Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-16 Thread Joe Kazura
LOL - One would think, but it's not 'good enough' according to our University's Security Czar! On Jun 9, 2009, at 11:05 PM, Markus Kesaromous wrote: Would using a powerful magnet also work?? :) From: ehem...@townisp.com To: fedora-list@redhat.com Date: Tue, 9 Jun 2009 22:58:05 -0400

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-13 Thread g
Beartooth wrote: I have it on excellent authority that a .45 acp won't make a hole clear through a hard drive, but that a .30-06 will. factory .45 acp may not. custom .45 acp can. .357 mag good for spindle motor. rem 720 .306 can at 600 yds. .25c print @ 100 yds -- peace out. tc,hago.

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-13 Thread Bruno Wolff III
On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 16:49:03 -0400, Robert L Cochran cochr...@speakeasy.net wrote: Thanks to all who answered. I'm anxious to try out Alan's security erase suggestion on a much newer drive. It appears to be a lot less labor intensive. If you are really worried about this, set up

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-11 Thread Robin Laing
Rick Stevens wrote: Henrik Schmiediche wrote: Check out: http://www.dban.org - Henrik From: fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com [mailto:fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com] On Behalf Of Fernando Cassia Sent: Wednesday, June 10, 2009 2:51 PM To: Community assistance,

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-11 Thread Jussi Lehtola
On Thu, 2009-06-11 at 10:38 -0600, Robin Laing wrote: There was a challenge put out to recover data that was erased with dd but no takers. The comment that I read on the web site pointed to a phone call that dd makes it to costly to recover. The title says it all:

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread Tim
On Tue, 2009-06-09 at 22:58 -0400, Erik Hemdal wrote: I know that there are a number of commercial services that offer to destroy disks, recycle what can be recovered, and provide you evidence of observed destruction, although I don't have much experience with them. To really believe that,

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread Fernando Cassia
On Tue, Jun 9, 2009 at 6:00 PM, Mike McCarty mike.mcca...@sbcglobal.netwrote: Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy

RE: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread Henrik Schmiediche
Check out: http://www.dban.org - Henrik From: fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com [mailto:fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com] On Behalf Of Fernando Cassia Sent: Wednesday, June 10, 2009 2:51 PM To: Community assistance, encouragement, and advice for using Fedora. Subject: Re: OT: Can

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread Rick Stevens
Henrik Schmiediche wrote: Check out: http://www.dban.org - Henrik From: fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com [mailto:fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com] On Behalf Of Fernando Cassia Sent: Wednesday, June 10, 2009 2:51 PM To: Community assistance, encouragement, and advice for using

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread Robert L Cochran
I'm surprised this thread was reawakened...makes me wonder what sort of child I created here! I first used Alan's suggestion about checking for, and if possible, using the security erase feature of a security-erase enabled hard drive. This drive was too old to have such a feature. I checked

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread Fernando Cassia
On Wed, Jun 10, 2009 at 5:49 PM, Robert L Cochrancochr...@speakeasy.net wrote: I'm surprised this thread was reawakened...makes me wonder what sort of child I created here! I first used Alan's suggestion about checking for, and if possible, using the security erase feature of a security-erase

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-10 Thread James Kosin
Tim wrote: Tim: But do you know what the drive does when you use that function? ;-\ Bruno Wolff III: Reading the drive back in should give you a good idea. If that isn't enough of a check for you then you should just be destroying the drive. While that would tell you that *you*

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-09 Thread Mike McCarty
Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can write zeroes or some form of

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-09 Thread Erik Hemdal
Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can write zeroes or some form of

RE: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-09 Thread Markus Kesaromous
Would using a powerful magnet also work?? :) From: ehem...@townisp.com To: fedora-list@redhat.com Date: Tue, 9 Jun 2009 22:58:05 -0400 Subject: Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It? Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-02 Thread Nifty Fedora Mitch
On Mon, Jun 01, 2009 at 01:58:27AM -0700, Jonathan Ryshpan wrote: On 05/30/2009 04:49 AM, Mike Cloaked wrote: How do you access the security erase facility? All kidding aside, there's a web site from which you can download a little DOS utility to invoke security erase on a drive. The

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-02 Thread Tim
On Sun, 2009-05-31 at 12:52 -0500, Steven Stern wrote: I like to put the drives on a sidewalk and whack them a few times with an 8 lb sledge hammer. When I pick up the drive and shake it and it makes a nice jingling sound, the job is done. Wouldn't you love to see someone doing that out the

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-02 Thread Tim
Tim: But do you know what the drive does when you use that function? ;-\ Bruno Wolff III: Reading the drive back in should give you a good idea. If that isn't enough of a check for you then you should just be destroying the drive. While that would tell you that *you* couldn't read your own

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-02 Thread Robert L Cochran
On 05/29/2009 09:46 PM, Robert L Cochran wrote: On 05/29/2009 05:44 PM, Alan Cox wrote: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write various bit patterns 25 times over the entire drive (see the man page for more options).

