Re: [-empyre-] Research in Practice, week two, January 14-20

2013-01-15 Thread t.memm...@underacademy.org
In Sweden the dissertation defense is setup where you defend your dissertation directly with an opponent, usually a senior scholar in the field of study. This usually lasts between 2-5 hours. Then the discussion is open to the grading committee, followed by questions from the public (meaning

Re: [-empyre-] Research in Practice, week two, January 14-20

2013-01-15 Thread Maria Damon
Talan: What is a dissertation opponent? That is a role that has not been part of my experience in the States, either as a PhD candidate or as a professor in a doctoral degree-granting program. bests, md On 1/15/13 9:55 AM, t.memm...@underacademy.org wrote: Hello - IĆ¢EUR^(TM)ve never really

Re: [-empyre-] Research in Practice, week two, January 14-20

2013-01-15 Thread t.memm...@underacademy.org
NOT the newly annointed Doctor, hopefully! :) On Tue Jan 15 17:39 , Simon Biggs sent: who buys the drinks? Sent from a mobile device, thus the brevity. Simon Biggs si...@littlepig.org.uk s.bi...@ed.ac.uk http://www.littlepig.org.uk On 15 Jan 2013, at 17:07, t.memm...@underacademy.org

Re: [-empyre-] Research in Practice, week two, January 14-20

2013-01-15 Thread t.memm...@underacademy.org
NOT the newly annointed Doctor, hopefully! :) On Tue Jan 15 17:39 , Simon Biggs sent: who buys the drinks? Sent from a mobile device, thus the brevity. Simon Biggs si...@littlepig.org.uk s.bi...@ed.ac.uk http://www.littlepig.org.uk On 15 Jan 2013, at 17:07, t.memm...@underacademy.org

Re: [-empyre-] Research in Practice, week two, January 14-20

2013-01-15 Thread Gabriela VargasCetina
I've seen some of these PhD Dissertation defenses online, and I find the whole procedure very stimulating: you have to think on your feet! My own PhD dissertation in Canada was a bit like this, since at McGill the Dissertation Defense Committee used to be formed by specialists in several