[Election-Methods] RE : Re: peer-reviewed work that is critical of IRV

2007-09-28 Thread Kevin Venzke
James, --- James Gilmour [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit : Kevin Venzke Sent: 28 September 2007 15:23 What are the best articles or books that can be cited here? Voting Matters is not highly respected on Wikipedia. Kevin, could you please elaborate on your comment about Voting matters

[Election-Methods] peer-reviewed work that is critical of IRV

2007-09-28 Thread Kevin Venzke
Hello, What are the best articles or books that can be cited here? Voting Matters is not highly respected on Wikipedia. Thanks. Kevin Venzke _ Ne gardez plus qu'une seule adresse mail ! Copiez vos mails vers

[Election-Methods] RE : Re: peer-reviewed work that is critical of IRV

2007-09-28 Thread Kevin Venzke
Howard, --- Howard Swerdfeger [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit : Not peer review, but Ka ping yee of... http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ has run sum simulations of election systems in 2d space and it shows quite a few problems with IRV. these guys (warren smith) also have some Yee diagrams

Re: [Election-Methods] RE : Re: peer-reviewed work that is critical ofIRV

2007-09-28 Thread James Gilmour
--- James Gilmour [EMAIL PROTECTED] a écrit : Kevin Venzke Sent: 28 September 2007 15:23 What are the best articles or books that can be cited here? Voting Matters is not highly respected on Wikipedia. Kevin, could you please elaborate on your comment about Voting matters

Re: [Election-Methods] RE : Is sincere voting in Range suboptimal?

2007-09-28 Thread Dave Ketchum
Just a reminder that the Internet can be slow - kungfu was involved in several such for EM: Received: from 66.33.216.126 by mf1.clarityconnect.net (Clarity Connect Spam and Virus Filter); Fri, 28 Sep 2007 14:17:16 -0400 Received: from diego.dreamhost.com (diego.dreamhost.com

Re: [Election-Methods] peer-reviewed work that is critical of IRV

2007-09-28 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 10:41 AM 9/28/2007, Howard Swerdfeger wrote: Not peer review, but Ka ping yee of... http://zesty.ca/voting/sim/ has run sum simulations of election systems in 2d space and it shows quite a few problems with IRV. these guys (warren smith) also have some Yee diagrams

Re: [Election-Methods] RE : Re: peer-reviewed work that is critical ofIRV

2007-09-28 Thread Abd ul-Rahman Lomax
At 02:24 PM 9/28/2007, James Gilmour wrote: I found only one comment, on the Discussion page for Plurality Criterion, where Voting matters is described as an on-line IRV advocacy publication. That is a gross misrepresentation of Voting matters. It is not an advocacy publication of any kind.