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-06-01 Thread Jonathan Ryshpan
On 05/30/2009 04:49 AM, Mike Cloaked wrote: How do you access the security erase facility? All kidding aside, there's a web site from which you can download a little DOS utility to invoke security erase on a drive. The README claims that security erase is better than smashing the drive to

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-31 Thread Mikkel L. Ellertson
Sharpe, Sam J wrote: 2009/5/30 Mikkel L. Ellertson mik...@infinity-ltd.com: Rick Stevens wrote: I generally take the drives out to the desert and use /sbin/detonate. As Jamie Hyneman once said on Mythbusters... When in doubtC4! Can I come with the next time you take one out? They

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-31 Thread Steven Stern
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 On 05/29/2009 10:08 AM, Robin Laing wrote: Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-31 Thread Wolfgang S. Rupprecht
Mikkel L. Ellertson mik...@infinity-ltd.com writes: This should probably be taken to another list... But I can not resist one last comment - low explosives like McVeigh was reported to have used would probably send the drive flying, rather then destroying it directly. A shaped charge from C4

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-30 Thread NiftyFedora Mitch
On Fri, May 29, 2009 at 4:39 AM, Ambrogio fn050...@interfree.it wrote: Il giorno ven, 29/05/2009 alle 14.52 +1200, Clint Dilks ha scritto: dd if=/dev/zero of=/dev/youbettergetthisright bs=1M If you want to be really sure you need to do the command above several time or use software like

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-30 Thread Tim
On Fri, 2009-05-29 at 13:31 +0100, Alan Cox wrote: It makes no real difference - use the drives own secure erase feature if you want to be sure, otherwise you've got no guarantee that everything will be cleared - only the drive knows enough to do the job. But do you know what the drive does

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-30 Thread Mike Cloaked
Alan Cox wrote: Use security erase, that is why it is there. How do you access the security erase facility? -- View this message in context: http://www.nabble.com/OT%3A-Can-Reformatting-A-Hard-Drive-To-ext3-Destroy-All-the-Data-On-It--tp23773312p23791508.html Sent from the Fedora

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-30 Thread Robert L Cochran
On 05/30/2009 04:49 AM, Mike Cloaked wrote: Alan Cox wrote: Use security erase, that is why it is there. How do you access the security erase facility? From `man hdparm`: --security-erase PWD Erase (locked) drive, using password PWD (DANGEROUS). Password is given as an

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-30 Thread Beartooth
On Fri, 29 May 2009 16:57:09 -0700, Rick Stevens wrote: Mikkel L. Ellertson wrote: Rick Stevens wrote: I generally take the drives out to the desert and use /sbin/detonate. As Jamie Hyneman once said on Mythbusters... When in doubtC4! Can I come with the next time you take one

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-30 Thread Bruno Wolff III
On Sat, May 30, 2009 at 18:16:00 +0930, Tim ignored_mail...@yahoo.com.au wrote: On Fri, 2009-05-29 at 13:31 +0100, Alan Cox wrote: It makes no real difference - use the drives own secure erase feature if you want to be sure, otherwise you've got no guarantee that everything will be

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Alan Cox
On Thu, 28 May 2009 22:29:23 -0400 Robert L Cochran cochr...@speakeasy.net wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Thermite ? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Ambrogio
Il giorno ven, 29/05/2009 alle 14.52 +1200, Clint Dilks ha scritto: dd if=/dev/zero of=/dev/youbettergetthisright bs=1M If you want to be really sure you need to do the command above several time or use software like http://www.dban.org/ /dev/zero is not the right device to use. Better

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Frank Murphy (Frankly3d)
Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can write zeroes or some form of

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Alan Cox
/dev/zero is not the right device to use. Better is /dev/random or /dev/urandom But they are not speed It makes no real difference - use the drives own secure erase feature if you want to be sure, otherwise you've got no guarantee that everything will be cleared - only the drive knows enough

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Srdan Tosovic
On Thu, 28 May 2009 22:29:23 -0400 Robert L Cochran cochr...@speakeasy.net wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Bruno Wolff III
On Fri, May 29, 2009 at 21:51:57 +0200, Srdan Tosovic t...@prip.tuwien.ac.at wrote: as root will write various bit patterns 25 times over the entire drive (see the man page for more options). If recovery after one pass of rewriting a disk is a credible threat you should be physically

