I have a question,

First here is the environment: 3 Exchange 5.5-SP3 Servers(Win2k SP2), this
is the main e-mail environment. A sendmail server relays outgoing and
incoming mail. Incoming mail is distributed to the appropriate exchange
server by e-mail aliases for every address, pointing to the appropriate
server for that address. The new piece is an Exchange 2000 server that
eventually every mailbox will be migrated to. The AD is in mixed mode.

Now here is the setup: Those sneaky Unix guys here have set up some of their
own DL's on the Sendmail server. The e-mail addresses of the Sendmail DL's
are in the same DNS domain(specifically: 'phcs.com') as the Exchange
servers.

So we come to the problem...we have moved a few users over to the new
Exchange 2k server. When these users were on any of the 5.5 servers, they
could send e-mail to one of the Sendmail DL's (eg.: '[EMAIL PROTECTED]'). With
their mailbox on the Exchange 2k server, sending to the sendmail DL's fails
with an Unkown Recipient NDR back from the Exchange Server.

It doesn't seem like a mystery to me why the Exchange 2k server won't send
out of the site for an address that it treats as internal. But what I can't
figure out is why the 5.5 servers will forward a message to the Sendmail
server for an SMTP mail address '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' when the IMS is configured to
route all 'phcs.com' to <inbound>.

The Senior guys that should know better than I have no clue either. I
haven't been here long enough to know if the Exchange servers were somehow
hacked to get this behavior.

I already have a couple solutions to the problem, but what I'm really
wondering is if this is proper behavior for Exchange 5.5 vs. 2000? 





List Charter and FAQ at:
http://www.sunbelt-software.com/exchange_list_charter.htm

Reply via email to