Re: [fonc] Unsolved problem in computer science? Fixing shortcuts.

2014-10-09 Thread Daniel W Gelder
The original question seems to be how to maintain links when the file is moved or renamed. Perhaps the file could have a unique ID in the file system, and the link would try the given pathname, but if it's not there, try the unique ID. Would that work?

Re: [fonc] Unsolved problem in computer science? Fixing shortcuts.

2014-10-09 Thread Pascal J. Bourguignon
Daniel W Gelder daniel.w.gel...@gmail.com writes: The original question seems to be how to maintain links when the file is moved or renamed. Perhaps the file could have a unique ID in the file system, and the link would try the given pathname, but if it's not there, try the unique ID. Would

Re: [fonc] Unsolved problem in computer science? Fixing shortcuts.

2014-10-09 Thread John Carlson
We may want a program which unfortunately has a path to a shortcut to still work if the files they point to are moved. On Oct 9, 2014 7:56 PM, Pascal J. Bourguignon p...@informatimago.com wrote: Daniel W Gelder daniel.w.gel...@gmail.com writes: The original question seems to be how to

Re: [fonc] Unsolved problem in computer science? Fixing shortcuts.

2014-10-09 Thread Pascal J. Bourguignon
Josh McDonald j...@joshmcdonald.info writes: Why should links be in the filesystem, rather than an application / UI construct? For a lot of reasons. But the question is justified. - because it would be more modular and represent more code reuse, to factorize out the management of links