Re: [EM] An example of BTR-STV

2006-06-08 Thread Rob LeGrand
Anthony O'Neal wrote: STV elects Andrea, Carter, and Deliliah. CPO-STV elects Andrea, Carter, and Scott. Now let's compute the score for BTR-STV: I should point out that I proposed BTR-IRV as a slightly hacked IRV that would never eliminate a Condorcet winner, in the hope that IRV supporters

Re: [EM] An example of BTR-STV

2006-06-08 Thread Anthony O'Neal
Anthony O'Neal wrote: STV elects Andrea, Carter, and Deliliah. CPO-STV elects Andrea, Carter, and Scott. Now let's compute the score for BTR-STV:I should point out that I proposed BTR-IRV as a slightly hacked IRV thatwould never eliminate a Condorcet winner, in the hope that IRV supportersmight

[EM] An example of BTR-STV

2006-06-07 Thread Anthony O'Neal
(This is the election I pulled out of the Wikipedia article for CPO-STV. I just didn't feel like making up an election where the results from CPO-STV and STV differ right now. If you want to see how the results for the CPO-STV and STV results were arrived upon, then go to the article) (PS, does

Re: [EM] An example of BTR-STV

2006-06-07 Thread Jan Kok
On 6/7/06, Anthony O'Neal [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: (PS, does anyone know what the BTR part of BTR-IRV means? Honestly, I can't figure it out, but that's what Warren on Rangevoting.com calls it. I'm thinking of changing the name to Majority Elimination by IRV, or ME-IRV, and ME-STV, but if

Re: [EM] An example of BTR-STV

2006-06-07 Thread raphfrk
Anthony O'Neal [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: (This is the election I pulled out of the Wikipedia article for CPO-STV. I just didn't feel like making up an election where the results from CPO-STV and STV differ right now. If you want to see how the results for the CPO-STV and STV results were