[digitalradio] Rethinking digital mode band plans-developing a solution

2010-02-21 Thread Dick
Andy: Your suggested band plan seems to me to be as good as any that I have seen and better than most that I have seen. I think it is unfortunate to have someone suggest a well thought out/workable plan and then watch it die for lack of support. It seems to me that the problem has been the

[digitalradio] Rethinking digital mode band plans-developing a solution

2010-02-20 Thread Andy obrien
Just some thoughts, critique welcome. If we think about HF digital QSOs there are 5 general types. 1. Weak signal propagation probes that are frequent in nature and regularly used by hams around the world (JT65A, ROS, WSPR, SLOW CW), Usually the exchange is a signal report, callsign, and

Re: [digitalradio] Rethinking digital mode band plans-developing a solution

2010-02-20 Thread phil williams
Andy, I have re-edited this response three times now. I was trying to offer something that would contribute to the greater good. I have nothing to offer to the greater good. I have come to the conclusion that I really don't care about band plans at such a detailed level. I respect what you