Re: [Edu-sig] PataPata 0.1.19 release Stigmergy

2006-06-30 Thread kirby urner
 faster and in a more maintainable way, whereas PataPata attempts to give
 you a live world of Python objects where some of those objects are Morphs
 and non-visual Prototypes.


Something we're used to from Visual FoxPro (not all classes are visual).

 so if PataPata picked up some I would expect PythonCard might lose some.

Very speculative.  At the moment, I'm doubting it.


 So actually related in some sense I guess.


Yes.

 Maybe it would be kind of like people building geodesic domes by someone
 fiddling with some construction materials and then making a triangle, and
 then other people getting excited and making triangles and linking them up
 to the first triangle, and then a whole dome somehow going up. Now, this

Yes, Dick Fischbeck http://profiles.yahoo.com/dick_fischbeck -- we met
once in Applewhite's apartment -- does these randome things where
you don't have to prefigure any math.  Just pinch for
concavity/convexity, staple together, and you're done.

 people who are deaf, blind, and mute building a geodesic dome by just
 helping each other add parts?


Sounds like some kind of emergency operation, not done with optimum
planning or forethought.  To be avoided if possible, or perhaps
simulated.

 prototypes. So, some emergent behavior is there as well, mediated by this
 mailing list around some common interests related to Python and education.

 --Paul Fernhout

Yes, that's the open source way I'd say, a kind of development by
Ouija Board approach -- and the amazing thing is:  it works, and
produces beautiful code.

Kirby
___
Edu-sig mailing list
Edu-sig@python.org
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/edu-sig


Re: [Edu-sig] PataPata 0.1.19 release Stigmergy

2006-06-29 Thread Paul D. Fernhout
kirby urner wrote:
 Or committed company employees, or crew members, or television screen 
 writers...

Good point.

By the way, SourceForge is finally allowing logins again, so there is now 
a proper release here:
   http://sourceforge.net/project/showfiles.php?group_id=165910

 I wonder if you've contacted Kevin Altis, the PythonCard developer I
 know best.  Robin Dunn, author of wxPython is also local (we've met
 many times).  I saw the new wx book at Powell's Technical, and almost
 bought it (I'm waiting for a bigger book budget to materialize, so I
 might expand my library).

To be clear, it is limited PythonCard compatibility, but it is using TK to 
achieve that, not WX. Eventually, I hope to improve the wx GUI, but the TK 
one is more advanced right now and the PythonCard compatibility is built 
on that. So, you can take your PythonCard resources (simple ones) and 
build TK GUIs with them (at least, as far as laying out widgets, 
connecting code still needs to be done by hand, and automating that is not 
a priority for me, if it would be doable at all given various issues).
It's a tribute to PythonCard's modular design of using a resource file 
that I was able to do this with PataPata.

The basic difference between PythonCard and PataPata is that PythonCard 
seems focused on helping you develop GUI-oriented Python applications 
faster and in a more maintainable way, whereas PataPata attempts to give 
you a live world of Python objects where some of those objects are Morphs 
and non-visual Prototypes.

Still, I'd expect the PythonCard project might not like a competitor? 
:-) I'm all for friendly competition of course -- but the reality is there 
are only so many volunteer developers to go around at any specific time, 
so if PataPata picked up some I would expect PythonCard might lose some. 
Certainly I could have tried to improve PythonCard rather than make 
something different. On the other hand, sometimes when something becomes 
popular, say building GUIs in Python, then everyone benefits (say if VB 
and Ruby and PHP developers switch to Python and either PythonCard or 
PataPata). In the PythonCard case, since it is under a more permissive 
license (BSD-ish) than PataPata (GPL) they do address different audiences.

So, see, some teamwork going on, though of an artifact mediated kind. I
think of that as a form of Stigmergy.
   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigmergic
 
 
 Wow, I'd never have guessed.  Same root as stigmata, no?  Maybe not.

Never thought of that.

On etymology:

From:
   http://www.answers.com/topic/stigmata
stigmata ... [plural of stigma, from Gr.,=brand]

From:
http://stigmergiccollaboration.blogspot.com/2006_05_01_stigmergiccollaboration_archive.html
Below are some variations on the terms origins (see the [poster for 
references):
 * ‘stigma’ (goad) and ‘ergon’ (work)…” to “…stigmergy (stigma: Wound 
from a pointed object; ergon: Work, product of labour = stimulating 
product of labour).
 * from the Greek words stigma ‘sign’ and ergon ‘action,’ and captures 
the notion that an agent’s actions leave signs in the environment, signs 
that it and other agents sense and that determine their subsequent actions.
 * [F]rom the Greek stigma: sting, and ergon: work.

So actually related in some sense I guess.

 From there: Stigmergy is a method of communication in emergent systems
 in which the individual parts of the system communicate with one another
 by modifying their local environment.

 So like when I mow my lawn in a certain pattern, signalling a
 satellite, or when ETs use a crop circle to phone home, right?
 Science fiction examples of stigging out (slang for exercising
 stigmergic abilities).

Not quite the same, though interesting examples to work with. The point of 
the individual or group stigmergic activity is not generally explicitly to 
signal, which is what you give examples of -- people intending to send a 
communication, but just doing it by making a large physical artifact. 
Rather, the idea is that each actor does something that feels good to them 
to improve their local environment, and other actors then build on their 
work in some way, or connect their own independent work to the others work 
on recognizing it.  So the cooperation is mediated through the artifact, 
but the artifact itself isn't necessarily intended as a signal (though it 
could be). For a better example, it would be like your neighbor sees you 
mow part of a crop circle in your cornfield, and they then decide to mow 
another part of a circle along the same arc which joins up with yours 
because it feels right, and so on, until soon your community has got a 
really big circle around the whole neighborhood someone really could see 
from space.

In the PataPata example, Gregor wasn't writing xturtle for PataPata, and 
PataPata wasn't written to host xturtle, but it turns out the two things 
can be used together. That is more like stigmergy in termite mound 
building, where termites mill 

Re: [Edu-sig] PataPata 0.1.19 release Stigmergy

2006-06-28 Thread kirby urner
On 6/28/06, Paul D. Fernhout [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:

 Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can
 change the world; indeed, it's the only thing that ever has. -- Margaret Mead


Or committed company employees, or crew members, or television screen writers...

 it has no functionality yet. (Limited) PythonCard compatibility motivated
 several major improvements in the system (including naming morphs and
 supporting menus and a visible flag).

I wonder if you've contacted Kevin Altis, the PythonCard developer I
know best.  Robin Dunn, author of wxPython is also local (we've met
many times).  I saw the new wx book at Powell's Technical, and almost
bought it (I'm waiting for a bigger book budget to materialize, so I
might expand my library).

 So, see, some teamwork going on, though of an artifact mediated kind. I
 think of that as a form of Stigmergy.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stigmergic

Wow, I'd never have guessed.  Same root as stigmata, no?  Maybe not.

 From there: Stigmergy is a method of communication in emergent systems
 in which the individual parts of the system communicate with one another
 by modifying their local environment.

 --Paul Fernhout

So like when I mow my lawn in a certain pattern, signalling a
satellite, or when ETs use a crop circle to phone home, right?
Science fiction examples of stigging out (slang for exercising
stigmergic abilities).

Kirby
___
Edu-sig mailing list
Edu-sig@python.org
http://mail.python.org/mailman/listinfo/edu-sig