From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Does anyone have any comments in reference to this critique of STV as
applied to choosing three pizza toppings? The issue is whether it's
fair
to transfer the surplus votes from the winners before transfering
votes
from the losers.
In PR-STV, the number of
Nathan Larson asked:
Does anyone have any comments in reference to this critique
of STV as applied to choosing three pizza toppings? The issue
is whether it's fair to transfer the surplus votes from the
winners before transferring votes from the losers.
The person who wrote the
Jonathan Lundell Sent: 13 November 2006 16:27
At 11:37 AM + 11/13/06, James Gilmour wrote:
Rather, STV-PR was devised to
ensure that each significant point of view within the electorate was
represented fairly (as expressed by the voters' responses to the
candidates who had offered
Does anyone have any comments in reference to this critique of STV as applied to choosing three pizza toppings? The issue is whether it's fair to transfer the surplus votes from the winners before transfering votes from the losers.
---What you describe would indeed work, however
Suppose the
