-02 Thread Robert Thompson
Soundings aren't required. They merely minimize wasted linking attempts on currently-unsuitable bands. You can run an entirely sounding free ALE network, and in fact the utility dxer crowd does occasionally note such networks run by various government or NGO entities. If you want to have the

Re: [digitalradio] Re: interesting piece by K1ZZ

2007-10-02 Thread Steve Hajducek
Hi Jim, It sounds almost like you are making case to abolish all forms of Amateur Radio Contesting with this argument of yours, no where in the FCC rules are contesting ( which by the way I enjoy ) mentioned as such, actually many of the FCC rules could be used to make an argument against