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Alan Cox
'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write various bit patterns 25 times over the entire drive (see the man page for more options). Whoopeeedoo. Thats still not the correct way to erase a disk. Use security erase,

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Sharpe, Sam J
2009/5/29 Alan Cox a...@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write various bit patterns 25 times over the entire drive (see the man page for more options). Whoopeeedoo. Thats still not the correct

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Jussi Lehtola
Quoting Sharpe, Sam J sam.sharpe+lists.red...@gmail.com: 2009/5/29 Alan Cox a...@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write various bit patterns 25 times over the entire drive (see the man page for more

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Sharpe, Sam J
2009/5/29 Jussi Lehtola jussileht...@fedoraproject.org: Quoting Sharpe, Sam J sam.sharpe+lists.red...@gmail.com: 2009/5/29 Alan Cox a...@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write various bit

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Rick Stevens
Sharpe, Sam J wrote: 2009/5/29 Jussi Lehtola jussileht...@fedoraproject.org: Quoting Sharpe, Sam J sam.sharpe+lists.red...@gmail.com: 2009/5/29 Alan Cox a...@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Mikkel L. Ellertson
Rick Stevens wrote: I generally take the drives out to the desert and use /sbin/detonate. As Jamie Hyneman once said on Mythbusters... When in doubtC4! Can I come with the next time you take one out? They will not let me play with C4 any more. :( Mike -- Washington DC’s low

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Patrick O'Callaghan
On Fri, 2009-05-29 at 23:37 +0100, Sharpe, Sam J wrote: 2009/5/29 Jussi Lehtola jussileht...@fedoraproject.org: Quoting Sharpe, Sam J sam.sharpe+lists.red...@gmail.com: 2009/5/29 Alan Cox a...@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Rick Stevens
Mikkel L. Ellertson wrote: Rick Stevens wrote: I generally take the drives out to the desert and use /sbin/detonate. As Jamie Hyneman once said on Mythbusters... When in doubtC4! Can I come with the next time you take one out? They will not let me play with C4 any more. :( Well,

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Sharpe, Sam J
2009/5/30 Mikkel L. Ellertson mik...@infinity-ltd.com: Rick Stevens wrote: I generally take the drives out to the desert and use /sbin/detonate. As Jamie Hyneman once said on Mythbusters...     When in doubtC4! Can I come with the next time you take one out? They will not let me play

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Sharpe, Sam J
2009/5/30 Patrick O'Callaghan pocallag...@gmail.com: On Fri, 2009-05-29 at 23:37 +0100, Sharpe, Sam J wrote: 2009/5/29 Jussi Lehtola jussileht...@fedoraproject.org: Quoting Sharpe, Sam J sam.sharpe+lists.red...@gmail.com: 2009/5/29 Alan Cox a...@lxorguk.ukuu.org.uk: 'shred' is part of

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Robert L Cochran
On 05/29/2009 05:44 PM, Alan Cox wrote: 'shred' is part of coreutils (i.e. installed by default). Doing something like shred /dev/sdX as root will write various bit patterns 25 times over the entire drive (see the man page for more options). Whoopeeedoo. Thats still not the correct way

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-29 Thread Robert L Cochran
is 'ha ha' because of suggestions, or aluminum rusting? I think the idea of dropping a hard drive in brine is funny. Hence the ha ha! if you have no need for drive and wish to insure removing all data, take drive apart, remove disk and burn oxide coating with a torch. or use lighter

OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-28 Thread Robert L Cochran
I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can write zeroes or some form of nonsense to every storage

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-28 Thread Sam Varshavchik
Robert L Cochran writes: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can write zeroes or some form of

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-28 Thread Arthur Pemberton
On Thu, May 28, 2009 at 9:29 PM, Robert L Cochran cochr...@speakeasy.net wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-28 Thread Clint Dilks
Sam Varshavchik wrote: Robert L Cochran writes: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can

Re: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-28 Thread Gene Heskett
On Thursday 28 May 2009, Robert L Cochran wrote: I have a hard drive that I need to destroy the data on. What is the most dependable way to do this? Can reformatting the drive as ext3 or ext4 or some other filesystem effectively destroy the existing data? Is there free software that can write

RE: OT: Can Reformatting A Hard Drive To ext3 Destroy All the Data On It?

2009-05-28 Thread Stuart Munro
Bob I have used this utility before with good success http://www.soft32.com/download_191651.html I have used this one with greater success http://www.killdisk.com/?gclid=CKatoNLX4JoCFQENDQodO0xTAQ both are free utilities -Original Message- From: fedora-list-boun...@redhat.com